Pith. sign in

REVIEW 2 major objections 4 minor 75 references

Interface-sensitive microwave loss in superconducting tantalum films sputtered on c-plane sapphire

T0 review · 2 major / 4 minor · reviewed 2026-08-11 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗ Review JSON

Pith's one-line read Microwave loss in epitaxial tantalum films on c-plane sapphire originates at the tantalum/sapphire interface, and can be eliminated by inserting a niobium interlayer or damaging the sapphire surface.

desk verdict Genuinely useful experimental paper showing the epitaxial Ta/sapphire interface is a major microwave loss source, with causal language slightly ahead of the evidence. read the letter →

arxiv 2412.16730 v2 pith:QXDIWN75 submitted 2024-12-21 quant-ph cond-mat.mtrl-sci

Anthony P. McFadden , Jinsu Oh , Lin Zhou , Trevyn F.Q. Larson , Stephen Gill , Akash V. Dixit , Raymond Simmonds , Florent Lecocq This is my paper · ORCID
classification quant-phcond-mat.mtrl-sci
keywords tantalumthinfilmsmicrowavelossc-planesapphireepitaxialinterfacesuperconductingresonatorstwo-levelsystemsniobiuminterlayerqubitmaterials
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

This paper claims that the poor microwave performance of high-quality epitaxial α-phase tantalum films on c-plane sapphire is caused by the epitaxial Ta/sapphire interface itself, not by the film's bulk quality, surface roughness, or ordinary two-level-system losses. The evidence comes from a systematic growth-temperature study: epitaxial Ta(111) films have excellent structural and DC electrical properties, yet their resonator quality factors are roughly 60 times lower than comparable Nb films. By controlling the nucleation interface, the paper shows that inserting a thin epitaxial Nb interlayer or deliberately damaging the sapphire surface with argon plasma restores high quality factors. This identifies a specific, controllable material interface as the loss source and offers practical steps for fabricating low-loss tantalum superconducting circuits.

What carries the argument

The experimental control is a three-way sample comparison: epitaxial α-Ta(111) grown directly on c-plane sapphire (Sample A), on a 5-nm epitaxial Nb(111) interlayer (Sample B), and on sapphire deliberately disordered by an in-situ argon plasma (Sample C). Because Nb films of nearly identical structure are low-loss and the Ta films in Samples A and B have nearly identical XRD, roughness, resistivity, Tc, and RRR, the only systematic difference is the Ta/sapphire interface; the ~60x Qi difference therefore localizes the loss to that interface. The measurement chain is narrow-gap (6/3 µm) CPW resonators at low photon occupation, with the diameter-correction method used to extract internal quality factor.

What would settle it

A direct probe of the interface would settle the claim: grow an epitaxial Ta film on sapphire while altering only the interfacial chemistry, for example by oxygen dosing or changing the surface termination, and check whether the low-Qi loss disappears while the Ta remains epitaxial (111). Alternatively, spectroscopic detection of in-gap quasiparticle states at the epitaxial Ta/sapphire interface (e.g. via a tunnel junction or X-ray standing wave) that does not correlate with the loss would contradict the interfacial-loss mechanism.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The central discovery is that the epitaxial α-Ta(111)/Al2O3(0001) interface is a significant source of microwave loss in superconducting resonators, while structurally similar epitaxial Ta films nucleated on a 5-nm Nb(111) interlayer or on plasma-damaged sapphire show internal quality factors more than an order of magnitude higher. The loss is essentially power-independent over the studied range, indicating it is not a saturable two-level-system loss. The paper infers the interfacial origin by comparing three samples grown at the same temperature that differ only in the nucleation layer: Sample A (epitaxial Ta directly on sapphire) has low Qi, while Sample B (Nb interlayer) and Sample C (plasma-treated sapphire) recover high Qi despite similar Ta bulk properties. The microscopic mechanism is left open, with candidates including interface quasiparticle states, interfacial piezoelectricity, or vortex dynamics.

Load-bearing premise

The attribution of the loss to the epitaxial Ta/sapphire interface assumes that the three samples differ only in the nucleation interface and not in hidden variables such as impurity incorporation, strain, or electronic structure changes induced by the Nb interlayer or plasma damage.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • Growing epitaxial α-Ta on a thin epitaxial Nb interlayer restores resonator internal quality factors to above 500k, providing a practical route to low-loss Ta capacitors without changing the Ta surface.
  • The loss is power-independent, so it will not be cured by operating at higher power or by TLS-mitigation strategies such as surface cleaning alone.
  • Substrate surface preparation matters not only for chemical cleanliness but for the crystallographic structure of the interface: plasma damage removes the lossy epitaxial interface at the cost of film texture and roughness.
  • High DC transport quality (RRR above 40, Tc near bulk) does not guarantee low microwave loss, so structural and DC characterization alone is insufficient to qualify a superconducting film for quantum circuits.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • The results suggest that other epitaxial metal/sapphire interfaces used in superconducting circuits deserve the same kind of differential testing, since a material could be falsely blamed for loss that actually originates at its epitaxial interface with the substrate.
  • If the loss mechanism is an electronic interface state, adjusting the Fermi-level alignment or the oxygen stoichiometry at the interface (e.g. by oxygen dosing during growth) could suppress the loss while preserving epitaxy, which is a testable alternative to the interlayer and damage approaches.
  • The reproducibility data in Appendix A imply the effect is robust across substrate vendors and polish types, so the mitigation strategy should transfer across fabrication facilities, provided the growth-temperature calibration is done carefully.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Signed reviews

