Jacobi sums and cyclotomic numbers: A survey report

Jagmohan Tanti; Md. Helal Ahmed

Jacobi sums and cyclotomic numbers: A survey report

T0 review · 0 major / 1 minor · reviewed 2026-05-25 · grok-4.3

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗

Pith's one-line read Survey reviews diophantine systems for finding coefficients of Jacobi sums and cyclotomic numbers.

desk verdict A narrow survey that gathers existing results on diophantine systems for Jacobi sums and cyclotomic numbers but introduces no new theorems or methods. read the letter →

arxiv 1906.09960 v1 pith:646X2XJN submitted 2019-06-21 math.NT

Md. Helal Ahmed , Jagmohan Tanti This is my paper · ORCID

classification math.NT

keywords Jacobisumscyclotomicnumbersdiophantinesystemsnumbertheoryfinitefields

verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

This paper is a survey that collects and reviews existing results on diophantine systems used to determine the coefficients of Jacobi sums and the values of cyclotomic numbers. It presents the body of work on these problems and states the current status of determining them in general. A reader would care because Jacobi sums and cyclotomic numbers appear repeatedly in calculations over finite fields and in the study of cyclotomic extensions.

What carries the argument

Diophantine systems that solve for the coefficients of Jacobi sums and for cyclotomic numbers.

What would settle it

A previously unknown diophantine system that determines these quantities in a new range of cases and is absent from the survey would show the review does not capture the full current status.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The survey reviews results concerning the diophantine systems for finding the cyclotomic numbers and coefficients of Jacobi sums and indicates the current status of the problem.

Load-bearing premise

The literature reviewed covers the main approaches to determining Jacobi sums and cyclotomic numbers via diophantine systems.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

Explicit values or congruences for Jacobi sums follow from solutions to the reviewed systems in the cases covered.
Cyclotomic numbers can be computed directly once the corresponding diophantine system is solved.
The status of the general problem remains open beyond the special cases treated in the collected results.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

The survey implies that further work on general diophantine formulations could close remaining cases.
Methods reviewed here may extend to related objects such as Gauss sums in the same finite-field setting.

Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, simulated authors' rebuttal, and a circularity audit.

Desk Editor's Note

read the letter

This paper is a survey report whose stated purpose is to review results on diophantine systems for finding cyclotomic numbers and the coefficients of Jacobi sums, then note the current status of that line of work. No new results are claimed anywhere in the abstract or the described scope. The authors stick strictly to compilation of prior literature. What the paper does is keep the topic tightly bounded, which makes the review easier to produce and potentially easier to use than a wider survey would be. If the body lists the main papers, their approaches, and where the open questions sit, it could serve as a convenient reference for someone already interested in this corner of algebraic number theory. The limitation is built in: the work adds no synthesis, no resolution of open problems, and no fresh perspective. Its value therefore depends entirely on whether the coverage is accurate and reasonably complete. The abstract gives no sign of gaps or errors, but without independent checks that remains an assumption. There are no derivations to verify, so no circularity or fitting issues arise. The paper is aimed at specialists who already work with Jacobi sums or cyclotomic fields and want a quick map of the diophantine literature. A broader audience in number theory would find little to engage with. It shows clear, limited thinking that matches its modest claim. I would not bring it to a general reading group, but a group focused on character sums might find the status summary worth a quick look. I would not cite it unless I needed to point someone to a survey on exactly this sub-topic. A journal that publishes short surveys in number theory should send it to referees so they can check coverage and accuracy; the central claim is narrow enough that it can be evaluated on its own terms.

Referee Report

0 major / 1 minor

Summary. The manuscript is a survey reviewing results on diophantine systems used to determine cyclotomic numbers and the coefficients of Jacobi sums, with the goal of indicating the current status of these problems in the literature.

Significance. If the coverage is accurate and reasonably complete, the survey could serve as a useful consolidation of known results on Jacobi sums and cyclotomic numbers, an area with a long history of study. No new theorems or computations are claimed, so significance rests on the quality and representativeness of the literature synthesis.

minor comments (1)

The abstract refers to 'a large number of interesting results' without indicating the time span, key authors, or selection criteria for the reviewed literature; this makes it difficult to assess completeness from the provided description alone.

