{"as_of":"2026-08-23T15:23:00Z","caps":{"database_statements":6,"inbound":100,"outbound":100},"context_digest":"sha256:a8bcf1cdf369277e94d016cf3a36a3fce66781f238d5634c878d2a31713bd54b","coverage":[{"denominator":30,"lane":"reference_resolution","note":"Typed states for the displayed outbound observations.","records_observed":30,"source":"paper_references, paper_reference_links","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.513547Z","state":"measured"},{"denominator":31,"lane":"standing_notices","note":"One-hop event checks from named stored sources.","records_observed":31,"source":"scholarly_work_events, retraction_status_cache","source_observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","state":"measured"},{"denominator":1,"lane":"inbound_itemization","note":"Pith citing papers itemized under the disclosed page cap.","records_observed":1,"source":"paper_references, paper_reference_links","source_observed_at":"2026-05-16T11:14:54.033663Z","state":"measured"},{"denominator":1,"lane":"external_citation_measurements","note":"A source-named dated measurement, never combined with another source.","records_observed":0,"source":"arxiv_reference","source_observed_at":"2026-05-16T11:17:47.168161Z","state":"measured"}],"external_citation_measurements":[],"inbound":[{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","doi":null,"metadata_source":"arxiv_reference","pith_arxiv_id":"1909.00393","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-06-05T21:23:00.469572Z","title":"Sukannya Purkayastha, Anne Lauscher, and Iryna Gurevych","venue":null,"work_id":"f0e37799-8eeb-4eac-a576-b523ebfcd9ce","year":1909},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2601.18081","last_updated":"2026-04-13T21:20:11Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-02T22:05:18.939377Z","submitted_at":"2026-01-26T02:30:01Z","title":"DRPG (Decompose, Retrieve, Plan, Generate): An Agentic Framework for Academic Rebuttal","version":2},"reference_index":6,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-05-16T11:14:54.033663Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/1909.00393","citing_paper":"/paper/2601.18081"},"observation_digest":"sha256:f508b05ad983369a4fe01058230822bb646f40db6f67b375ed30764df8748eb4","observation_id":"67e9a378-18a3-41a4-b0ad-3ae4ef2dd813","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-05-16T11:17:47.170631Z","resolver_source":"arxiv_id","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}}],"links":{"evidence":"/evidence","html":"/paper/1909.00393/citation-record","integrity":"/paper/1909.00393/integrity","json":"/paper/1909.00393/citation-record.json","paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"outbound":[{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:55.034228Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"367038ee-268b-408d-a667-71d45a411593","year":2019},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":1,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.380989Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:e1a0730ce5690ad53e7cefda738640bfaa4a791bbb64b13a7c160826a48ab4eb","observation_id":"7cae9e50-b53d-4213-84c4-729d95b0690b","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:55.039137Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:55.018728Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"39359171-ccda-4970-83e7-9ce5ca9af1ce","year":2017},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":2,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.386267Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:1ae085f37b8ef10fda4a6bc7427a1a2012334245fd7c3c7b74e8b943fbb0658c","observation_id":"8ad9ad1f-596f-42c6-b474-42f1370cdcea","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:55.023561Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:55.003370Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"f38d4abf-590d-4756-84bc-9f6af16ab119","year":1960},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":3,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.391028Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:fdb9ac0b2eaf5a4902d0662f9856d2e9b8fcf81ba6285765d2497cfd432a6b93","observation_id":"35a7b62e-09c5-42dc-86f4-d1ffed16f7d9","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:55.008018Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1810.04805","last_updated":"2019-05-24T20:37:26Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T18:16:28.847993Z","submitted_at":"2018-10-11T00:50:01Z","title":"BERT: Pre-training of Deep Bidirectional Transformers for Language Understanding","version":2},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":"1810.04805","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.396059Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2018},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":4,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.396059Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/1810.04805","citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:ed3d03b68aa43e18d1c096390b26ef34c1211071636227c5dd23feba97aea928","observation_id":"4ea6303d-cb3e-4c0a-8813-9380712d6ba1","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.396059Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.988979Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"75b46754-0541-40a1-8460-29577d317d49","year":1995},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":5,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.400921Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:090e3afaf9551051c7e71e75aca15058783b3f1c22baa52a2fb0819d64dd19f4","observation_id":"d0bf8cb0-6fc0-4b6e-9070-83516355a898","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.993641Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.405385Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2019},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":6,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.405385Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:05ef3e783a286f492d587e6598e2235308d9a18f44670b7b27913a723190cae9","observation_id":"259dc2cb-cc37-4c82-b52b-623ef57394fc","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.405385Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.410496Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2018},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":7,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.410496Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:a2dc2542092565f0c0473af7b9b3dee372db3c86b6e338f7ad5ba511a57ecb35","observation_id":"d64b4972-2800-4d2b-a20c-0b0b539e20c5","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.410496Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.963213Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"50557e3c-b349-403f-bea7-272a2bfb65ea","year":2013},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":8,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.414694Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:d8607df6545a5528411ad0f0ec50406e09d5597c473c775c9ccf9be444965c7a","observation_id":"55708d65-8f51-4bc2-93d4-351dc1841e67","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.968134Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1907.11889","last_updated":"2019-07-27T10:19:19Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-01T16:51:06.287369Z","submitted_at":"2019-07-27T10:19:19Z","title":"Towards