Pith. sign in

REVIEW 3 major objections 4 minor 73 references

Dissipative dynamics of atomic and molecular Rydberg gases: Avalanche to ultracold plasma states of strong coupling

T0 review · 3 major / 4 minor · reviewed 2026-08-14 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗ Review JSON

Pith's one-line read A nitric oxide ultracold plasma settles into a long-lived, low-temperature state that classical rate-equation and hydrodynamic simulations cannot reproduce, and the paper argues this signals a quantum many-body localized phase.

desk verdict A useful review of the UBC NO ultracold plasma work wrapped around a speculative many-body localization claim that this manuscript does not substantiate. read the letter →

arxiv 1908.07633 v1 pith:3MFJS72X submitted 2019-08-20 physics.plasm-ph cond-mat.dis-nnphysics.chem-ph

M. Aghigh , K. Grant , R. Haenel , K. L. Marroquín , F. B. V. Martins , H. Sadegi , M. Schulz-Weiling , J. Sous
show 3 more authors
R. Wang J. S. Keller E. R. Grant
This is my paper · ORCID
classification physics.plasm-phcond-mat.dis-nnphysics.chem-ph
keywords ultracoldplasmaRydberggasavalanchenitricoxidearrestedrelaxationmany-bodylocalizationpredissociationambipolarexpansionstrongcoupling
verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

This review argues that a laser-prepared ultracold plasma of nitric oxide molecules, born from a Rydberg gas avalanche, settles into a long-lived, low-temperature state whose relaxation halts in a way no classical rate-equation or hydrodynamic model can produce. The central claim is that this arrested relaxation signals a quantum many-body localized phase, sustained because predissociation of NO Rydberg molecules removes the rare thermal regions that would otherwise destroy localization. If true, ultracold plasmas become a laboratory platform for studying many-body localization in a dense, strongly coupled, long-range-interacting system, a regime rarely reached in condensed matter experiments. The paper reviews early ultracold plasma work and then details the NO experiments and simulations that support this shift beyond conventional plasma physics.

What carries the argument

The load-bearing mechanisms are: prompt Penning ionization between close Rydberg pairs, whose density is set by a closed-form integral over an Erlang nearest-neighbor distribution and which seeds the electron-impact avalanche; coupled rate-equation hydrodynamics on a 100-shell ellipsoidal model including ambipolar expansion and resonant NO+–NO* charge exchange; and a three-dimensional spin model of long-range dipole-dipole (spin flip-flop) and Ising interactions with disorder, proposed to produce many-body localization. The predissociation of NO Rydberg molecules is the crucial self-purifying process that depletes thermal Griffiths regions.

What would settle it

Measure the predissociation lifetime of NO Rydberg molecules inside a quenched plasma volume with a locally elevated temperature and compare it with the thermalization (energy-spreading) timescale; if depletion of the hot region does not occur promptly, the self-purifying mechanism fails. Alternatively, run the classical shell model with explicit predissociation rates; if any initial condition reproduces the long-lived low-temperature state, the paper's pivotal 'no combination of initial conditions' claim is disproved.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The paper's central discovery is the characterization of an anomalous molecular ultracold plasma state: after avalanche ionization of a state-selected NO Rydberg gas, the plasma bifurcates and relaxes to a spatially correlated quasi-equilibrium of ions, electrons, and Rydberg molecules that persists with very low apparent electron temperature. The authors show that the classical coupled rate-equation plus ambipolar hydrodynamic model, even when run on a realistic Gaussian ellipsoidal density distribution, cannot reproduce the observed arrested relaxation for any initial conditions. They propose that dipole-dipole spin-flip-flop and Ising interactions, together with strong quenched disorder, produce many-body localization; predissociation of relaxing NO molecules acts as a self-cleaning mechanism that depletes any delocalizing Griffiths region, preserving the localized state.