Simulated Author's Rebuttal

0 responses · 0 unresolved

We thank the referee for reviewing our survey on Jacobi sums and cyclotomic numbers. The report notes that the manuscript consolidates known results without claiming new theorems, and highlights that its value depends on the accuracy and completeness of the literature synthesis. No specific major comments or points of criticism are raised in the report, and the recommendation is listed as uncertain. We address the overall assessment below.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No significant circularity: survey of external literature only

full rationale

The paper is a survey whose stated purpose is to review existing results on diophantine systems for cyclotomic numbers and Jacobi-sum coefficients and to summarize the current status. No new theorem, derivation, prediction, or computation is asserted by the authors. The load-bearing requirement is only that the review accurately cover the cited external literature; no internal equations, self-citations, or fitted inputs reduce to the paper's own inputs by construction. This is the normal honest finding for a review article with no original derivations.

Assumptions & free parameters 0 free parameters · 0 assumptions · 0 invented entities

As a survey report, the paper introduces no free parameters, axioms, or invented entities; it reviews prior work without adding new mathematical objects or assumptions of its own.

how reviews work

0 comments

Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Jacobi sums and cyclotomic numbers: A survey report." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/646X2XJN

@misc{pith2026190609960,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Jacobi sums and cyclotomic numbers: A survey report},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/646X2XJN}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:1906.09960}
}

read the original abstract

The determination of Jacobi sums, their congruences and cyclotomic numbers have been the object of attention for many years and there are large number of interesting results related to these in the literature. This survey aims at reviewing results concerning the diophantine systems for finding the cyclotomic numbers and coefficients of Jacobi sums and to indicate the current status of the problem.

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

60 extracted references · 60 canonical work pages

[1]

V. V. Acharya and S. A. Katre, Cyclotomic numbers of order s 2l, l an odd prime, Acta Arith., 69 (1) (1995), 51 − 74

work page 1995
[2]

Adleman, C

L. Adleman, C. Pomerance and R. Rumely, On distinguishin g prime numbers from composite numbers, Ann. of Math., 117 (1983), 173 − 206

work page 1983
[3]

M. H. Ahmed, J. Tanti and A. Hoque, Cyclotomic numbers of o rder 2 l2 with prime l, (arXiv:1807.07708v2 [math.NT])

work page Pith review arXiv
[4]

M. H. Ahmed, J. Tanti, K. Chakraborty and S. Pusph, A Publi c-key cryptosystem using cyclotomic matrices, (preprint)

work page
[5]

M. H. Ahmed and J. Tanti, Congruences of Jacobi sums of ord er 2 l2 with prime l, (arXiv:1902.10512 [math.NT]). 18 MD HELAL AHMED AND JAGMOHAN TANTI

work page arXiv 1902
[6]

Anuradha and S

N. Anuradha and S. A. Katre, Number of points on the projec tive curves aY l = bXl + cZ l and aY 2l = bX2l + cZ 2l deﬁned over ﬁnite ﬁelds, l an odd prime, J. Number Theory, 77 (1999), 288 − 313

work page 1999
[7]

Thesis, Univ

Anuradha Narasimhan, Arithmetic Characterization and Applications of Jacobi Sums of Or- der l and 2 l, Ph.D. Thesis, Univ. of Pune, 2000

work page 2000
[8]

B. C. Berndt, R. J. Evans, and K. S. Williams, Gauss and Jac obi Sums, John Wiley and Sons Inc., A Wiley-Interscience Publication, New York, 199 8

work page

Show all 60 references

[9]

B. C. Berndt and R. J. Evans, Sums of Gauss, Jacobi and Jaco bsthal, J. Number Theory, 11 1979, 349 − 398

1979
[10]

B. C. Berndt and R. J. Evans, Sums of Gauss, Eisenstein, J acobi, Jacobsthal and Brewer, Illinois J. Math., 23 (1979), 374 − 437

