arxiv: 2604.12980 · v1 · submitted 2026-04-14 · ✦ hep-th · gr-qc

Recognition: unknown

State counting in gravity and maximal entropy principle

Juan Hernandez , Mikhail Khramtsov

Authors on Pith no claims yet

Pith reviewed 2026-05-10 15:37 UTC · model grok-4.3

classification ✦ hep-th gr-qc

keywords black hole microstatesBekenstein-Hawking entropyHawking radiationPage curveinformation paradoxgravity path integralvon Neumann entropyconvex optimization

0 comments

The pith

State counting for black holes and the Page curve for Hawking radiation are equivalent in the gravity path integral.

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The paper aims to establish that counting microstates to account for the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy is the same task as recovering the unitary Page curve for the entanglement entropy of Hawking radiation, when both are analyzed through the semiclassical gravity path integral. If this holds, the information loss puzzle is resolved as soon as any overcomplete basis of microstates whose number matches the known entropy is inserted into the path integral. A convex optimization problem that maximizes the von Neumann entropy of the radiation under path-integral constraints supplies the mathematical link between the two descriptions. Readers would care because the equivalence shows that unitarity in radiation does not require extra structure beyond entropy-compatible state counting.

Core claim

It is known that the semiclassical approximation to the gravity path integral can be leveraged to explain certain inherently quantum aspects of gravity. One such aspect is the state-counting interpretation of the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy of black holes. A second aspect is the Page curve for the entanglement entropy of Hawking radiation, which agrees with expectations from unitarity. We show that these two questions are equivalent from the gravity path integral point of view. In particular, the Hawking's information loss puzzle gets resolved automatically by considering any (over)complete basis of black hole microstates which is compatible with black hole entropy. The tool which relates the

What carries the argument

The convex optimization problem for the von Neumann entropy of Hawking radiation, which equates the state-counting question with the derivation of the Page curve under path-integral constraints.

If this is right

The information loss puzzle is resolved automatically once any entropy-compatible basis is used.
The Page curve emerges for every overcomplete basis that reproduces the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy.
No additional microscopic details beyond entropy matching are required for unitarity in the radiation.
Semiclassical path integrals alone suffice to encode both the counting and the unitary evolution.

Where Pith is reading between the lines

These are editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

The same optimization lens could be applied to other gravitational systems where state counting and radiation entropy appear together.
If the equivalence persists beyond the semiclassical regime, it supplies a selection criterion for consistent bases in full quantum gravity.

Load-bearing premise

The semiclassical approximation to the gravity path integral suffices to capture the quantum aspects of black hole entropy and radiation, and that there exists an overcomplete basis of microstates compatible with the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy.

What would settle it

An explicit computation in a controlled model that uses a complete microstate basis matching the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy yet produces a radiation von Neumann entropy deviating from the Page curve would falsify the equivalence.

read the original abstract

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, simulated authors' rebuttal, and a circularity audit. Tearing a paper down is the easy half of reading it; the pith above is the substance, this is the friction.

Desk Editor's Note private letter to a colleague

The paper claims that any compatible overcomplete microstate basis in the semiclassical path integral automatically resolves the information loss puzzle through convex optimization on radiation entropy, but the argument lacks explicit derivations and risks circularity.

read the letter

The main point is that the authors treat the Bekenstein-Hawking state counting and the unitary Page curve as equivalent problems in the gravity path integral. They say any overcomplete basis of microstates that matches the black hole entropy will produce the correct radiation entropy via a convex optimization step, so the information puzzle disappears without extra work.

Referee Report

2 major / 1 minor

Summary. The manuscript claims that the state-counting interpretation of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy and the unitary Page curve for Hawking radiation are equivalent problems when viewed through the semiclassical gravity path integral. It asserts that the black hole information loss puzzle is resolved automatically upon inserting any (over)complete basis of microstates compatible with the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy, with the link provided by a convex optimization problem that extremizes the von Neumann entropy of the Hawking radiation.