No signed human review yet.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

2 major / 4 minor

Summary. This paper reports a systematic study of Nb and Ta films sputtered on c-plane sapphire at different growth temperatures, correlating structural, transport, and microwave-loss properties. The central finding is that epitaxial alpha-Ta(111) films grown directly on c-plane sapphire show markedly poor low-power internal quality factors (Qi ~ 8k) despite excellent structural and DC transport properties, whereas Nb films and lower-temperature Ta films are high-performing. To locate the loss, the authors compare three 630 C samples: Sample A (epitaxial Ta on sapphire), Sample B (epitaxial Ta on a 5 nm epitaxial Nb interlayer), and Sample C (Ta on an Ar-plasma-damaged sapphire surface, yielding textured film). Both modifications raise Qi to ~400-500k, and the paper attributes the loss to the epitaxial Ta/sapphire interface. The authors support this with XRD, AFM, RHEED, TEM/EDS, and transport data, and they reproduce the effect on additional samples in Appendix A. They further note that the loss is essentially power-independent, suggesting a non-TLS mechanism, and they discuss possible microscopic origins while leaving the mechanism open.

Significance. If the central claim holds, this is an important result for superconducting quantum devices: it identifies a specific, previously unrecognized loss channel at epitaxial Ta/sapphire interfaces and offers simple, practical mitigation routes (Nb interlayer or substrate-surface damage). The study is thorough in its characterization, provides detailed process parameters for reproducibility, and the appendices strengthen the conclusion by showing the effect across different substrate vendors, polish conditions, and surface preparations. The two-control experimental design is clever and the paper is candid about the open microscopic mechanism. However, the causal attribution to the interface itself is the load-bearing point, and it rests on the assumption that the controls differ only in the intended interfacial property, which is not uniquely established.

major comments (2)
  1. [Section III C, Fig. 3, Table II] The two controls used to identify the interface as the loss source each change more than the interface alone. Sample B replaces the Ta/sapphire interface with Ta/Nb and Nb/sapphire interfaces, introducing a new material and possible proximity, strain, or field-distribution effects; Sample C simultaneously amorphizes the sapphire surface and changes the Ta film from epitaxial (111) to textured (110). The fact that two very different modifications both raise Qi by ~60x is consistent with an interfacial loss mechanism, but it does not uniquely prove that the loss resides specifically at the epitaxial Ta/sapphire interface, because the shared variable (absence of that interface) is not varied independently of other film and interface properties. A geometry-sweep test that varies the interface participation ratio (e.g., CPW gap width) on identically grown Samples A and B would provide a direct, quantitative test of the claim that the loss scales with interface participation. Without such a test, the abstract's statement that the authors 'determine that the source of loss is only present in samples having an epitaxial Ta/sapphire interface' is stronger than the evidence supports; the data establish a strong correlation, not a unique causal proof.
  2. [Section IV, first paragraph] The inference that Samples A and B are 'very similar' and that therefore the loss must come from the interface relies on macroscopic quantities (XRD lattice constant, RRR, Tc, surface roughness). Microwave loss at an interface can be controlled by atomic-scale chemistry, interfacial strain, or electronic structure that need not affect Tc or RRR, as the paper itself acknowledges when discussing possible mechanisms. The claim that the loss is not due to Ta film structure or surface morphology is supported by the comparison between A and B, but the comparison cannot exclude the possibility that the 5 nm Nb interlayer alters the interfacial electronic structure or strain in the Ta film in a way that removes a loss channel located in the Ta near the interface rather than at the sapphire interface itself. The paper should either soften the causal language (e.g., 'suggests' instead of 'determines' in the abstract) or add a more direct test, such as increasing the number of geometries to vary interface participation or performing a thickness series with fixed interface, to separate interface from near-interface film loss.
minor comments (4)
  1. [Appendix E] The text contains a typo: 'Lorenzian' should be 'Lorentzian' in the description of the resonance line shape.
  2. [Section IV and reference 51] The word 'vorticies' is misspelled; it should be 'vortices' in the discussion and in the title of reference 51.
  3. [Section II A] The chemical name in the text is misspelled: 'heximethyldisilazane' should be 'hexamethyldisilazane'.
  4. [Section II C and Appendix E] The photon-number estimation in Eq. (2) depends on the assumed attenuation and the extracted Q and Qc; the paper should clarify the systematic uncertainty in the absolute photon number, since the power-independence argument for the lossy samples relies on the relative scaling across the measured range.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No significant circularity: the interface-loss claim is an experimentally controlled comparison, not a derivation that reduces to its inputs.

full rationale

The paper's central claim—that epitaxial α-Ta(111)/Al2O3(0001) interfaces introduce microwave loss—is supported by direct resonator measurements, with Qi extracted using the standard diameter-correction model and compared across samples that differ in the nucleation interface. No parameter is fitted to the target conclusion, and no quantity is defined in terms of the result. The Sample A/B/C comparison is a controlled experiment: Sample B adds a 5 nm Nb interlayer and Sample C plasma-damages the sapphire and changes Ta texture, so each control changes more than just the interface. That is a threat to causal identification, but it is not circularity, because the Q-factor differences are measured independently and the authors do not assume the interface conclusion when interpreting them. Citations to prior work (DCM fitting, participation-ratio estimates, Nb surface encapsulation, piezoelectric-loss studies) are external methods or benchmarks rather than self-citations carrying the argument. The only self-citations are to standard measurement or processing references, and they are not load-bearing for the interface-loss claim. Therefore no self-definitional, fitted-input, or self-citation circularity is present.