1979
[11]

Betsumiya, M

K. Betsumiya, M. Hirasaka, T. Komatsu, and A. Munemasa, Upper bounds on cyclotomic numbers, Linear Alg. Appl., 438 (1) (2013), 111 − 120

2013
[12]

L. D. Baumert and H. Fredricksen, The cyclotomic number s of order eighteen with applica- tions to diﬀerence sets, Math. Comp., 21 (1967), 204 − 219

1967
[13]

N. Buck, L. Smith, B. K. Spearman and K. S. Williams, The c yclotomic numbers of order ﬁfteen, Math. of Comp., 48 1987, 67 − 83

1987
[14]

Davenport, The Higher Arithmetic, An introduction t o the theory of numbers, Chapter VIII by J

H. Davenport, The Higher Arithmetic, An introduction t o the theory of numbers, Chapter VIII by J. H. Davenport, Seventh edition, Cambridge Univ. Pr ess, Cambridge, 1999

1999
[15]

L. E. Dickson, Cyclotomy, higher congruences, and W ari ng’s problem, Amer. J. Math., 57 (1935), 391 − 424

1935
[16]

L. E. Dickson, Cyclotomy and trinomial congruences, Tr ans. Amer. Soc., 37 (1935), 363 −380

1935
[17]

L. E. Dickson, Cyclotomy when e is composite, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 38 (1935), 187 −200

1935
[18]

Eisenstein, Einfacher beweis und verallgemeinerun g des fundamental-theorems fur die biquadratischen reste, in Mathematische W erke, Band I, 223 − 245, Chelsea, New York, 1975

G. Eisenstein, Einfacher beweis und verallgemeinerun g des fundamental-theorems fur die biquadratischen reste, in Mathematische W erke, Band I, 223 − 245, Chelsea, New York, 1975

1975
[19]

R. J. Evans, Congruences for Jacobi Sums, J. Number Theo ry, 71 (1998), 109 − 120

1998
[20]

R. J. Evans, Resolution of sign ambiguities of Jacobi an d Jacobsthal sums, Paciﬁc J. Math., 81 (1979), 71 − 80

1979
[21]

R. J. Evans and J. R. Hill, The cyclotomic numbers of orde r sixteen, Math. Comp., 33 (1979), 827 − 835

1979
[22]

Friesen, J

C. Friesen, J. B. Muskat, B. K. Spearman and K. S. William s, Cyclotomy of order 15 over GF (p2), p ≡ 4, 11 (mod 15), Int. J. Math. Math. Sci., 9 (1986), 665 − 704

1986
[23]

C. F. Gauss, Theoria Residuorum Biquadraticorum, W erk e, 2 (1876), 67 − 92
[24]

C. F. Gauss, Disquisitiones Arithmeticae, Section 358
[25]

Hall, Jr., Characters and cyclotomy, (Proc

M. Hall, Jr., Characters and cyclotomy, (Proc. Symp. Pu re Math. 8), 31 − 43. Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, R. I., 1965

1965
[26]

Ihara, Proﬁnite braid groups, Galois representatio ns, and complex multiplications, Ann

Y. Ihara, Proﬁnite braid groups, Galois representatio ns, and complex multiplications, Ann. Math., 123 (1986), 43 − 106

1986
[27]

Ireland and M

K. Ireland and M. Rosen, A Classical Introduction to Mod ern Number Theory, Second edition. Springer, New York, 1990

1990
[28]

Iwasawa, A note on Jacobi sums, Symposia Math., 15 447−459, Academic Press, London, 1975

K. Iwasawa, A note on Jacobi sums, Symposia Math., 15 447−459, Academic Press, London, 1975

1975
[29]

C. G. J. Jacobi, Brief an Gauss, 8 Februar 1827. [CW: vol. 7, pp. 393 − 400]
[30]

C. G. J. Jacobi, Uber die Kreistheilung und Ihre Anwendu ng auf die Zahlentheorie, Monats- ber. Konigl. Akad. Wiss. Berlin, (1837), 127 − 136. (Same paper as J. Reine Angew. Math. 30 (1846), 166 − 182) [CW: vol. 6, pp. 254 − 274]
[31]

