Nonparametric identification and efficient estimation of causal effects with instrumental variables

Instrumental variables are widely used in econometrics and epidemiology for identifying and estimating causal effects when an exposure of interest is confounded by unmeasured factors. Despite this popularity, the assumptions invoked to justify the use of instruments differ substantially across the literature. Similarly, statistical approaches for estimating the resulting causal quantities vary considerably, and often rely on strong parametric assumptions. In this work, we compile and organize structural conditions that nonparametrically identify conditional average treatment effects, average treatment effects among the treated, and local average treatment effects, with a focus on identification formulae invoking the conditional Wald estimand. Moreover, we build upon existing work and propose nonparametric efficient estimators of functionals corresponding to marginal and conditional causal contrasts resulting from the various identification paradigms. We illustrate the proposed methods on an observational study examining the effects of operative care on adverse events for cholecystitis patients, and a randomized trial assessing the effects of market participation on political views.