{"as_of":"2026-08-09T17:17:00Z","caps":{"database_statements":6,"inbound":100,"outbound":100},"context_digest":"sha256:0592f02ffae3294db100dd5dd1097e67566640754f6200a19e81be30338464d1","coverage":[{"denominator":27,"lane":"reference_resolution","note":"Typed states for the displayed outbound observations.","records_observed":27,"source":"paper_references, paper_reference_links","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.014833Z","state":"measured"},{"denominator":29,"lane":"standing_notices","note":"One-hop event checks from named stored sources.","records_observed":29,"source":"scholarly_work_events, retraction_status_cache","source_observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","state":"measured"},{"denominator":2,"lane":"inbound_itemization","note":"Pith citing papers itemized under the disclosed page cap.","records_observed":2,"source":"paper_references, paper_reference_links","source_observed_at":"2026-08-03T14:27:22.905645Z","state":"measured"},{"denominator":1,"lane":"external_citation_measurements","note":"A source-named dated measurement, never combined with another source.","records_observed":1,"source":"pith","source_observed_at":"2026-08-05T02:28:24.338817Z","state":"measured"}],"external_citation_measurements":[{"count":0,"observed_at":"2026-08-05T02:28:24.338817Z","source":"pith"}],"inbound":[{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","doi":"10.48550/arxiv.2508.01547","metadata_source":"pith","pith_arxiv_id":"2508.01547","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-05T02:49:54.815029Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","venue":"cs.HC","work_id":"cfa58db0-aa22-4e9a-b10a-69c05cab546d","year":2025},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2512.20306","last_updated":"2026-06-11T14:58:39Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-03T15:50:08.919368Z","submitted_at":"2025-12-23T12:17:10Z","title":"Structured Visualization Design Knowledge for Grounding Generative Reasoning and Situated Feedback","version":3},"reference_index":2025,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-03T14:27:22.905645Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2508.01547","citing_paper":"/paper/2512.20306"},"observation_digest":"sha256:de8f2b3b035b840364ac19ca6d1f2fd6d6a64c3bfa227d5c0ee9656753688c6a","observation_id":"d00156fc-cd42-483e-8e37-0457718de9d6","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-03T14:29:01.200385Z","resolver_source":"local_arxiv","status":"metadata_mismatch"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":"2508.01547","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-14T14:28:29.626547Z","title":"Ahn and N","venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2025},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2607.09938","last_updated":"2026-07-10T19:40:51Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T05:53:39.890991Z","submitted_at":"2026-07-10T19:40:51Z","title":"\"Code Is Cheap. Show Me the Talk.\": Lessons from Teaching and Managing AI Coding Tool Usage in a Visualization Course","version":1},"reference_index":3,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-07-14T14:28:29.626547Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2508.01547","citing_paper":"/paper/2607.09938"},"observation_digest":"sha256:07f8d5956f8e60fcb0c096aaaf00384e61ea06bf79a675414de81bc4319d17a8","observation_id":"526b0a91-f963-4adf-a9eb-728dd2f1a194","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-07-14T14:28:29.626547Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"malformed_identifier"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}}],"links":{"evidence":"/evidence","html":"/paper/2508.01547/citation-record","integrity":"/paper/2508.01547/integrity","json":"/paper/2508.01547/citation-record.json","paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"outbound":[{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.803398Z","title":"Accessed on Sep 9, 2023","venue":null,"work_id":"a13d21d2-261c-463a-af51-f4c4b405aeb3","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":1,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.884727Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:f5634c3c42f356baf555fb5024e792bb1e3f366fa6e92f75650e4cfe0ca62ef7","observation_id":"eb9390cf-4d1f-4a5a-9f18-6e002625a4fb","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.809500Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.785226Z","title":"Ahmad, C","venue":null,"work_id":"6a6018d9-a100-4ea1-8d67-c90db2ee546b","year":2018},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":2,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.889962Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:73e9004d1ffb8f4c55a0398511c6ca5f22a5daac77ba0c860cb035c96e42aabb","observation_id":"e48fcd4c-e86c-48fd-8736-27b2c1c4b73d","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.791472Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.766463Z","title":"Alexander, P","venue":null,"work_id":"fe1accdb-eed0-4b2d-820f-2b7ce393c89c","year":2024},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":3,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.894869Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:366e189e41b627cace4b2d3c1037c62673b5dd6864b3e3e3797b08e35992be1a","observation_id":"1d07e3b1-9e55-4e18-894d-86dba57f45e1","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.773126Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.748770Z","title":"Awasthi, S","venue":null,"work_id":"8264806c-b410-47e4-ac02-766b583bc3c9","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":4,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.900155Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:6a073230ba71994611e19cc557e6d7cfbc60dd7449211248422ac9aa758e8f54","observation_id":"4be70606-a0d0-4f91-922a-53c5672f6efe","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.754725Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.730878Z","title":"Barua, S","venue":null,"work_id":"396c0a87-f428-4a2d-b6ea-f1310eba848a","year":2014},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":5,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.905293Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:dc77f54f871a2ca36f9df2dfd8dde7e368c4bcedfbcf9f413be4aa650f177d8b","observation_id":"e88eb262-79ad-4871-a895-8d0ed78cba37","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.735954Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.712606Z","title":"Bendeck and J","venue":null,"work_id":"4913be16-a405-4d80-9943-39cc41cdc3b6","year":2024},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":6,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.910897Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:726bdaa871862eab19ef4143441b583cd332b794927f776597bc7c3b0d89854d","observation_id":"02100efc-14fc-4744-b11a-ac48f8d67eab","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.718724Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.692544Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"db07da72-c987-409b-a469-cd926a24a11e","year":2024},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":7,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.916834Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:2ad678ead2449f88b58627a34e0957b6921749b71973b21b89b7cf74548b279d","observation_id":"51fe9723-d1bf-4246-b54d-f50076e9609a","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.699552Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.921639Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":8,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.921639Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:29f55650a80806d7d0c61e6f71f6eb664658043c457b09bb9eb65a54f8b17205","observation_id":"f0d08807-858c-4da9-b5d7-233d8b98a957","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.921639Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.670380Z","title":"Diehl, A","venue":null,"work_id":"c266d20f-ddb3-4ea2-a52a-01f4a57e6f87","year":2018},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":9,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.926908Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:60fe36319f66ae0df593a76e0d54ebe83eff7bdf1849d9d1e918dc13eddd11bb","observation_id":"7a4d6b5c-64ef-4485-8e69-6071bd941eaf","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.678829Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"malformed_identifier"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":"10.1075/idj.22004.est","metadata_source":"doi_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.049082Z","title":"i learned it on the job","venue":null,"work_id":"3436855e-239a-464d-8abb-ecc9cd2db9c1","year":2022},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":10,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.931534Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:fbe3c5677ff59cd4344afebc2d6d810492eae11711961d171a73872d95dde205","observation_id":"2c393555-6179-48f9-b6e8-81e1557ab5bd","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.055595Z","resolver_source":"doi","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.651011Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"166e55a6-39fc-4b52-b42d-626cfa7afa0a","year":2015},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":11,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.936656Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:29c6e09328116e2750d7746b96838f0b3e36683d7ec9b733644f959f56a7fdf8","observation_id":"9f0241b7-d00a-4268-8a6f-ba88f93bfce9","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.657413Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2310.09617","last_updated":"2025-05-19T08:12:29Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T20:28:06.526638Z","submitted_at":"2023-10-14T16:45:29Z","title":"How Good is ChatGPT in Giving Advice on Your Visualization Design?","version":5},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2310.09617","doi":null,"metadata_source":"pith","pith_arxiv_id":"2310.09617","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.291461Z","title":"How Good is ChatGPT in Giving Advice on Your Visualization Design?","venue":"cs.HC","work_id":"d9c47b2f-4780-475c-83ab-65739e38b7db","year":2023},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":12,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.941498Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2310.09617","citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:2c0bae869163396a13c42e81ddaa476601337e1ac03baaa39d97d9a5204778ab","observation_id":"33acce8a-c115-4ba2-abc9-b440445d2da8","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.299958Z","resolver_source":"local_arxiv","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.630629Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"74551b6b-bd68-404c-a9cf-312ff70e8b08","year":2015},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":13,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.946414Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:4e12ae3239b362a4eafa01dbcf0777d3f34d2146efac5ceaa5b20489f5d5bbb5","observation_id":"29d6fd80-0e15-4d89-ae03-ed8a9ea42e59","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.638197Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2211.09110","last_updated":"2023-10-01T21:44:23Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-01T19:14:56.803459Z","submitted_at":"2022-11-16T18:51:34Z","title":"Holistic