Load-bearing premise

The quantum explanation stands on the claim that predissociation of relaxing NO molecules reliably and rapidly removes any local thermal region (a so-called Griffiths region) before it can spread delocalization; if predissociation is too slow or too rare, the system would thermalize and many-body localization would not survive.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

  • The early avalanche remains well described by classical rate equations, but the long-lived arrested state requires a quantum treatment, so future simulations must add spin dynamics to the hydrodynamic model.
  • The Penning fraction, set by initial Rydberg density and principal quantum number, controls whether the plasma reaches the self-assembled, long-lived state or relaxes conventionally.
  • Predissociation acts as a stabilizer unique to molecular plasmas: it deletes the rare thermal regions that would otherwise seed delocalization, a mechanism unavailable in atomic Rydberg gases.
  • Bifurcation and momentum-matching charge exchange channel electron energy into mass transport, explaining the observed separation into recoiling plasma volumes with low internal temperature.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

  • If predissociation is really the purifying agent, tuning the predissociation lifetime (by isotope choice or by selecting different Rydberg series) should switch the plasma between localized and thermalizing behavior; this is a testable consequence the paper does not itself propose.
  • A direct look for many-body-localization signatures, such as slow, logarithmic growth of correlations or persistent memory of the initial density pattern in the ion-Rydberg spin degrees of freedom, would complement the electron-temperature measurements reported here.
  • The same avalanche-to-arrested sequence may appear in other predissociating molecular Rydberg gases in supersonic beams, which would make the claimed phase a general phenomenon rather than a property of one molecule.
Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Referee Report

3 major / 4 minor

Summary. The paper reviews the formation and evolution of ultracold plasmas from state-selected Rydberg gases, with emphasis on the NO molecular ultracold plasma studied by the authors' group. It describes prompt Penning ionization, electron-impact avalanche, coupled rate-equation and shell-model simulations, ambipolar expansion, and bifurcation of the plasma volume. The central new claim, developed in Sections G and H, is that the experimentally observed long-lived, low-temperature state of arrested relaxation cannot be reproduced by any classical rate-equation/hydrodynamic simulation and may constitute a quantum many-body localized (MBL) phase, stabilized by predissociation of Rydberg molecules that depletes rare thermal Griffiths regions. The paper also presents a compact closed-form expression for the initial Penning electron density (Eq. 3) and an empirical scaling law for the avalanche timescale (Eqs. 7–8).

Significance. If the central claim were established, the paper would identify a new experimental platform for studying many-body localization in a strongly coupled ultracold plasma, which would be a notable advance and would connect plasma physics with quantum many-body physics. The review portions accurately summarize the published literature on Rydberg-gas avalanche to plasma, and the paper usefully consolidates the authors' experimental observations of anomalous long lifetime and low apparent electron temperature. The closed-form Penning-density expression (Eq. 3) and the scaled rate-equation collapse (Eqs. 7–8) are practical contributions. However, the manuscript's most distinctive claims—the impossibility of a classical explanation and the predissociation-based purification mechanism—are asserted at a level of generality that exceeds the evidence presented, and the paper currently functions more as a research proposal than as a demonstrated result.

major comments (3)
  1. [Section G, final paragraph] The statement "No combination of initial conditions can produce a simulation that conforms classically with the state of arrested relaxation we observe experimentally" is a universal impossibility claim, but the manuscript reports only the authors' own shell-model simulations for a limited set of initial densities and principal quantum numbers (Figures 3–5), with no systematic variation of ellipsoid aspect ratio, initial electron temperature, or rate coefficients, and no comparison with an independent classical simulation. As written, this conflates "no simulation we tried" with "no classical simulation can," and the claim is load-bearing because the quantum MBL interpretation depends on classical models being excluded. The authors should either restrict the statement to the tested parameter regime or provide a systematic search over initial conditions with a documented classical model.
  2. [Section E, Figures 4–5; Section G] The manuscript does not present a quantitative comparison between the classical shell-model simulation and the experimental observable that defines the arrested-relaxation state, such as the 400 µs flight-time images of Figure 7 or the time-resolved SFI spectra of Figure 2. The claimed failure of the classical model is asserted qualitatively, and no test statistic or quantitative discrepancy is shown. Without a direct, quantitative comparison, the central anomaly of a long-lived cold plasma remains suggestive rather than established, and the need for a non-classical explanation is not demonstrated.
  3. [Section H, final paragraph] The proposed mechanism for protecting localization from Griffiths regions—"the local predissociation of relaxing NO molecules promptly proceeds to deplete that region to a void of no consequence"—is asserted without quantitative support. The manuscript gives no predissociation rate for the relevant nf(2) Rydberg states under plasma conditions, no comparison of that rate with the dipole-dipole energy-transfer timescale that would thermalize a Griffiths region, and no argument that depletion removes the region rather than leaving a dense neutral or ionic remnant that still conducts. Because this mechanism is the paper's answer to the generic expectation that higher-dimensional systems thermalize, it requires at least order-of-magnitude rate estimates and timescale comparisons to be credible.
minor comments (4)
  1. [General manuscript organization] The manuscript contains clearly extraneous inserted material from other documents, including a "PhD Comprehensive Examination Report Kevin Marroquín" heading, repeated passages about a Xe Rydberg-gas experiment, and duplicated figure captions with mismatched numbering. These must be removed before the paper can be considered for publication.
  2. [Section II, Equations 7–8] The empirical sigmoid coefficients a, b, and c in Eq. 7 are fitted to the authors' own rate-equation results; the text should state explicitly that these are empirical fit parameters and give the range of initial densities and principal quantum numbers over which the scaling holds.
  3. [Reference list] The reference list contains numerous formatting errors, such as [18] and [19] listing an unrelated article title ("Exact solutions for matter-enhanced neutrino oscillations") and inconsistent author-name capitalization (e.g., [9], [24], [27]). The bibliography should be carefully corrected.
  4. [Abstract and Introduction] The paper is described as a review, but Sections G and H advance new claims about many-body localization. The authors should clarify whether the paper is intended as a review, a research article, or a combination, and adjust the framing accordingly.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 2.0 of 10