Assumptions & free parameters 1 free parameters · 4 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The paper makes no first-principles derivation; its central claim is an empirical correlation supported by controlled sample comparison. No adjustable free parameters are introduced ad hoc; Qi is extracted via standard DCM fits. The main domain assumptions are that the DCM extraction, the participation-ratio estimate, and the thermocouple calibration are valid.

free parameters (1)
  • Internal quality factor Qi (extracted via DCM line-shape fit) = 8.3k (Sample A), 520k (Sample B), 370k (Sample C); Ta series range 7.4k-500k
    Qi is the measured outcome driving the central claim. It is fit from S21 spectra using the standard diameter-correction model, so it is not an arbitrary or hand-tuned parameter; it is listed because it is formally a number fitted to data.
assumptions (4)
  • standard math The diameter-correction model S21(f)=1-Q/Qc_hat/(1+2iQ(f-f0)/f0) correctly extracts internal quality factor from resonator spectra.
    All Qi values in Tables I-III and Fig. 2 rely on this fit; it is a standard method in the superconducting resonator community (Appendix E, Eq. 1).
  • domain assumption The narrow-gap CPW geometry gives 0.4-0.5% electric field participation at the metal/substrate interface, based on an assumed 2 nm interfacial layer.
    Used to justify sensitivity of the measurement to interface loss; the authors acknowledge assumptions about interfacial extent and dielectric properties (Section II.C).
  • domain assumption Thermocouple temperature calibrated by the aluminum melting point gives consistent substrate surface temperature across all growths.
    All growth temperature comparisons assume the calibration is reproducible; the surface is about 130 C lower than the thermocouple reading (Section II.A).
  • domain assumption High-vacuum annealing at 880 C yields equivalent sapphire surface chemistry for the main comparison samples.
    Samples A and B are assumed to start from the same prepared surface, which is needed to attribute the Qi difference to the interface rather than contamination (Section II.A and IV).

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Interface-sensitive microwave loss in superconducting tantalum films sputtered on c-plane sapphire." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/QXDIWN75

@misc{pith2026241216730,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Interface-sensitive microwave loss in superconducting tantalum films sputtered on c-plane sapphire},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/QXDIWN75}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2412.16730}
}
read the original abstract

Quantum coherence in superconducting circuits has increased steadily over the last decades as a result of a growing understanding of the various loss mechanisms. Recently, tantalum (Ta) emerged as a promising material to address microscopic sources of loss found on niobium (Nb) or aluminum (Al) surfaces. However, the effects of film and interface microstructure on low-temperature microwave loss are still not well understood. Here we present a systematic study of the structural and electrical properties of Ta and Nb films sputtered on c-plane sapphire at varying growth temperatures. As growth temperature is increased, our results show that the onset of epitaxial growth of alpha-phase Ta correlates with lower Ta surface roughness, higher critical temperature, and higher residual resistivity ratio, but surprisingly also correlates with a significant increase in loss at microwave frequency. Notably, this high level of loss is not observed in Nb films prepared in the same way and having very similar structure. By experimentally controlling the surface on which the Ta film is nucleated, we determine that the source of loss is only present in samples having an epitaxial Ta/sapphire interface and show that it is apparently mitigated by either growing a thin, epitaxial Nb inter-layer between the Ta film and the substrate or by intentionally treating, and effectively damaging, the sapphire surface with an in-situ argon plasma before Ta growth. In addition to elucidating this interfacial microwave loss, this work provides adequate process details to aid reproducible growth of low-loss Ta films across fabrication facilities.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 2412.16730 by the authors.

Figure 1
Figure 1. FIG. 1. Coupled ( [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p005_1.png] view at source ↗
Figure 2
Figure 2. FIG. 2. Low power, average internal quality factor ( [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p005_2.png] view at source ↗
Figure 4
Figure 4. Fig.4. From the specular, coupled scan presented in Fig.4(a), [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p006_4.png] view at source ↗
Figures from the paper (8 more)
Figure 3
Figure 3. Figure 3: FIG. 3. Low power internal quality factor ( [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p007_3.png]
Figure 4
Figure 4. Figure 4: FIG. 4. (a) Coupled ( [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p008_4.png]
Figure 5
Figure 5. Figure 5: FIG. 5. Atomic force micrographs of samples A, B, and C showing [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p009_5.png]
Figure 7
Figure 7. Figure 7: FIG. 7. Scanning transmission electron micrographs of Samples A(a-d), B(e-h), and C(i-m). (a, e, i) Low mag HAADF-STEM images. (b, f, j) [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p010_7.png]
Figure 8
Figure 8. Figure 8: FIG. 8. (a) RHEED patterns of the starting [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p014_8.png]
Figure 9
Figure 9. Figure 9: FIG. 9. X-ray diffraction pole figures of the Ta/Nb (110) reflections for epitaxial (Sample A), textured (Sample C) 100nm thick Ta films grown [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p015_9.png]
Figure 10
Figure 10. Figure 10: FIG. 10. Atomic force micrographs of 100nm thick Nb and Ta films grown on [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p015_10.png]
Figure 11
Figure 11. Figure 11: FIG. 11. (a) Internal quality factor plotted against estimated photon number for several resonator chips presented in this work. The different [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p016_11.png]