Evaluation of Language Models","version":2},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":"2211.09110","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.950976Z","title":"Liang, R","venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2022},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":14,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.950976Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2211.09110","citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:7757ffc7ea23d23fa8fc144f34dbefb6dc891964cbb9a93caa5a44a35ea38af8","observation_id":"7a4dd1aa-6409-4573-9471-c56681a8e309","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.950976Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.610378Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"34d4487d-b718-48df-a9eb-c5865f9248d4","year":2024},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":15,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.957661Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:e95217e7f463b87f111bc3ab29bab920f509934d08a24e509b5a0635e9d22361","observation_id":"9c518768-c769-499d-86e8-e457af2a1aae","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.617769Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":null,"pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.962279Z","title":"Luther, J.-L","venue":null,"work_id":null,"year":2015},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":16,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.962279Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:7f3711203ceb29a46562298b2253c0d844cb5314fea77fab7f208403acd61532","observation_id":"ddfadda8-b25d-4eb3-94fe-2b57ceec3bfb","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.962279Z","resolver_source":null,"status":"malformed_identifier"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"reason":"canonical_work_link_unavailable","source_receipts":[],"state":"unavailable"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.590650Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"5b60f69a-5305-42c2-b6d6-9873cdfbc930","year":2009},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":17,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.966721Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:dc148cfa3f3f9df3967a51ab616bbdce7de1f998eab8e304e3ef42a931c1f044","observation_id":"9de3fb36-5aa5-44a5-a1a4-985194ea22e1","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.597011Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.570114Z","title":"Naderi, S","venue":null,"work_id":"90c25bf8-d266-43d3-bd31-458e4abcd558","year":2020},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":18,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.971467Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:4a9ebcd68001d5c1be917558c4019fc1fad8a4bdd8a2ffa9b9aa1e1b813add63","observation_id":"bb480075-9875-47f4-806e-555712d16ded","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.576735Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.550655Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"f131f722-f314-4a8d-b644-964533460c89","year":null},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":19,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.977187Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:5c14a241ac2c38429bf6b08f75e5b0a50982af1af4ddae7ad211963905eec911","observation_id":"a5fff819-9001-43e5-b9e4-922a00ffc4fd","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.557309Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2021.31149","doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.166572Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"aa1765ab-b2d6-42e0-b79f-78f186ce9352","year":2022},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":20,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.982186Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:19369932c9d5c1c1dd63bfe2e4dedde91a0c705790d18a08fb19ad5f739047e0","observation_id":"fd885b43-d668-4c15-801a-28a2d1ab0f1a","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.176306Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"metadata_mismatch"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.526940Z","title":"Shah and J","venue":null,"work_id":"8114df2e-f980-4dbf-9962-bf97eafe8201","year":2010},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":21,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.987219Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:a4a3d2d481ae9bb8dd72f8a09195ef67975cb68edf9b0e646e7a2430fcd8e9bf","observation_id":"ebcb01f6-ecc1-4a30-a8a6-eef552d1e159","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.536745Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2404.03820","last_updated":"2024-06-21T13:57:11Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-07-06T17:55:53.304768Z","submitted_at":"2024-04-04T22:31:58Z","title":"CantTalkAboutThis: Aligning Language Models to Stay on Topic in Dialogues","version":2},"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":"2404.03820","doi":null,"metadata_source":"pith","pith_arxiv_id":"2404.03820","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.075858Z","title":"CantTalkAboutThis: Aligning Language Models to Stay on Topic in Dialogues","venue":"cs.CL","work_id":"4875264b-43e6-46d7-8bad-f1eb760f4451","year":2024},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":22,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.991650Z"},"links":{"cited_paper":"/paper/2404.03820","citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:2e8a166e3f7517d0d4c419a295e08854f18b9cf7cf219cfb395716a51a02cf32","observation_id":"0c03162b-2e85-4ecd-b4b1-2186eb671679","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.081897Z","resolver_source":"local_arxiv","status":"verified_exact"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.501460Z","title":"Van der Lee, A","venue":null,"work_id":"c8d1bd29-bee2-4780-a8c9-35b101156622","year":2021},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":23,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:16.996315Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:f5f56c740b299f9effcb8af8ab57695af6556445be9cbf08f3a90fe05cc2cf99","observation_id":"5193826c-7941-4422-9e00-c1c0dd21a7e7","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.511070Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.477767Z","title":"Van Miltenburg, D","venue":null,"work_id":"3debf3f5-fbda-430b-b1cd-fd3ccd2d3b63","year":null},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":24,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.000879Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:562df237567adbf41342084cbcd0d8df9947c68a1cb33a4e1ccae679c8fc7cfb","observation_id":"c32b2aa2-f7d6-4704-8916-d2245add6ccf","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.487033Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.427333Z","title":null,"venue":null,"work_id":"9aede010-63b5-410d-bc9b-46550e641d42","year":null},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":26,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.010300Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:84149b15da42237bc55512a5bbaa5ebb3dcf40f2dff07a39a57de6a22fa15b9f","observation_id":"64f4e5dc-bb60-419a-8529-ea280dc15653","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.434857Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"unresolved"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.398606Z","title":"As an output, present a list of pairs of visualization advice:(advice_title, advice_description, L1, L2, L3 (keyword), evidence) with the references of Taxonomy in a json format","venue":null,"work_id":"f6c537a8-d285-49bd-9e85-c88c37f23cbd","year":null},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":27,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.014833Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:c626b2018a0f9f5cd85d70bb85c54cd82ed1d1deabacf83af157d25c2f7c7e6c","observation_id":"e2839e32-079a-4bd7-adcc-d56c8ffce5a6","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.409558Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}},{"citation":{"cited_paper":null,"cited_work":{"arxiv_id":null,"doi":null,"metadata_source":"raw_reference","pith_arxiv_id":null,"snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.455331Z","title":"Expand the L3 keyword set to improve coverage and enable the detection of visualization-related concepts within text","venue":null,"work_id":"527ab269-d8c3-4eed-a0c5-7b15874884b4","year":null},"citing_paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice","version":1},"reference_index":2018,"source":"pdf_text","source_observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.005582Z"},"links":{"citing_paper":"/paper/2508.01547"},"observation_digest":"sha256:e67170f8666689d3adc71d8234357f1bd3fd8506354102c7076bcd130eb309b6","observation_id":"52a7cc45-2afc-494a-9322-72036b108bd2","resolution":{"observed_at":"2026-08-06T05:41:17.463478Z","resolver_source":"raw_fallback","status":"verified_fuzzy"},"standing_notice":{"events":[],"observation":"No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00.","reason":null,"source_receipts":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"state":"measured"}}],"paper":{"arxiv_id":"2508.01547","last_updated":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","latest_version":1,"primary_category":"cs.HC","snapshot_observed_at":"2026-08-08T08:03:07.806435Z","submitted_at":"2025-08-03T02:14:00Z","title":"Understanding Why ChatGPT Outperforms Humans in Visualization Design Advice"},"reference_resolution":{"displayed":27,"state_counts":{"malformed_identifier":2,"metadata_mismatch":1,"parse_uncertain":0,"unresolved":9,"verified_exact":3,"verified_fuzzy":12},"total_outbound_references":27},"refusal":"A citation records a reference. It does not transfer a finding from one paper to another.","schema":"pith.paper-citation-record.v1","standing_sources":[{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:31:02.800959+00:00","source":"crossref"},{"observed_at":"2026-08-09T06:30:57.326959+00:00","source":"retraction_watch"}],"thesis":"As of 9 August 2026, this Paper Citation Record lists 27 of 27 outbound references and 2 inbound Pith citation observations for arXiv:2508.01547."}