No constructional circularity: the anomaly is experimental, Eq. 7 is openly empirical, and the MBL claim is framed as a suggestion rather than a derived prediction.

full rationale

Walking the claimed derivation chain, I find no step in which a 'prediction' reduces to its own inputs by construction. The arrested-relaxation anomaly is an experimental observation (Figures 2, 6 and 7), independent of all models. The classical description is displayed as coupled rate equations (Eqs. 4-6) and hydrodynamic shell equations (Eqs. 9-12), with rate coefficients validated by independent molecular-dynamics work cited as [41], and Section D supplies an extrinsic early-time check against SFI data. Equation 7 is explicitly labeled by its 'empirical coefficients' and is used only as an internal scaling surrogate for the shell-model visualization, not as a first-principles prediction; the later phrase 'scaled to agree with the simulated ion density at the elapsed time of 100 ns' makes the non-independence explicit rather than hidden. The Section G statement that 'No combination of initial conditions can produce a simulation that conforms classically with the state of arrested relaxation we observe experimentally' is an overbroad negative based on the authors' own finite simulation set, but that is an evidential or correctness limitation, not a circular reduction. Likewise, the Section H MBL suggestion is introduced with 'one can make a case' and 'We suggest', and its Griffiths-region purification by predissociation is a qualitative assumption lacking a numerical rate comparison; again this is unsupported assumption, not a definitional loop. The numerous self-citations [50-57] point to work whose equations and observations are reproduced or independently falsifiable in this paper, so they do not operate as an unverified uniqueness import. The score of 2 reflects the heavily self-referential framing and the overbroad classical-exclusion claim, but no specific equation or fitted parameter is silently renamed as an independent prediction.

Assumptions & free parameters 1 free parameters · 4 assumptions · 0 invented entities

The central new interpretation rests on the rate-equation and shell model, which depends on external rate coefficients and several domain assumptions, and on a speculative spin-model mechanism for many-body localization. The empirical sigmoid (Eq 7) is fitted to the authors' own simulations, and the 'failure of classical models' claim is based on the authors' own code with no external benchmark.

free parameters (1)
  • Empirical sigmoid coefficients a, b, c (Eq 7) = a=0.00062, b=0.00082, c=0.075
    These coefficients set the scaled avalanche rate rho_e/rho0 = a/(b + exp(-c tau)); the paper calls them empirical, and they are fitted to the authors' own rate-equation simulations rather than derived from first principles.
assumptions (4)
  • domain assumption MD-validated rate coefficients k_ij, k_i,ion, k_i,tbr from Pohl et al. (2008)
    The coupled rate equations (Eqs 4-5) rely on external molecular-dynamics-calibrated rate coefficients; the avalanche predictions inherit the accuracy of those coefficients.
  • domain assumption Local space charge confines electrons to shells, conserving quasi-neutrality
    Stated in Section II.E; the shell-model expansion and electron temperature evolution assume this confinement.
  • domain assumption Resonant ion-Rydberg charge exchange redistributes the ambipolar force, represented by effective ion mass m' = (1 + rho*/rho) m (Eq 12)
    This effective-mass ansatz is introduced to capture momentum sharing between ions and Rydberg molecules; it is not derived in this paper.
  • ad hoc to paper Predissociation of relaxing NO molecules depletes Griffiths regions and preserves localization
    This is the key mechanism in Section II.H that protects the hypothesized many-body localized state from thermal regions; it is asserted without quantitative support in this review.