S. A. Katre and A. R. Rajwade, Resolution of the sign ambi guity in the determination of the cyclotomic numbers of order 4 and the corresponding Jaco bsthal sum, Math. Scand., 60 (1987), 52 − 62

1987
[32]

S. A. Katre and A. R. Rajwade, On the Jacobsthal sum φ9(a) and the related sum ψ9(a) , Math. Scand., 53 (1983), 193 − 202

1983
[33]

S. A. Katre and A. R. Rajwade, Complete solution of the cy clotomic problem in Fq for any prime modulus l, q = pα, p ≡ 1 (mod l), Acta Arith., 45 (1985), 183 − 199

1985
[34]

S. A. Katre and A. R. Rajwade, Unique determination of cy clotomic numbers of order ﬁve, Manuscripta Math., 53 (1-2) (1985), 65 − 75

1985
[35]

Lehmer, On the number of solutions of uk + D ≡ (mod p), Paciﬁc J

E. Lehmer, On the number of solutions of uk + D ≡ (mod p), Paciﬁc J. Math., 5 (1955), 103 − 118

1955
[36]

Lehmer, On the cyclotomic numbers of order sixteen, C anad

E. Lehmer, On the cyclotomic numbers of order sixteen, C anad. J. Math., 6 (1954), 449 −454. A SUR VEY REPORT 19

1954
[37]

P. A. Leonard and K. S. Williams, The cyclotomic numbers of order seven, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., 51 (1975), 295 − 300

1975
[38]

P. A. Leonard and K. S. Williams, The cyclotomic numbers of order eleven, Acta Arith., 26 (1975), 367 − 383

1975
[39]

K. H. Leung, S. L. Ma and B. Schmidt, New Hadamard matrice s of order 4 p2 obtained from Jacobi sums of order 16, J. Comb. Theory, Series A, 113 (5) (2006), 822 − 838

2006
[40]

J. B. Muskat, On Jacobi sums of certain composite orders , Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 134 (1968), 483 − 502

1968
[41]

J. B. Muskat, The cyclotomic numbers of order fourteen, Acta Arith., 11, (1966), 263 − 279

1966
[42]

J. B. Muskat and A. L. Whiteman, The cyclotomic numbers o f order twenty, Acta Arith., 17, (1970), 185 − 216

1970
[43]

J. B. Muskat and Y. C. Zee, Sign ambiguities of Jacobi sum s, Duke Math. J., 40 (1973), 313 − 334

1973
[44]

J. C. Parnami, M. K. Agrawal, and A. R. Rajwade, A congrue nce relation between the coeﬃcients of the Jacobi sum, Indian J. Pure Appl. Math., 12 (7) (1981), 804 − 806

1981
[45]

J. C. Parnami, M. K. Agrawal, and A. R. Rajwade, Jacobi su ms and cyclotomic numbers for a ﬁnite ﬁeld, Acta Arith., 41 (1982), 1 − 13

1982
[46]

Shirolkar, S

D. Shirolkar, S. A. Katre, Jacobi sums and cyclotomic nu mbers of order l2, Acta Arith., 147 (2011), 33 − 49

2011
[47]

Stickelberger, Uber eine Verallgemeinerung der Kre isteillung, Math

L. Stickelberger, Uber eine Verallgemeinerung der Kre isteillung, Math. Ann., 37 (1890), 321 − 367
[48]

Storer, Cyclotomy and diﬀerence sets I, Markham Publ

T. Storer, Cyclotomy and diﬀerence sets I, Markham Publ . Co.,Chicago, 1967

1967
[49]

Storer, A Family of Diﬀerence Sets, Dissertation, Un iversity of Southern California, 1964

T. Storer, A Family of Diﬀerence Sets, Dissertation, Un iversity of Southern California, 1964

1964
[50]

Storer, On the unique determination of the cyclotomi c numbers for Galois ﬁelds and Galois domains, J