Effective Rebuttal: Listening Comprehension using Corpus-Wide Claim Mining","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"1907.11889","doi":null,"metadata_source":"pith","pith_arxiv_id":"1907.11889","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.709482Z","title":"Towards Effective Rebuttal: Listening Comprehension using Corpus-Wide Claim Mining","venue":"cs.CL","work_id":"7c510dd8-234d-45d8-b1da-a090ffeba4f9","year":2019},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":9,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.419073Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/1907.11889","citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:eccb16477e5a85b882128342c379c52045d792b53e3edd771e79389f4c5884fc","observation_id":"c9e2284e-1031-4c0f-a8d1-bf278b45a8c9","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.714617Z","resolver_source":"local_arxiv","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1809.01984","last_updated":"2018-09-06T13:36:40Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T18:32:10.469714Z","submitted_at":"2018-09-06T13:36:40Z","title":"Training Millions of Personalized Dialogue Agents","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"1809.01984","doi":null,"metadata_source":"pith","pith_arxiv_id":"1809.01984","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.685657Z","title":"Training Millions of Personalized Dialogue Agents","venue":"cs.CL","work_id":"65331256-eb95-4617-9c15-4d1b9b153469","year":2018},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":10,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.423562Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/1809.01984","citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:d1a8f7dd078f56b51177b4428a588c0f1872ce15543fd1866da009f8a73b9b28","observation_id":"7bb282c9-35a7-4cae-9403-3f9c12f606df","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.692827Z","resolver_source":"local_arxiv","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1301.3781","last_updated":"2013-09-07T00:30:40Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T03:04:11.148340Z","submitted_at":"2013-01-16T18:24:43Z","title":"Efficient Estimation of Word Representations in Vector Space","version":3},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":"1301.3781","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.428098Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2013},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":11,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.428098Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/1301.3781","citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:e262012f5c37e783b1cff0b6053ba4547fa04e3751080704378a0ae44305f919","observation_id":"6f8554d2-0633-4d71-a728-002dada46c59","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.428098Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.948348Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"7de9f066-f5e5-4240-9180-c275669ecebf","year":2018},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":12,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.432796Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:10b45383c8a1ef13c64df7febb3c19166d61ec4922d7c1fe0356d1f9fa5c3d96","observation_id":"efcca508-218f-4bf7-8dca-b5d4473a7122","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.953076Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.933509Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"6e769f4b-cc40-4c80-94e5-02574234d672","year":2017},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":13,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.437319Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:8fe6a29c7ea50ad2a374f98a6ba381923ba72dc5390dbec4241bd5a0395dc470","observation_id":"9da82f65-fd0b-4ff1-9962-25d3af836c8a","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.938625Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.918634Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"b2754605-458f-405d-9af0-304fd7f75960","year":2015},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":14,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.441618Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:50e571fa21d811d54cf40c5af0b5166b4b7c33dde5b122e2d2608c1679c6eeff","observation_id":"00abfd02-bcb6-49bf-ae06-6f3b0fa76bd1","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.923220Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.903820Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"6108a50c-0b8a-4a85-9ad7-589693b15d5e","year":2015},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":15,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.445982Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:505417b536e8124670ad473262c25773890e1360b146741ffb5214e00ec94a98","observation_id":"e2d9a6e9-5e37-4a82-b590-e6db880ba955","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.908594Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.888596Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"9d8af8d7-2b09-4ebd-b2c9-9d9128da9c11","year":2011},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":16,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.450241Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:bccdbedda5242880762b12b116aa0024a28036a0cd4156e8c0990ba142dcf3be","observation_id":"d5c3e10b-0061-4685-9e94-560e96be35e2","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.893355Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.873718Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"0f003493-8260-41b5-bbb4-1b96827db943","year":2015},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":17,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.454636Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:3e17b980c31053d81c0bf97bf718e8619ba3878213afae527a924f332abeb2ad","observation_id":"45c5ea54-24dc-4618-9467-6015cb342220","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.878429Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.857760Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"7727bad9-c9a0-4993-aa0c-c8528131a30e","year":2015},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":18,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.459181Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:39eabe5cbb1cbe2065b5169aa52b1d84cc60f6e6267c735f9a065b44d9a07031","observation_id":"7f18bdce-12a5-4579-a2f9-15a6bf86835a","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.863100Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.841698Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"9f183a80-3a99-4106-a860-89bbb00f8154","year":2015},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":19,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.463342Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:18c45498deafb5a4ea296c6c0ef365b9baeaa163d8cfdc22ecb5d8ec9feb6f34","observation_id":"58876ab4-c957-413e-9676-b1feafb3a29a","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.846558Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.826563Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"1b514a4c-d849-4c8c-a985-0470d77c8751","year":2013},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":20,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.467973Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:b78f25b716cc27e87d97cd3ac3ae2631fdfd5abe8e47288ee818c25068046e67","observation_id":"12a7e123-4596-4b50-906c-b10f8eb4e579","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.831170Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.472346Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2018},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":21,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.472346Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:e585720425a0730b0476cef4b421c80d377fba35f734b345a0f6879e3e526df8","observation_id":"1060970d-dc9c-46a9-b742-9a434d250330","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.472346Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.811472Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"7ae68a38-1c7b-4e6f-a471-97978b8e925c","year":2012},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":22,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.476723Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:803a740d980f0df5937d8c4eb41175bdb1f7247fb1de1d1e59616d2381a7c79e","observation_id":"2610b92b-7428-4d6a-895d-df4e31a256eb","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.816243Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.480987Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":1966},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":23,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.480987Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:f09ca314ce35cdd98083997d6aa05a7cb1e5d7204df8ff56e63df0dfbfe7a2c4","observation_id":"2560d117-686d-4f61-a9b2-4c96b61f29ef","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.480987Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1604.04562","last_updated":"2017-04-24T10:55:12Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T22:01:30.182934Z","submitted_at":"2016-04-15T16:40:49Z","title":"A Network-based End-to-End Trainable Task-oriented Dialogue System","version":3},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":"1604.04562","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.485399Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2016},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":24,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.485399Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/1604.04562","citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:88b7dc5a7c9f037f12bfe2608ba50f649777eef859d70a793a7150c22f03568a","observation_id":"0ade34f2-0c42-4770-9df2-0f3d792e3443","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.485399Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.796691Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"aed70930-7131-4de2-bf0a-37d29bda8813","year":2017},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":25,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.489964Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:b4ee5e757dd4eb626073ba9cefda43d5984c9e5c9b6f23535442aa593495704b","observation_id":"190df967-7fe5-4b26-83b6-8229cc5f308a","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.801433Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.781817Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"e1a6f93b-4ff3-4745-996b-936794acda6b","year":2016},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":26,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.494415Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:22a32142a234ab95fdbd2aae5317463877b08723a3220d46202b94137aadba56","observation_id":"7300afc9-6341-4eb4-90c0-fe176f68323e","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.786458Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.498759Z","title":"URL: \" 'urlintro :=","venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":null},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":27,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.498759Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:4d79984f51fe2f5ae3be6614e138f618879c8ea8081e3c3a6bcf2b84c17386ca","observation_id":"a9bdeba2-1ba0-4123-a54f-02a8c35d6ab3","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.498759Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.503661Z","title":"write newline","venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":null},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":28,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.503661Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:d3d576f10c86122757eded0a920d08be7048a0a829a3997ba09a49fcc045ed19","observation_id":"fce7028d-490f-4d21-bb6b-0594a63e2242","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.503661Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.508705Z","title":", \" * write output.state after.block = add.period write newline","venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":null},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":29,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.508705Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:ac35ce39f346dc658269e6b1866b5b1838aaef479a7f02936b2196b952cfbc86","observation_id":"185d6814-16a9-462d-81d3-5b4748332930","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.508705Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.513547Z","title":"write newline","venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":null},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal","version":1},"reference_index":30,"source":"arxiv_source","source_observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.513547Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/1909.00393"},"observation_digest":"sha256:a19d64d3520833a2335d6a0628f61c788558bb977375ec97ff2f51418d95e230","observation_id":"7133ecdb-857d-462b-9ac2-a18f8b83f3d4","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-14T05:57:54.513547Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}}],"paper":{"arxiv_id":"1909.00393","last_updated":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","latest_version":1,"primary_category":"cs.CL","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-20T16:43:27.921101Z","submitted_at":"2019-09-01T13:24:35Z","title":"A Dataset of General-Purpose Rebuttal"},"reference_resolution":{"displayed":30,"state_counts":{"malformed_identifier":0,"metadata_mismatch":0,"parse_uncertain":0,"unresolved":28,"verified_exact":2,"verified_fuzzy":0},"total_outbound_references":30},"refusal":"A citation records a reference. It does not transfer a finding from one paper to another.","schema":"pith.paper-citation-record.v1","standing_sources":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:58.430688+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-23T06:30:53.778098+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"thesis":"As of 23 August 2026, this Paper Citation Record lists 30 of 30 outbound references and 1 inbound Pith citation observation for arXiv:1909.00393."}