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

75 extracted references · 74 canonical work pages

  1. [1]

    Koch , author T

    author author J. Koch , author T. Yu , author J. Gambetta , author A. Houck , author D. Schuster , author J. Majer , author A. Blais , author M. Devoret , author S. Girvin , \ and\ author R. Schoelkopf ,\ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. A \ volume 76 ,\ pages 042319 ( year 2007 ) NoStop

    work page 2007

  2. [2]

    Nakamura , author Y

    author author Y. Nakamura , author Y. Pashkin , \ and\ author J. Tsai ,\ @noop journal journal Nature \ volume 398 ,\ pages 786--788 ( year 1999 ) NoStop

    work page 1999

  3. [3]

    Krantz , author M

    author author P. Krantz , author M. Kjaergaard , author F. Yan , author T. Orlando , author S. Gustavsson , \ and\ author W. Oliver ,\ @noop journal journal Appl. Phys. Rev. \ volume 6 ,\ pages 021318 ( year 2019 ) NoStop

    work page 2019

  4. [4]

    Kjaergaard , author M

    author author M. Kjaergaard , author M. Schwartz , author J. Braumuller , author P. Krantz , author J. I.-J. \ Wang , author S. Gustavsson , \ and\ author W. Oliver ,\ @noop journal journal Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics \ volume 11 ,\ pages 369--395 ( year 2020 ) NoStop

    work page 2020

  5. [5]

    Biznarova , author A

    author author J. Biznarova , author A. Osman , author E. Rehnman , author L. Chayanun , author C. Krizan , author P. Malmberg , author M. Rommel , author C. Warren , author P. Delsing , author A. Yurgens , author J. Bylander , \ and\ author A. F. \ Roudsari ,\ title title Mitigation of interfacial dielectric loss in aluminum-on-silicon superconducting qub...

    work page 2024

  6. [6]

    Bal , author A

    author author M. Bal , author A. Murthy , author S. Zhu , author F. Crisa , author X. You , author Z. Huang , author T. Roy , author J. Lee , author D. van Zanten , author R. Pilipenko , author I. Nekrashevich , author A. Lunin , author D. Bafia , author Y. Krasnikova , author C. Kopas , author E. O. \ Lachman , author D. Miller , author J. Mutus , author...

    work page 2024

  7. [7]

    Kono , author J

    author author S. Kono , author J. Pan , author M. Chegnizadeh , author X. Wang , author A. Youssefi , author M. Scigliuzzo , \ and\ author T. Kippenberg ,\ title title Mechanically induced correlated errors on superconducting qubits with relaxation times exceeding 0.4 ms , \ @noop journal journal Nat. Commun. \ volume 15 ,\ pages 3950 ( year 2024 ) NoStop

    work page 2024

  8. [8]

    Place , author L

    author author A. Place , author L. Rodgers , author P. Mundada , author B. Smitham , author M. Fitzpatrick , author Z. Leng , author A. Premkumar , author J. Bryon , author A. Vrajitoarea , author S. Sussman , author G. Cheng , author T. Madhavan , author H. Babla , author X. Le , author Y. Gang , author B. Jack , author A. Gyenis , author N. Yao , author...

    work page 2021

Show all 75 references
  1. [9]

    Simmonds , author K

    author author R. Simmonds , author K. Lang , author D. Hite , author S. Nam , author D. Pappas , \ and\ author J. Martinis ,\ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Lett. \ volume 93 ,\ pages 077003 ( year 2004 ) NoStop

    2004

  2. [10]

    Siddiqi ,\ @noop journal journal Nat Rev Mater \ volume 6 ,\ pages 875--891 ( year 2021 ) NoStop

    author author I. Siddiqi ,\ @noop journal journal Nat Rev Mater \ volume 6 ,\ pages 875--891 ( year 2021 ) NoStop

    2021

  3. [11]

    Wang , author X

    author author C. Wang , author X. Li , author H. Xu , author Z. Li , author J. Wang , author Z. Yang , author Z. Mi , author X. Liang , author T. Su , author C. Yang , author G. Wang , author W. Wang , author Y. Li , author M. Chen , author C. L. K. \ Linghu , author J. Han , ...

    2022

  4. [12]

    Crowley , author R

    author author K. Crowley , author R. McLellen , author A. Dutta , author N. Shumiya , author A. Place , author X. H. \ Li , author Y. Gang , author T. Madhavan , author M. Bland , author R. Chang , author N. Khedkar , author Y. C. \ Feng , author E. Umbarkar , author X. Gui , ...