how reviews work

0 comments
Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Dissipative dynamics of atomic and molecular Rydberg gases: Avalanche to ultracold plasma states of strong coupling." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/3MFJS72X

@misc{pith2026190807633,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Dissipative dynamics of atomic and molecular Rydberg gases: Avalanche to ultracold plasma states of strong coupling},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/3MFJS72X}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:1908.07633}
}
read the original abstract

Not long after metastable xenon was photoionized in a magneto-optical trap, groups in Europe and North America found that similar states of ionized gas evolved spontaneously from state-selected, high principal quantum number Rydberg gases. Studies of atomic xenon and molecular nitric oxide entrained in a supersonically cooled molecular beam subsequently showed much the same final state evolved from a sequence of prompt Penning ionization and electron-impact avalanche to plasma, well-described by coupled rate-equation simulations. But, measured over longer times, the molecular ultracold plasma was found to exhibit an anomalous combination of very long lifetime and very low apparent electron temperature. This review summarizes early developments in the study of ultracold plasmas formed by atomic and molecular Rydberg gases, and then details observations as they combine to characterize properties of the nitric oxide molecular ultracold plasma that appear to call for an explanation beyond the realm of conventional plasma physics.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 1908.07633 by the authors.

Figure 1
Figure 1. Distributions of ion-ion nearest neighbours [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p004_1.png] view at source ↗
Figure 2
Figure 2. Ramp Q3 pulse used to obtain field-ionization spectra of Xe Rydberg states. A tuned RC circuit produces a pulsed electrostatic field that rises to 838 V cm−1 with a time constant of three μs [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p005_2.png] view at source ↗
Figure 5
Figure 5. Global population fractions of particles as they [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p006_5.png] view at source ↗
Figures from the paper (3 more)
Figure 4
Figure 4. Figure 4: (top frame) Cross-sectional contour diagram in the [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p006_4.png]
Figure 18
Figure 18. Figure 18: Rydberg spectra for di↵erent ⇢0. From top to bottom in [µm￾3]=0.07, 0.10, 0.13, 0.19, 0.27, 0.30, 0.32 and 3 23 30,300 30400 30,500 ω2 frequency (cm-1) [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p007_18.png]
Figure 7
Figure 7. Figure 7: x, y detector images of ultracold plasma volumes produced by 2:1 aspect ratio ellipsoidal Rydberg gases with selected initial state, 40f(2) after a flight time of 402 µs over a distance of 575 mm. Lower frame displays the distribution in x of the charge integrated in y…

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

73 extracted references · 73 canonical work pages

  1. [1]

    Science 1991, 252(5004):384–389

    Van Horn HM: Dense Astrophysical Plasmas . Science 1991, 252(5004):384–389

    work page 1991

  2. [2]

    This causes mixing with core penetrating states that are strongly dissociative

    This close-coupled interaction disrupts the separability of Rydberg orbital configurations in the Penning partner. This causes mixing with core penetrating states that are strongly dissociative. Penning partners are thus very likely to dissociate, leaving a spatially isolated distribution of ions. We refer to the spatial correlation that results as a Penni...

    work page

  3. [5]

    Results 3.1. Preparation of the Xe Rydberg gas Withω1set to excite the transition in Xe from Xe⎡⎣⎤⎦pp5P 6 [5/2]523/222, we tuneω2over a range from 515 nmto 508 nm, which drives absorption from thep6state toRydberg states in thensandndseries with an initial principalquantum number ranging from=n300to 70. Using a for-ward-bias high-voltage pulse, applied to...

    work page 2014

  4. [6]

    Results 3.1. Preparation of the Xe Rydberg gas Withω1set to excite the transition in Xe from Xe⎡⎣⎤⎦pp5P 6 [5/2]523/222, we tuneω2over a range from 515 nmto 508 nm, which drives absorption from thep6state toRydberg states in thensandndseries with an initial principalquantum number ranging from=n300to 70. Using a for-ward-bias high-voltage pulse, applied to...

    work page 2014

  5. [7]

    Reviews of Modern Physics 1993, 65(2):301–336

    Burrows A, Liebert J: The science of brown dwarfs . Reviews of Modern Physics 1993, 65(2):301–336

    work page 1993

  6. [8]

    Reviews of Modern Physics 1976, 48(2):239–308

    Hinton FL, Hazeltine RD: Theory of plasma trans- port in toroidal confinement systems . Reviews of Modern Physics 1976, 48(2):239–308

    work page 1976

  7. [9]

