REVIEW 7 cited by
Inference of the optical depth to reionization from low multipole temperature and polarisation Planck data
Not yet reviewed by Pith; the record is open.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet. Machine review is queued; the pith claim, tier, and objections will appear here once it completes.
SPECIMEN: schema-true, not a live event
T0 review · schema-true
One-sentence machine reading of the paper's core claim.
pith:XXXXXXXX · record.json · timestamp
Signed reviews
read the original abstract
This paper explores methods for constructing low multipole temperature and polarisation likelihoods from maps of the cosmic microwave background anisotropies that have complex noise properties and partial sky coverage. We use Planck 2018 High Frequency Instrument (HFI) and updated SRoll2 temperature and polarisation maps to test our methods. We present three likelihood approximations based on quadratic cross spectrum estimators: (i) a variant of the simulation-based likelihood (SimBaL) techniques used in the Planck legacy papers to produce a low multipole EE likelihood; (ii) a semi-analytical likelihood approximation (momento) based on the principle of maximum entropy; (iii) a density-estimation `likelihood-free' scheme (DELFI). Approaches (ii) and (iii) can be generalised to produce low multipole joint temperature-polarisation (TTTEEE) likelihoods. We present extensive tests of these methods on simulations with realistic correlated noise. We then analyse the Planck data and confirm the robustness of our method and likelihoods on multiple inter- and intra-frequency detector set combinations of SRoll2 maps. The three likelihood techniques give consistent results and support a low value of the optical depth to reoinization, tau, from the HFI. Our best estimate of tau comes from combining the low multipole SRoll2 momento (TTTEEE) likelihood with the CamSpec high multipole likelihood and is tau = 0.0627+0.0050-0.0058. This is consistent with the SRoll2 team's determination of tau, though slightly higher by 0.5 sigma, mainly because of our joint treatment of temperature and polarisation.
Forward citations
Cited by 7 Pith papers
-
Boosting the optical depth to Thomson scattering with primordial black hole evaporation at high redshift
A monochromatic primordial black hole population can raise the CMB optical depth by at most Delta tau ~ 0.008 under current CMB data, leaving BAO-CMB tensions essentially unchanged.
-
Ringing of the Reionization: A first direct measurement of the intergalactic pressure smoothing scale at redshift z>4.2 as imprinted onto small-scale peculiar velocities in the Lyman-alpha forest
A claimed first direct measurement of the IGM pressure smoothing scale at z≈4.2–5.0 from a fitted peak in the Lyman-alpha flux power spectrum, tied to an acoustic feature in the peculiar velocity gradient.
-
Cosmological Concordance in an Especially Opaque Universe: A Tentative Cosmological Detection of Physical Neutrino Mass in $\Lambda$CDM
Imposing a high prior on τ = 0.11 ± 0.006 produces a 2σ positive neutrino mass sum of 0.10 eV and restores concordance between CMB and DESI data inside ΛCDM.
-
Cosmology from Planck CMB Lensing and DESI DR1 Quasar Tomography
DESI DR1 quasars cross-correlated with Planck PR4 lensing give sigma8 = 0.929 and S8 = 0.922, about 1.5 sigma above Planck's LCDM prediction, and a sound-horizon-free H0 = 69.1 km/s/Mpc.
-
Cosmological implications of DESI DR2 BAO measurements in light of the latest ACT DR6 CMB data
Adding ACT DR6 data to DESI DR2 BAO keeps the roughly 3 sigma preference for evolving dark energy and, for the baseline Planck+ACT combination, reports a neutrino mass limit below 0.061 eV.
-
The Impact of Population III.1 Flash Reionization for CMB Polarization and Thomson Scattering Optical Depth
An early 'Pop III.1 Flash' reionization phase shifts CMB polarization power from l<8 to l>8, allowing a higher optical depth τ≈0.08–0.09 while staying closer to Planck's low-l EE data than a standard tanh reionization model.
-
Late Time Dynamical Dark Energy and the CMB-Distance Ladder Tension
The SNIa absolute-magnitude tension between the distance ladder (−19.204) and CMB+ΛCDM (−19.430) is independent of late-time expansion history, and DESI's w0–wa dark-energy hints shift H0 by only ~0.3–0.4 km/s/Mpc.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.