    2023

  5. [13]

    Inaba ,\ @noop journal journal Jpn

    author author A. Inaba ,\ @noop journal journal Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. \ volume 19 ,\ pages 1553 ( year 1980 ) NoStop

    1980

  6. [14]

    author author B. Mazin ,\ title title Superconducting materials for microwave kinetic inductance detectors , \ @noop journal journal Handbook of Superconductivity \ volume 4 ,\ pages 756--765 ( year 2022 ) NoStop

    2022

  7. [15]

    Jiang , author T

    author author A. Jiang , author T. Tyson , author L. Axe , author L. Gladczuk , author M. Sosnowski , \ and\ author P. Cote ,\ title title The structure and stability of -ta thin films , \ @noop journal journal Thin Solid Films \ volume 479 ,\ pages 166--173 ( year 2005 ) NoStop

    2005

  8. [16]

    Lee \ and\ author D

    author author S. Lee \ and\ author D. Windover ,\ title title Phase, residual stress, and texture in triode-sputtered tantalum coatings on steel , \ @noop journal journal Surface and Coatings Technology \ volume 108-109 ,\ pages 65--72 ( year 1998 ) NoStop

    1998

  9. [17]

    Face \ and\ author D

    author author D. Face \ and\ author D. Prober ,\ title title Nucleation of body-centered-cubic tantalum films with a thin niobium underlayer , \ @noop journal journal Journal of Vacuum Science and Technology A \ volume 5 ,\ pages 3408--3411 ( year 1987 ) NoStop

    1987

  10. [18]

    Urade , author K

    author author Y. Urade , author K. Yakushiji , author M. Tsujimoto , author T. Yamada , author K. Makise , author W. Mizubayashi , \ and\ author K. Inomata ,\ title title Microwave characterization of tantalum superconducting resonators on silicon substrate with niobium buffer...

    2024

  11. [19]

    Alegria , author D

    author author L. Alegria , author D. Tennant , author K. Chaves , author J. Lee , author S. O'Kelley , author Y. Rosen , \ and\ author J. DuBois ,\ title title Two-level systems in nucleated and non-nucleated epitaxial alpha-tantalum films , \ @noop journal journal Appl. Phys....

    2023

  12. [20]

    Lee , author Z

    author author J. Lee , author Z. Sung , author A. Murthy , author A. Grassellino , \ and\ author A. Romanenko ,\ title title Stress-induced structural changes in superconducting nb thin films , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Mater. \ volume 7 ,\ pages L063201 ( year 2023 ) NoStop

    2023

  13. [21]

    Kunzmann , author T

    author author S. Kunzmann , author T. Hammerschmidt , author G. Schierning , \ and\ author A. Grunebohm ,\ title title Ab initio study of transition paths between (meta)stable phases of nb and ta-substituted nb , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Mater. \ volume 8 ,\ pages 03...

    2024

  14. [22]

    Ward , author E

    author author R. Ward , author E. Grier , \ and\ author A. Petford-Long ,\ title title Mbe growth of (110) refractory metals on a-plane sapphire , \ @noop journal journal The Journal of Materials Science: Materials in Electronics \ volume 14 ,\ pages 533--539 ( year 2003 ) NoStop

    2003

  15. [23]

    Wang , author C

    author author C. Wang , author C. Axline , author Y. Gao , author T. Brecht , author Y. Chu , author L. Frunzio , author M. Devoret , \ and\ author R. Schoelkopf ,\ @noop journal journal Appl. Phys. Lett. \ volume 107 ,\ pages 162601 ( year 2015 ) NoStop

    2015

  16. [24]

    Gambetta , author C

    author author J. Gambetta , author C. Murray , author Y.-K.-K. \ Fung , author D. McClure , author O. Dial , author W. Shanks , author J. Sleight , author M. Steffen , author K. Watanabe , author J. Hone , \ and\ author K. Fong ,\ @noop journal journal IEEE Transactions on App...

    2017

  17. [25]

    Huang , author B

    author author S. Huang , author B. Lienhard , author G. Calusine , author A. Vepsalainen , author J. Braumuller , author D. Kim , author A. J. \ Melville , author B. Niedzielski , author J. Yoder , author B. Kannan , author T. Orlando , author S. Gustavsson , \ and\ author W. ...

    2021

  18. [26]

    Sheldon , author M

    author author S. Sheldon , author M. Sandberg , author H. Paik , author B. Abdo , author J. Chow , author M. Steffen , \ and\ author J. Gambetta ,\ title title Characterization of hidden modes in networks of superconducting qubits , \ @noop journal journal Appl. Phys. Lett. \ ...

    2017

  19. [27]

    Gordon , author C

    author author R. Gordon , author C. Murray , author C. Kurter , author M. Sandberg , author S. Hall , author K. Balakrishnan , author R. Shelby , author B. Wacaser , author A. Stabile , author J. Sleight , author M. Brink , author M. Rothwell , author K. Rodbell , author O. Di...