    Reviews of Modern Physics 1993, 65(2):255–299

    Ichimaru S: Nuclear fusion in dense plasmas . Reviews of Modern Physics 1993, 65(2):255–299

    work page 1993

  8. [10]

    Beam plasma interaction hydrodynamics, hot dense matter, Clarendon Press - Oxford 2009

    Atzeni S, Meyer-ter Vehn J: The physics of inertial fusion. Beam plasma interaction hydrodynamics, hot dense matter, Clarendon Press - Oxford 2009

    work page 2009

Show all 73 references
  1. [11]

    Reviews of Modern Physics 2005, 76(4):1071– 9 1141

    Boozer AH: Physics of magnetically confined plasmas. Reviews of Modern Physics 2005, 76(4):1071– 9 1141

    2005

  2. [12]

    Physical Review Letters 2004, 93(13):531

    Rousse A, Phuoc KT, Shah R, Pukhov A, Lefebvre E, Malka V, Kiselev S, Burgy F, Rousseau JP, Umstadter D, Hulin D: Production of a keV X-Ray Beam from Synchrotron Radiation in Relativistic Laser- Plasma Interaction . Physical Review Letters 2004, 93(13):531

    2004

  3. [13]

    Reviews of Modern Physics 2009, 81(3):1229–1285

    Esarey E, Schroeder CB, Leemans WP: Physics of laser-driven plasma-based electron accelerators . Reviews of Modern Physics 2009, 81(3):1229–1285

    2009

  4. [14]

    Journal of the Optical Society of America B 2003, 50:1091–1097

    Gallagher T, Pillet p, Robinson M, Laburthe B: Back and forth between Rydberg atoms and ultracold plasmas. Journal of the Optical Society of America B 2003, 50:1091–1097

    2003

  5. [15]

    Science 2007, 316:705–708

    Killian T: Ultracold Neutral Plasmas . Science 2007, 316:705–708

    2007

  6. [16]

    Physics Reports 2007, 449:77–130

    Killian T, Pattard T, Pohl T, Rost J:Ultracold neutral plasmas. Physics Reports 2007, 449:77–130

    2007

  7. [17]

    Lyon M, Rolston SL: Ultracold neutral plasmas. Rep. Prog. Phys. 2017, 80:017001

    2017

  8. [18]

    Zeitschrift f¨ ur Naturforschung 1993, 48 a(12):1256–1259

    Scherzer WG, Selzle HL, Schlag EW: Long lived ZEKE states above the ionization threshold. Zeitschrift f¨ ur Naturforschung 1993, 48 a(12):1256–1259

    1993

  9. [19]

    Alt C, Scherzer WG, Selzle HL, Schlag EW: Can molecular ZEKE states be generated by Rydberg electron pickup? Chemical Physics Letters 1994, 224(3-4):366–370

    1994

  10. [20]

    Physical Review Letters 1999, 83(23):4776– 4779

    Killian TC, Kulin S, Bergeson SD, Orozco LA, Orzel C, Rolston SL: Creation of an Ultracold Neutral Plasma. Physical Review Letters 1999, 83(23):4776– 4779

    1999

  11. [21]

    Physical Review Letters 2002, 88(6):4776

    Kuzmin SG, ONeil TM: Numerical Simulation of Ultracold Plasmas: How Rapid Intrinsic Heating Limits the Development of Correlation . Physical Review Letters 2002, 88(6):4776

    2002

  12. [22]

    Exact solutions for matter-enhanced neutrino oscillations 2002, 88(5)

    Robicheaux F, Hanson JD: Simulation of the Ex- pansion of an Ultracold Neutral Plasma . Exact solutions for matter-enhanced neutrino oscillations 2002, 88(5)

    2002

  13. [23]

    Exact solutions for matter- enhanced neutrino oscillations 2007, 99(15):155001

    Laha S, Gupta P, Simien CE, Gao H, Castro J, Pohl T, Killian TC: Experimental Realization of an Exact Solution to the Vlasov Equations for an Expanding Plasma . Exact solutions for matter- enhanced neutrino oscillations 2007, 99(15):155001

    2007

  14. [24]

    Physical Review X 2016, 6(2):154

    Strickler TS, Langin TK, Mcquillen P, Daligault J, Killian TC: Experimental Measurement of Self- Diffusion in a Strongly Coupled Plasma . Physical Review X 2016, 6(2):154

