Paper Citation Record · LEDGER

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon

As of 13 August 2026, this Paper Citation Record lists 22 of 22 outbound references and 2 inbound Pith citation observations for arXiv:2505.21602.

A citation records a reference. It does not transfer a finding from one paper to another.

pith.paper-citation-record.v1
2505.21602 v1

Coverage vector

measured 22 of 22 reference resolution

Typed states for the displayed outbound observations.

Source: paper_references, paper_reference_links, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:17.300884Z

measured 24 of 24 standing notices

One-hop event checks from named stored sources.

Source: scholarly_work_events, retraction_status_cache, observed 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00

measured 2 of 2 inbound itemization

Pith citing papers itemized under the disclosed page cap.

Source: paper_references, paper_reference_links, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:15.466444Z

measured 0 of 1 external citation measurements

A source-named dated measurement, never combined with another source.

Source: arxiv_reference, observed 2026-07-04T05:59:36.824054Z

Reference resolution

22 of 22 outbound references displayed

verified exact1
verified fuzzy9
unresolved12
parse uncertain0
malformed identifier0
metadata mismatch0

External citation measurements

No source-named external measurement is stored.

Outbound references

Observation 0e712636-74ee-4776-977c-49ce869f9b4b · outbound

This paper cites Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon

Reference 1

Resolution: unresolved; no resolver link, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:15.466444Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

Unavailable: canonical work link unavailable.

Observation 1fefbbb7-7c84-4505-aade-1ab67833da6a · outbound

This paper cites relevant in the RG sense.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon relevant in the RG sense

Reference 2

Resolution: verified fuzzy; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:21.190276Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation 81a5b6ed-812a-4137-b434-c591eeca4644 · outbound

This paper cites (3) with respect to time, yields time-non-local con- tributions to linear order inθ0 in the transformations of ∂xθ and ∂xθ (see Eq.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon (3) with respect to time, yields time-non-local con- tributions to linear order inθ0 in the transformations of ∂xθ and ∂xθ (see Eq

Reference 3

Resolution: verified fuzzy; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:20.940724Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation ca63651a-0b23-473c-b4ae-618140d07120 · outbound

This paper cites • We reiterate that we cannot calculate the exponents for either the immortal flock or the Malthusian flock analytically.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon • We reiterate that we cannot calculate the exponents for either the immortal flock or the Malthusian flock analytically

Reference 4

Resolution: verified fuzzy; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:20.701589Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation 20c20cb6-5eec-4f8c-aa37-55c0c2a62fdd · outbound

This paper cites Chaté and A.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Chaté and A

Reference 5

Resolution: verified fuzzy; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:20.464750Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation b87bcfb8-7d8e-4d26-91f6-d78c159e7e03 · outbound

This paper cites Comment on "The inconvenient truth about flocks" by Chen et al.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Comment on "The inconvenient truth about flocks" by Chen et al

Reference 6

Resolution: unresolved; no resolver link, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:15.850721Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

Unavailable: canonical work link unavailable.

Observation d68f1952-656d-46c2-9bfe-b3789eba8f53 · outbound

This paper cites The inconvenient truth about flocks.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon The inconvenient truth about flocks

Reference 7

Resolution: unresolved; no resolver link, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:15.942619Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

Unavailable: canonical work link unavailable.

Observation 36d3a1a3-ae47-49db-b40e-a31ac5cf8661 · outbound

This paper cites an unresolved cited work.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Unresolved cited work

Reference 8

Resolution: unresolved; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:20.289813Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation f216d3da-e132-4ccf-83ea-6596bd9e45b7 · outbound

This paper cites Forster, Physical Review Letters32, 1161 (1974).

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Forster, Physical Review Letters32, 1161 (1974)

Reference 9

Resolution: verified fuzzy; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:20.107354Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation fc95f87b-656b-4f1f-a8d3-ac5a29ff39f6 · outbound

This paper cites Stark and T.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Stark and T

Reference 10

Resolution: verified fuzzy; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:19.906816Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation 2c4ed7dd-2076-4f91-9328-dcbb1d27286c · outbound

This paper cites De Gennes and J.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon De Gennes and J

Reference 11

Resolution: unresolved; no resolver link, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:16.273531Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

Unavailable: canonical work link unavailable.

Observation 25a956da-26f4-4073-a8a8-32cd3eb458a1 · outbound

This paper cites an unresolved cited work.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Unresolved cited work

Reference 12

Resolution: unresolved; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:19.694326Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation ca766e86-b82a-4e28-85cd-6b6ed238947d · outbound

This paper cites Solon, H.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Solon, H

Reference 13

Resolution: verified fuzzy; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:19.464853Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation 899941e1-07a2-401b-a7f8-4b092e8906cc · outbound

This paper cites Inescapable anisotropy of non-reciprocal XY models.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Inescapable anisotropy of non-reciprocal XY models

Reference 14

Resolution: verified exact; local_arxiv, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:17.477600Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation bb8c4b41-3a31-4c5c-88fe-1f8e734cefe8 · outbound

This paper cites an unresolved cited work.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Unresolved cited work

Reference 15

Resolution: unresolved; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:19.208352Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation c993b560-31de-4c65-9ece-0fe6250c9f9d · outbound

This paper cites Low and A.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Low and A

Reference 16

Resolution: verified fuzzy; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:18.931289Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation 96925c03-f244-437b-b717-0a777086dc95 · outbound

This paper cites an unresolved cited work.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Unresolved cited work

Reference 17

Resolution: unresolved; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:18.640529Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation b0277999-6818-484e-aac5-86c1c448d4af · outbound

This paper cites Jentsch and C.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Jentsch and C

Reference 18

Resolution: unresolved; no resolver link, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:17.005747Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

Unavailable: canonical work link unavailable.

Observation b9d84aa2-284d-418d-8a59-8a3dd07065aa · outbound

This paper cites an unresolved cited work.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Unresolved cited work

Reference 19

Resolution: unresolved; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:18.335147Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation 9aa65c31-9dd9-4f28-9cb6-7a7be1db9c46 · outbound

This paper cites an unresolved cited work.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Unresolved cited work

Reference 20

Resolution: unresolved; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:18.030402Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Observation efd26499-a634-4fc3-9627-f025d919b490 · outbound

This paper cites Toner, The Physics of Flocking: Birth, Death, and Flight in Active Matter (Cambridge University Press, 2024).

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Toner, The Physics of Flocking: Birth, Death, and Flight in Active Matter (Cambridge University Press, 2024)

Reference 21

Resolution: unresolved; no resolver link, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:17.225926Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

Unavailable: canonical work link unavailable.

Observation 21aa485b-a998-4570-bc17-02f06ecd08fa · outbound

This paper cites Mahault, F.

Response to the comment on The inconvenient truth about flocks by Chat\'e and Solon Mahault, F

Reference 22

Resolution: verified fuzzy; raw_fallback, observed 2026-08-07T13:40:17.820452Z

Source-reported events for the cited work

No event found in the named queried sources as of 2026-08-13T06:32:02.005865+00:00.

Pith citing papers

Observation 0e712636-74ee-4776-977c-49ce869f9b4b · inbound