    2022

  20. [28]

    McRae , author H

    author author C. McRae , author H. Wang , author J. Gao , author M. Vissers , author T. Brecht , author A. Dunsworth , author D. Pappas , \ and\ author J. Mutus ,\ @noop journal journal Rev. Sci. Instrum. \ volume 91 ,\ pages 091101 ( year 2020 ) NoStop

    2020

  21. [29]

    Mizutani ,\ title title Correct substrate temperature monitoring with infrared optical pyrometer for molecular-beam epitaxy of iii-v semiconductors , \ @noop journal journal J

    author author T. Mizutani ,\ title title Correct substrate temperature monitoring with infrared optical pyrometer for molecular-beam epitaxy of iii-v semiconductors , \ @noop journal journal J. Vac. Sci. Technol. B \ volume 6 ,\ pages 1671--1677 ( year 1988 ) NoStop

    1988

  22. [30]

    Lee , author G

    author author W. Lee , author G. Yoffe , author D. Schlom , \ and\ author J. H. \ Jr. ,\ title title Accurate measurement of mbe substrate temperature , \ @noop journal journal Journal of Crystal Growth \ volume 111 ,\ pages 131--135 ( year 1991 ) NoStop

    1991

  23. [31]

    author author N. Wilson ,\ title In-situ characterization of the surfaces and interfaces in superconducting coplanar waveguides, RE-NiO3 heterosctructures, and self assembled ErSb nanostructures grown by molecular beam epitaxy ,\ @noop type PhD dissertation ,\ address Material...

    2017

  24. [32]

    Dwikusuma , author D

    author author F. Dwikusuma , author D. Saulys , \ and\ author T. Kuech ,\ title title Study on sapphire surface preparation for iii-nitride heteroepitaxial growth by chemical treatments , \ @noop journal journal J. Electrochem. Soc. \ volume 149 ,\ pages G603 ( year 2002 ) NoStop

    2002

  25. [33]

    Vlasov , author A

    author author V. Vlasov , author A. Muslimov , author A. Butashin , \ and\ author V. Kanevsky ,\ title title Sapphire evolution of the vicinal (0001) sapphire surface upon annealing in air , \ @noop journal journal Surface and Thin Films \ volume 61 ,\ pages 58--62 ( year 2016...

    2016

  26. [34]

    author author C. J. \ Kopas , author E. Lachman , author C. R. H. \ McRae , author Y. Mohan , author J. Y. \ Mutus , author A. Nersisyan , \ and\ author A. Poudel ,\ https://arxiv.org/abs/2204.07202 title Simple coplanar waveguide resonator mask targeting metal-substrate inter...

    2022 arXiv

  27. [35]

    author author J. Gao ,\ title The physics of superconducting microwave resonators ,\ @noop type PhD dissertation ,\ address California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California ( year 2008 ) NoStop

    2008

  28. [36]

    Calusine , author A

    author author G. Calusine , author A. Melville , author W. Woods , author R. Das , author C. Stull , author V. Bolkhovsky , author D. Braje , author D. Hover , author D. Kim , author X. Miloshi , author D. Rosenberg , author A. Sevi , author J. Yoder , author E. Dauler , \ and...

    2018

  29. [37]

    Khalil , author M

    author author M. Khalil , author M. Stoutimore , author F. Wellstood , \ and\ author K. Osborn ,\ @noop journal journal J. Appl. Phys. \ volume 111 ,\ pages 054510 ( year 2012 ) NoStop

    2012

  30. [38]

    author author J. Aumentado ,\ title title Superconducting parametric amplifiers: the state of the art in josephson parametric amplifiers , \ @noop journal journal IEEE Microwave Magazine \ volume 21 ,\ pages 45--59 ( year 2020 ) NoStop

    2020

  31. [39]

    Wildes , author J

    author author A. Wildes , author J. Mayer , \ and\ author K. Theis-Brol ,\ title title The growth and structure of epitaxial niobium on sapphire , \ @noop journal journal Thin Solid Films \ volume 401 ,\ pages 7--34 ( year 2001 ) NoStop

    2001

  32. [40]

    author author M. R. \ anf C. Altman ,\ title title A new structure in tantalum thin fims , \ @noop journal journal Appl. Phys. Lett. \ volume 7 ,\ pages 51--52 ( year 1965 ) NoStop

    1965

  33. [41]

    Feinstein \ and\ author R

    author author L. Feinstein \ and\ author R. Huttemann ,\ title title Factors controlling the structure of sputtered ta films , \ @noop journal journal Thin Solid Films \ volume 16 ,\ pages 129--145 ( year 1973 ) NoStop

    1973

  34. [42]

    Mayer , author G

    author author J. Mayer , author G. Gutekunst , author G. Mobus , author J. Dura , author C. Flynn , \ and\ author M. Rhule ,\ title title Structure and defects of mbe grown nb- al_2 o_3 interfaces , \ @noop journal journal Acta metall. mater. \ volume 40 ,\ pages S217--S225 ( ...

    1992

  35. [43]

    Zmuidzinas ,\ title title Superconducting microresonators: Physics and applications , \ @noop journal journal Annu

    author author J. Zmuidzinas ,\ title title Superconducting microresonators: Physics and applications , \ @noop journal journal Annu. Rev. Condens. Matter Phys. \ volume 3 ,\ pages 169--214 ( year 2012 ) NoStop

    2012

  36. [44]

    Clavero , author D

    author author C. Clavero , author D. Beringer , author W. Roach , author J. Skuza , author K. Wong , author A. Batchelor , author C. Reece , \ and\ author R. Lukaszew ,\ title title Strain effects on the crystal growth and superconducting properties of epitaxial niobium ultrat...