    2016

  15. [25]

    Phys Rev Lett 1998, 80(2):253–256

    Mourachko I, Comparat D, de Tomasi F, Fioretti A, Nosbaum P, Akulin VM, Pillet p: Many-Body Effects in a Frozen Rydberg Gas . Phys Rev Lett 1998, 80(2):253–256

    1998

  16. [26]

    Phys Rev Lett 2001, 86(17):3759

    Killian TC, Lim MJ, Dumke R, Bergeson SD, Rolston SL: Formation of Rydberg Atoms in an Expanding Ultracold Neutral Plasma . Phys Rev Lett 2001, 86(17):3759

    2001

  17. [27]

    Vitrant G, Raimond J, Gross M, Haroche S: Rydberg to plasma evolution in a dense gas of very excited atoms. J. Phys. B 1982, 15:L49–L55

    1982

  18. [28]

    Phys Rev A 2004, 70(4):10

    Li W, Noel MW, Robinson MP, Tanner PJ, Gallagher TF, Comparat D, Tolra BL, Vanhaecke N, Vogt T, Zahzam N, Pillet P, Tate DA: Evolution dynamics of a dense frozen Rydberg gas to plasma . Phys Rev A 2004, 70(4):10

    2004

  19. [29]

    Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2005

    Comparat D, Vogt T, Zahzam N, Mudrich M, Pillet p: Star cluster dynamics in a laboratory: electrons in an ultracold plasma . Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society 2005

    2005

  20. [30]

    Phys Rev Lett 2008, 100(4):B6

    Tanner PJ, Han J, Shuman ES, Gallagher TF: Many- Body Ionization in a Frozen Rydberg Gas . Phys Rev Lett 2008, 100(4):B6

    2008

  21. [31]

    Phys Rev A 2008, 78(4):040704

    Viteau M, Chotia A, Comparat D, Tate DA, Gallagher TF, Pillet P: Melting a frozen Rydberg gas with an attractive potential. Phys Rev A 2008, 78(4):040704

    2008

  22. [32]

    J of Phys: Conf Ser 2009, 194:012066

    Pillet p, Vogt T, Viteau M, Chotia A, Zhao J, Comparat D, Gallagher TF, Tate D, Ga¨ etan A, Miroshnychenko Y, Wilk T, Browaeys A, Grangier P: Controllable in- teractions between Rydberg atoms and ultracold plasmas. J of Phys: Conf Ser 2009, 194:012066

    2009

  23. [33]

    Phys Rev A 2013, 87:013407

    Mcquillen P, Zhang X, Strickler T, Dunning FB, Killian TC: Imaging the evolution of an ultracold strontium Rydberg gas. Phys Rev A 2013, 87:013407

    2013

  24. [34]

    Phys Rev A 2005

    Vanhaecke N, Comparat D, Tate D, Pillet p: Ionization of Rydberg atoms embedded in an ultracold plasma. Phys Rev A 2005

    2005

  25. [35]

    Phys Rev Lett 2007, 98(2):023004

    Amthor T, Reetz-Lamour M, Westermann S, Denskat J, Weidem¨ uller M: Mechanical Effect of van der Waals Interactions Observed in Real Time in an Ultracold Rydberg Gas . Phys Rev Lett 2007, 98(2):023004

    2007

  26. [36]

    Phys Rev A 2007, 76(5):054702

    Amthor T, Reetz-Lamour M, Giese C, Weidem¨ uller M: Modeling many-particle mechanical effects of an interacting Rydberg gas . Phys Rev A 2007, 76(5):054702

    2007

  27. [37]

    Phys Rev Lett 2013, 110:045004

    Robert-de-Saint-Vincent M, Hofmann CS, Schempp H, G¨ unter G, Whitlock S, Weidem¨ uller M:Spontaneous Avalanche Ionization of a Strongly Blockaded Rydberg Gas. Phys Rev Lett 2013, 110:045004

    2013

  28. [38]

    Phys Rev A 2014, 90(2):022712

    Robicheaux F, Goforth MM, Phillips MA: Simulations of prompt many-body ionization in a frozen Rydberg gas. Phys Rev A 2014, 90(2):022712

    2014

  29. [39]

    Phys Rev A 2006, 73(2):020704

    Knuffman B, Raithel G: Emission of fast atoms from a cold Rydberg gas . Phys Rev A 2006, 73(2):020704

    2006

  30. [40]