T. Storer, On the unique determination of the cyclotomi c numbers for Galois ﬁelds and Galois domains, J. Combinatorial Theory, 2 (1967), 296 − 300

1967
[51]

van W amelen, Jacobi sums over ﬁnite ﬁelds, Acta Arith ., 102 (1) (2002), 1-20

P. van W amelen, Jacobi sums over ﬁnite ﬁelds, Acta Arith ., 102 (1) (2002), 1-20

2002
[52]

W eil, Number of solutions of equations in a ﬁnite ﬁeld , Bull

A. W eil, Number of solutions of equations in a ﬁnite ﬁeld , Bull. Amer. Math. Soc., 55 (1949), 497 − 508

1949
[53]

A. E. W estern, An extension of Eisenstein’s law of recip rocity II, Proc. London Math. Soc., (2) 7 (1908), 265 − 297

1908
[54]

A. L. Whiteman, A Family of Diﬀerence Sets, Illinois J. M ath., 6 (1962), 107 − 121

1962
[55]

A. L. Whiteman, Cyclotomy and Jacobsthal sums, Amer. J. Math., 74 (1952), 89 − 99

1952
[56]

A. L. Whiteman, The cyclotomic numbers of order ten, Pro c. Sympos. Appl. Math., 10, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, R. I., 1960, 95 − 111

1960
[57]

A. L. Whiteman, The cyclotomic numbers of order twelve, Acta Arith., 6 (1960), 53 − 76

1960
[58]

A. L. Whiteman, The cyclotomic numbers of order sixteen , Trans. Amer. Math. Soc., 86 (1957), 401 − 413

1957
[59]

Y. C. Zee, The Jacobi sums of orders thirteen and sixty an d related quadratic decompositions, Math. Z., 115 (1970), 259 − 272

1970
[60]

Y. C. Zee, The Jacobi sums of order twenty-two, Proc. Am. Math. Soc., 28 (1971), 25 − 31. Md Helal Ahmed @ Department of Mathematics, Central University of Jharkhand, Ranchi-835205, India E-mail address : ahmed.helal@cuj.ac.in Jagmohan Tanti @ Department of Mathematics, Centra...

1971

Pith tools

Reviewed May 25, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.

[1] [1]

V. V. Acharya and S. A. Katre, Cyclotomic numbers of order s 2l, l an odd prime, Acta Arith., 69 (1) (1995), 51 − 74

work page 1995

[2] [2]

Adleman, C

L. Adleman, C. Pomerance and R. Rumely, On distinguishin g prime numbers from composite numbers, Ann. of Math., 117 (1983), 173 − 206

work page 1983

[3] [3]

M. H. Ahmed, J. Tanti and A. Hoque, Cyclotomic numbers of o rder 2 l2 with prime l, (arXiv:1807.07708v2 [math.NT])

work page Pith review arXiv

[4] [4]

M. H. Ahmed, J. Tanti, K. Chakraborty and S. Pusph, A Publi c-key cryptosystem using cyclotomic matrices, (preprint)

work page

[5] [5]

M. H. Ahmed and J. Tanti, Congruences of Jacobi sums of ord er 2 l2 with prime l, (arXiv:1902.10512 [math.NT]). 18 MD HELAL AHMED AND JAGMOHAN TANTI

work page arXiv 1902

[6] [6]

Anuradha and S

N. Anuradha and S. A. Katre, Number of points on the projec tive curves aY l = bXl + cZ l and aY 2l = bX2l + cZ 2l deﬁned over ﬁnite ﬁelds, l an odd prime, J. Number Theory, 77 (1999), 288 − 313

work page 1999

[7] [7]

Thesis, Univ

Anuradha Narasimhan, Arithmetic Characterization and Applications of Jacobi Sums of Or- der l and 2 l, Ph.D. Thesis, Univ. of Pune, 2000

work page 2000

[8] [8]

B. C. Berndt, R. J. Evans, and K. S. Williams, Gauss and Jac obi Sums, John Wiley and Sons Inc., A Wiley-Interscience Publication, New York, 199 8

work page