    2012

  37. [45]

    author author S. G. \ Jones , author N. Materise , author K. Leung , author J. Weber , author B. Isakov , author X. Chen , author J. Zheng , author A. Gyenis , author B. Jaeck , \ and\ author C. McRae ,\ title title Grain size in low loss superconducting ta thin films on c axi...

    2023

  38. [46]

    Aumentado , author G

    author author J. Aumentado , author G. Catelani , \ and\ author K. Serniak ,\ title title Quasiparticle poisoning in superconducting quantum computers , \ @noop journal journal Physics Today \ volume 76 ,\ pages 34--39 ( year 2023 ) NoStop

    2023

  39. [47]

    Scigliuzzo , author L

    author author M. Scigliuzzo , author L. Bruhat , author A. Bengtsson , author J. Burnett , author A. F. \ Roudsari , \ and\ author P. Delsing ,\ title title Phononic loss in superconducting resonators on piezoelectric substrates , \ @noop journal journal New J. Phys. \ volume ...

    2020

  40. [48]

    McRae , author A

    author author C. McRae , author A. McFadden , author R. Zhao , author H. Wang , author J. Long , author T. Zhao , author S. Park , author M. Bal , author C. Palmstrom , \ and\ author D. Pappas ,\ @noop journal journal J. Appl. Phys. \ volume 129 ,\ pages 025109 ( year 2021 ) NoStop

    2021

  41. [49]

    DeGennes ,\ title title Boundary effects in superconductors , \ @noop journal journal Rev

    author author P. DeGennes ,\ title title Boundary effects in superconductors , \ @noop journal journal Rev. Mod. Phys. \ volume 36 ,\ pages 225 ( year 1964 ) NoStop

    1964

  42. [50]

    Chen , author J

    author author C. Chen , author J. Tran , author A. McFadden , author R. Simmonds , author K. Saito , author E.-B. \ Chu , author D. Morales , author V. Suezaki , author Y. Hou , author J. Aumentado , author P. Lee , author J. Moodera , \ and\ author P. Wei ,\ title title Signa...

    2024

  43. [51]

    Song , author T

    author author C. Song , author T. Heitmann , author M. Defeo , author K. Yu , author R. McDermott , author M. Neeley , author J. Martinis , \ and\ author B. Plourde ,\ title title Microwave response of vorticies in superconducting thin films of re and al , \ @noop journal jour...

    2009

  44. [52]

    author author C. H. \ Hinrichs \ and\ author C. Swenson ,\ title title Superconducting critical field of tantalum as a function of temperature and pressure , \ @noop journal journal Physical Review \ volume 123 ,\ pages 1106 ( year 1961 ) NoStop

    1961

  45. [53]

    Stan , author S

    author author G. Stan , author S. Field , \ and\ author J. Martinis ,\ title title Critical field for complete vortex expulsion from narrow superconducting strips , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Lett. \ volume 92 ,\ pages 097003 ( year 2004 ) NoStop

    2004

  46. [54]

    Oderno , author C

    author author V. Oderno , author C. Dufour , author C. Dumesnil , author K. Mangin , \ and\ author G. Marchal ,\ title title Hexagonal surface structure during the first stages of niobium growth on sapphire (1120) , \ @noop journal journal Philosophical Magazine Letters \ volu...

    1998

  47. [55]

    Grier , author M

    author author E. Grier , author M. Jenkins , author A. Petford-Long , author R. Ward , \ and\ author M. Wells ,\ title title Misfit dislocations of epitaxial (110) niobium|| (11-20) sapphire interfaces grown by molecular beam epitaxy , \ @noop journal journal Thin Solid Films ...

    2000

  48. [56]

    Cava , author B

    author author R. Cava , author B. Batlogg , author J. Krajewski , author P. Gammel , author H. Poulsen , author W. P. \ Jr , \ and\ author L. R. \ Jr ,\ title title Antiferromagnetism and metallic conductivity in nb12o29 , \ @noop journal journal Nature \ volume 350 ,\ pages 5...

    1991

  49. [57]

    Zheng , author X

    author author X. Zheng , author X. Dong , author S. Zhang , \ and\ author J. Yang ,\ title title Defect-induced ferromagnetism in w18o49 nanowires , \ @noop journal journal Journal of Alloys and Compounds \ volume 818 ,\ pages 152894 ( year 2020 ) NoStop

    2020

  50. [58]

    Cezar , author I

    author author A. Cezar , author I. Graff , author J. Varalda , author W. Schreiner , \ and\ author D. Mosca ,\ title title Oxygen-vacancy-induced room-temperature magnetization in lamellar v2o5 thin films , \ @noop journal journal J. Appl. Phys. \ volume 116 ,\ pages 163904 ( ...

    2014

  51. [59]

    Parida , author C

    author author M. Parida , author C. Vijayan , author C. Rout , author C. Suchand-Sandeep , author R. Philip , \ and\ author P. Deshmukh ,\ title title Room temperature ferromagnetism and optical limiting in v2o5 nanoflowers synthesized by a novel method , \ @noop journal journ...