    Phys Rev Lett 2001, 86(18):3993–3996

    Dutta SK, Feldbaum D, Walz-Flannigan A, Guest JR, Raithel G: High-Angular-Momentum States in Cold Rydberg Gases . Phys Rev Lett 2001, 86(18):3993–3996

    2001

  31. [41]

    Phys Rev A 2004, 69(6):063405

    Walz-Flannigan A, Guest JR, Choi JH, Raithel G: Cold-Rydberg-gas dynamics . Phys Rev A 2004, 69(6):063405

    2004

  32. [42]

    J Phys B 2014, 47:155301

    Hung J, Sadeghi H, Schluz-Weiling M, Grant E: Evolution from Rydberg gas to ultracold plasma in a supersonic atomic beam of Xe . J Phys B 2014, 47:155301

    2014

  33. [43]

    J Phys B 2005, 38:S333–S342

    Robicheaux F: Ionization due to the interaction between two Rydberg atoms . J Phys B 2005, 38:S333–S342

    2005

  34. [44]

    Phys Rev A 2003, 68:010703(R)

    Pohl T, Pattard T, Rost JM: Plasma formation from ultracold Rydberg gases . Phys Rev A 2003, 68:010703(R)

    2003

  35. [45]

    Physical Review A 2004, 70(3):33416

    Pohl T, Pattard T, Rost J: Kinetic modeling and molecular dynamics simulation of ultracold neu- tral plasmas including ionic correlations . Physical Review A 2004, 70(3):33416

    2004

  36. [46]

    Pohl T, Vrinceanu D, Sadeghpour HR: Rydberg Atom Formation in Ultracold Plasmas: Small Energy Transfer with Large Consequences. Phys. Rev. Lett. 2008, 100:223201. 10

    2008

  37. [47]

    Phys Rev A 2011, 84(5):052710

    Bannasch G, Pohl T: Rydberg-atom formation in strongly correlated ultracold plasmas . Phys Rev A 2011, 84(5):052710

    2011

  38. [48]

    Phys Rev Lett 2013, 110(25):253003

    Bannasch G, Killian TC, Pohl T: Strongly Coupled Plasmas via Rydberg Blockade of Cold Atoms . Phys Rev Lett 2013, 110(25):253003

    2013

  39. [49]

    Phys Rev A 2018, 97(4):043401

    Forest GT, Li Y, Ward ED, Goodsell AL, Tate DA: Expansion of an ultracold Rydberg plasma . Phys Rev A 2018, 97(4):043401

    2018

  40. [50]

    Phys Rev A 2018, 98(4):043431

    Crockett EV, Newell RC, Robicheaux F, Tate DA: Heating and cooling of electrons in an ultracold neutral plasma using Rydberg atoms . Phys Rev A 2018, 98(4):043431

    2018

  41. [51]

    Phys Rev Lett 2008, 101:205005

    Morrison JP, Rennick CJ, Keller JS, Grant ER: Evolu- tion from a molecular Rydberg gas to an ultracold plasma in a seeded supersonic expansion of NO . Phys Rev Lett 2008, 101:205005

    2008

  42. [52]

    Phys Rev A 2009, 79:062706

    Morrison JP, Rennick CJ, Grant ER: The very slow expansion of an ultracold plasma formed in a seeded supersonic molecular beam of NO . Phys Rev A 2009, 79:062706

    2009

  43. [53]

    Phys Rev A 2015, 91:023423

    Morrison JP, Grant ER: Dynamics of colliding ultracold plasmas. Phys Rev A 2015, 91:023423

    2015

  44. [54]

    Sadeghi H, Schulz-Weiling M, Morrison JP, Yiu JCH, Saquet N, Rennick CJ, Grant ER: Molecular ion– electron recombination in an expanding ultracold neutral plasma of NO +. Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2011, 13:18872

    2011

  45. [55]

    J Phys B 2011, 44:184015

    Saquet N, Morrison JP, Schulz-Weiling M, Sadeghi H, Yiu J, Rennick CJ, Grant ER: On the formation and decay of a molecular ultracold plasma . J Phys B 2011, 44:184015

    2011

  46. [56]

    J Phys B 2012, 45:175302

    Saquet N, Morrison JP, Grant E: Recombinative dissociation and the evolution of a molecular ultracold plasma. J Phys B 2012, 45:175302

    2012

  47. [57]

    Morrison JP, Saquet N, Grant ER: Classical scaling and the correspondence between the coupled rate equation and molecular dynamics models for the evolution of ultracold neutral plasma . J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys 2012, 45(2):025701–7