    2010

  52. [60]

    Lu , author J

    author author J. Lu , author J. Zhang , author J. Yang , author P. Hou , author L. Jia , author G. Wen , author L. Liu , author P. Lu , \ and\ author H. Sun ,\ title title Preparation, optical properties, room temperature ferromagnetism, and mechanism of ordered nanotube-like ...

    2024

  53. [61]

    Fujii , author D

    author author T. Fujii , author D. Alders , author F. Voogt , author T. Hibma , author B. Thole , \ and\ author G. Sawatzky ,\ title title In situ rheed and xps studies of epitaxial thin -fe_2o_3(0001) films on sapphire , \ @noop journal journal Surface Science \ volume 366 ,\...

    1996

  54. [62]

    Beran \ and\ author K

    author author J. Beran \ and\ author K. Masek ,\ title title Rheed and xps study of palladium interaction with cerium oxide surface , \ @noop journal journal Vacuum \ volume 167 ,\ pages 438--444 ( year 2019 ) NoStop

    2019

  55. [63]

    Chen , author A

    author author Y. Chen , author A. Das , author I. Duplessis , author D. Keane , \ and\ author M. Bedzyk ,\ title title Atomic-scale interface for pt nanoparticles on srtio3 (001) , \ @noop journal journal ACS Applied Materials and Interfaces \ volume 16 ,\ pages 26862--26869 (...

    2024

  56. [64]

    Gillet \ and\ author B

    author author E. Gillet \ and\ author B. Ealet ,\ title title Characterization of sapphire surfaces by electron energy-loss spectroscopy , \ @noop journal journal Surface Science \ volume 273 ,\ pages 427--436 ( year 1992 ) NoStop

    1992

  57. [65]

    Stageberg , author R

    author author F. Stageberg , author R. Cantor , \ and\ author A. Goldman ,\ title title Electronic density of states at the surface of a superconductor in contact with a magnetic insulator , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. B \ volume 32 ,\ pages 3292 ( year 1985 ) NoStop

    1985

  58. [66]

    DeWeert \ and\ author G

    author author M. DeWeert \ and\ author G. Arnold ,\ title title Superconducting-quasiparticle interface states , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Lett. \ volume 55 ,\ pages 1522--1525 ( year 1985 ) NoStop

    1985

  59. [67]

    DeWeert \ and\ author G

    author author M. DeWeert \ and\ author G. Arnold ,\ title title Theory of superconducting-quasiparticle interface states , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. B \ volume 39 ,\ pages 11307--11319 ( year 1989 ) NoStop

    1989

  60. [68]

    Balatsky \ and\ author S

    author author A. Balatsky \ and\ author S. Trugman ,\ title title Lifshitz tail in the density of states of a superconductor with magnetic impurities , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Lett. \ volume 79 ,\ pages 3767--3770 ( year 1997 ) NoStop

    1997

  61. [69]

    Fominov \ and\ author M

    author author Y. Fominov \ and\ author M. Skvortsov ,\ title title Subgap states in disordered superconductors with strong magnetic impurities , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. B. \ volume 93 ,\ pages 144511 ( year 2016 ) NoStop

    2016

  62. [70]

    author author T. Gilbert ,\ title title A phenomenological theory of damping in ferromagnetic metals , \ @noop journal journal IEEE Transactions in Magnetics \ volume 40 ,\ pages 3443--3449 ( year 2004 ) NoStop

    2004

  63. [71]

    Hickey \ and\ author J

    author author M. Hickey \ and\ author J. Moodera ,\ title title Origin of intrinsic gilbert damping , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Lett. \ volume 102 ,\ pages 137601 ( year 2009 ) NoStop

    2009

  64. [72]

    Georgescu \ and\ author S

    author author A. Georgescu \ and\ author S. Ismail-Beigi ,\ title title Surface piezoelectricity of (0001) sapphire , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Appl. \ volume 11 ,\ pages 064065 ( year 2019 ) NoStop

    2019

  65. [73]

    \ Park , author M

    author author D.-S. \ Park , author M. Hadad , author L. Riemer , author R. Ignatans , author D. Spirito , author V. Esposito , author V. Tileli , author N. Gauquelin , author D. Chezganov , author D. Jannis , author J. Verbeeck , author S. Gorfman , author N. Pryds , author P...

    2022

  66. [74]

    Rieger , author S

    author author D. Rieger , author S. Gunzler , author M. Spiecker , author A. Nambisan , author W. Wernsdorfer , \ and\ author I. Pop ,\ title title Fano interference in microwave resonator measurements , \ @noop journal journal Phys. Rev. Appl. \ volume 20 ,\ pages 014059 ( ye...

    2023

  67. [75]

    Bruno , author G

    author author A. Bruno , author G. de Lange , author S. Assad , author K. van der Enden , author N. Langford , \ and\ author L. Dicarlo ,\ title title Reducing intrinsic loss in superconducting resonators by surface treatment and deep etching of silicon substrates , \ @noop jo...

    2015

Pith tools

Reviewed August 11, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.