    2012

  48. [58]

    Chemical Physics 2018, 514:55–66

    Haenel R, Grant ER: Coupled rate-equation hydro- dynamic simulation of a Rydberg gas Gaussian ellipsoid: Classical avalanche and evolution to molecular plasma. Chemical Physics 2018, 514:55–66

    2018

  49. [59]

    Phys Rev A 2017, 96:23613

    Haenel R, Schulz-Weiling M, Sous J, Sadeghi H, Aghigh M, Melo L, Keller JS, Grant ER: Arrested relaxation in an isolated molecular ultracold plasma. Phys Rev A 2017, 96:23613

    2017

  50. [60]

    Phys Rev Lett 2018, 120:110601

    Sous J, Grant ER: Possible many-body localization in a long-lived finite-temperature ultracold quasi- neutral molecular plasma . Phys Rev Lett 2018, 120:110601

    2018

  51. [61]

    New J Phys 2019, 21:043033

    Sous J, Grant ER: Many-body physics with ul- tracold plasmas: quenched randomness and localization. New J Phys 2019, 21:043033

    2019

  52. [62]

    Schulz-Weiling M, Grant ER: Quantum state control of ultracold plasma fission. J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys 2016, 49(064009)

    2016

  53. [63]

    J Phys B 2016, 49:193001

    Schulz-Weiling M, Sadeghi H, Hung J, Grant ER: On the evolution of the phase-space distributions of a non-spherical molecular ultracold plasma in supersonic beam. J Phys B 2016, 49:193001

    2016

  54. [64]

    J Chem Phys 2009, 130(20):204302

    Settersten TB, Patterson BD, Carter CD: Collisional quenching of NO A 2Σ+ (v = 0) between 125 and 294 K. J Chem Phys 2009, 130(20):204302

    2009

  55. [65]

    Few J, Hancock G: Rate constants for collisional quenching of NO (A 2Σ+, v = 0) by He, Ne, Ar, Kr, and Xe, and infrared emission accompanying rare gas and impurity quenching . Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 2014, 16(22):11047–11053

    2014

  56. [66]

    Physical Review A 1990, 41(4):2059–2075

    Torquato S, Lu B, Rubinstein J: Nearest-neighbor distribution functions in many-body systems . Physical Review A 1990, 41(4):2059–2075

    1990

  57. [67]

    Phys Rev Lett 2014, 112:075001

    Sadeghi H, Kruyen A, Hung J, Gurian JH, Morrison JP, Schulz-Weiling M, Saquet N, Rennick CJ, Grant ER: Dissociation and the development of spatial correlation in a molecular ultracold plasma . Phys Rev Lett 2014, 112:075001

    2014

  58. [68]

    Physical Review A 2012, 86(5)

    Sadeghi H, Grant ER: Dissociative recombination slows the expansion of a molecular ultracold plasma. Physical Review A 2012, 86(5)

    2012

  59. [69]

    Physical Review A 2003, 68:010703 R

    Pohl T, Pattard T, Rost JM: Plasma formation from ultracold Rydberg gases . Physical Review A 2003, 68:010703 R

    2003

  60. [70]

    Burin AL: Localization in a random XY model with long-range interactions: Intermediate case between single-particle and many-body problems. Phys. Rev. B 2015, 92:104428

    2015

  61. [71]

    Phys Rev X 2017, 7:041021

    Nandkishore RM, Sondhi SL: Many body localization with long range interactions . Phys Rev X 2017, 7:041021

    2017

  62. [72]

    Gopalakrishnan S, Agarwal K, Demler EA, Huse DA, Knap M: Griffiths effects and slow dynamics in nearly many-body localized systems . Phys. Rev. B 2016, 93:134206

    2016

  63. [73]

    De Roeck W, Huveneers F: Stability and instability towards delocalization in many-body localization systems. Phys. Rev. B 2017, 95:155129

    2017

  64. [74]

    Agarwal K, Altman E, Demler E, Gopalakrishnan S, Huse DA, Knap M: Rare-region effects and dynam- ics near the many-body localization transition . Ann. Phys. (Amsterdam) 2017, 529(7):1600326

    2017

  65. [75]

    Ponte P, Laumann CR, Huse DA, Chandran A:Thermal inclusions: how one spin can destroy a many- body localized phase. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 2017, 375(2108):20160428

    2017

Pith tools

Reviewed August 14, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.