Significance. If the claimed equivalence can be derived explicitly, the result would unify two previously separate applications of the gravity path integral (microstate counting and entanglement entropy evolution) and show that unitarity follows without additional input once a compatible basis is chosen. This would strengthen the case that semiclassical gravity already encodes key quantum features of black holes, provided the optimization is shown to be non-tautological and independent of the specific basis choice.

major comments (2)

[Abstract] The abstract states that the two questions are equivalent and that the information puzzle is resolved by any compatible basis, but supplies neither the explicit form of the convex optimization functional for the radiation von Neumann entropy nor the construction of the (over)complete microstate basis. Without these, it is impossible to verify that the optimization enforces the Page curve independently of the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy being inserted by hand.
[Main text (equivalence argument)] The weakest assumption—that the semiclassical saddle-point structure of the path integral is preserved when an overcomplete basis is inserted—requires explicit demonstration. The manuscript must show that the basis insertion does not modify the on-shell action or the entropy counting that reproduces S_BH, otherwise the claimed automatic resolution may be circular.

minor comments (1)

[Abstract] Notation for the von Neumann entropy functional and the basis states should be introduced with explicit definitions before the optimization is stated.

Simulated Author's Rebuttal

2 responses · 0 unresolved

We thank the referee for the careful reading and insightful comments on our manuscript. We address each major point below, providing clarifications on the convex optimization setup and the basis insertion. We agree that greater explicitness in the abstract would aid verification and will revise accordingly, while maintaining that the equivalence is non-circular.

read point-by-point responses

Referee: [Abstract] The abstract states that the two questions are equivalent and that the information puzzle is resolved by any compatible basis, but supplies neither the explicit form of the convex optimization functional for the radiation von Neumann entropy nor the construction of the (over)complete microstate basis. Without these, it is impossible to verify that the optimization enforces the Page curve independently of the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy being inserted by hand.

Authors: The abstract is intentionally concise as a summary. The explicit convex optimization is formulated in the main text as the minimization of the von Neumann entropy S_vN of the Hawking radiation reduced density matrix, subject to the constraint that the black hole microstates form an (over)complete basis with dimension exp(S_BH) as determined by the gravity path integral. The basis construction is any set of states whose degeneracy reproduces the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy when inserted into the semiclassical saddles. This optimization directly yields the Page curve as the extremal configuration. To improve accessibility and address the verification concern, we will revise the abstract to include a brief statement of the optimization functional and basis compatibility condition. revision: partial
Referee: [Main text (equivalence argument)] The weakest assumption—that the semiclassical saddle-point structure of the path integral is preserved when an overcomplete basis is inserted—requires explicit demonstration. The manuscript must show that the basis insertion does not modify the on-shell action or the entropy counting that reproduces S_BH, otherwise the claimed automatic resolution may be circular.

Authors: The basis insertion preserves the semiclassical saddle-point structure because the microstates are chosen to be compatible with the fixed geometric background and boundary conditions of the original path integral; they contribute only to the degeneracy factor without altering the Einstein-Hilbert action or the on-shell value that yields S_BH. The entropy counting for S_BH remains unchanged as it arises from the same saddles, while the convex optimization over radiation von Neumann entropy selects the unitary Page curve independently of the specific basis details (provided the dimension matches). This avoids circularity since the optimization is a separate convex problem linking the two. We will add an explicit paragraph in the main text demonstrating that the modified measure does not shift the saddle points or on-shell action. revision: partial

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged

No significant circularity; equivalence derived from path-integral structure rather than definitional reduction

full rationale

The paper establishes an equivalence between the state-counting interpretation of Bekenstein-Hawking entropy and the unitary Page curve by framing both as outputs of the same semiclassical gravity path integral when an (over)complete microstate basis compatible with the entropy is inserted. The convex optimization on von Neumann entropy of radiation is presented as the relating tool. No quoted equation or step reduces the final result to the input basis choice by construction; the compatibility condition is an assumption whose consequences are then derived, not presupposed to force the Page curve. Self-citations, if present, are not load-bearing for the central equivalence claim. The derivation remains self-contained against external benchmarks such as the known semiclassical entropy and Page curve calculations.

Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger

0 free parameters · 2 axioms · 0 invented entities

Based solely on the abstract, the claim rests on the validity of the semiclassical gravity path integral for quantum effects and the existence of a microstate basis whose entropy matches the Bekenstein-Hawking value. No free parameters, axioms, or invented entities are explicitly listed.

axioms (2)

domain assumption Semiclassical approximation to the gravity path integral captures inherently quantum aspects such as state counting and entanglement entropy.
Stated in the first sentence of the abstract as the foundation for both aspects discussed.
domain assumption There exists an (over)complete basis of black hole microstates compatible with black hole entropy.
Invoked to resolve the information loss puzzle automatically.

pith-pipeline@v0.9.0 · 5406 in / 1475 out tokens · 52136 ms · 2026-05-10T15:37:29.348149+00:00 · methodology

discussion (0)

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

20 extracted references · 11 canonical work pages

[1]

Bekenstein,Black holes and entropy,Phys

J.D. Bekenstein,Black holes and entropy,Phys. Rev. D7(1973) 2333

1973
[2]

Hawking,Particle Creation by Black Holes,Commun

S.W. Hawking,Particle Creation by Black Holes,Commun. Math. Phys.43(1975) 199

1975
[3]

Gibbons and S.W

G.W. Gibbons and S.W. Hawking,Action integrals and partition functions in quantum gravity,Physical Review D15(1977) 2752

1977
[4]

Strominger and C

A. Strominger and C. Vafa,Microscopic origin of the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy, Physics Letters B379(1996) 99 [9601029]

1996
[5]

Balasubramanian, A

V. Balasubramanian, A. Lawrence, J.M. Magan and M. Sasieta,Microscopic Origin of the Entropy of Black Holes in General Relativity,Phys. Rev. X14(2024) 011024 [2212.02447]

work page arXiv 2024
[6]

Balasubramanian, A

V. Balasubramanian, A. Lawrence, J.M. Magan and M. Sasieta,Microscopic Origin of the Entropy of Astrophysical Black Holes,Physical Review Letters132(2024) 141501 [2212.08623]

work page arXiv 2024
[7]

Climent, R

A. Climent, R. Emparan, J.M. Mag´ an, M. Sasieta and A. Vilar L´ opez,Universal construction of black hole microstates,Physical Review D109(2024) 1 [2401.08775]

work page arXiv 2024
[8]

Balasubramanian, B

V. Balasubramanian, B. Craps, J. Hernandez, M. Khramtsov and M. Knysh, Factorization of the Hilbert space of eternal black holes in general relativity,JHEP01 (2025) 046 [2410.00091]

work page arXiv 2025
[9]

Balasubramanian and T

V. Balasubramanian and T. Yildirim,How to Count States in Gravity,2506.15767

work page arXiv
[10]

Hawking,Breakdown of Predictability in Gravitational Collapse,Phys

S.W. Hawking,Breakdown of Predictability in Gravitational Collapse,Phys. Rev. D14 (1976) 2460

1976
[11]

Page,Average entropy of a subsystem,Physical Review Letters71(1993) 1291 [9305007]

D.N. Page,Average entropy of a subsystem,Physical Review Letters71(1993) 1291 [9305007]

1993
[12]

Page,Information in black hole radiation,Physical Review Letters71(1993) 3743 [9306083]

D.N. Page,Information in black hole radiation,Physical Review Letters71(1993) 3743 [9306083]

1993
[13]

Penington, S

G. Penington, S.H. Shenker, D. Stanford and Z. Yang,Replica wormholes and the black hole interior,Journal of High Energy Physics2022(2022) [1911.11977]. 10

work page arXiv 2022
[14]

Almheiri, T

A. Almheiri, T. Hartman, J. Maldacena, E. Shaghoulian and A. Tajdini,Replica wormholes and the entropy of Hawking radiation,Journal of High Energy Physics2020 (2020) 1 [1911.12333]

work page arXiv 2020
[15]

Almheiri, T

A. Almheiri, T. Hartman, J. Maldacena, E. Shaghoulian and A. Tajdini,The entropy of Hawking radiation,Reviews of Modern Physics93(2021) [2006.06872]

work page arXiv 2021
[16]

Expanding the Black Hole Interior: Partially Entangled Thermal States in SYK

A. Goel, H.T. Lam, G.J. Turiaci and H. Verlinde,Expanding the Black Hole Interior: Partially Entangled Thermal States in SYK,JHEP02(2019) 156 [1807.03916]

work page Pith review arXiv 2019
[17]

Balasubramanian and T

V. Balasubramanian and T. Yildirim,The nonperturbative Hilbert space of quantum gravity with one boundary,JHEP03(2026) 040 [2506.04319]

work page arXiv 2026
[18]

Israel,Singular hypersurfaces and thin shells in general relativity,Nuovo Cim

W. Israel,Singular hypersurfaces and thin shells in general relativity,Nuovo Cim. B 44S10(1966) 1

1966
[19]

Balasubramanian, B

V. Balasubramanian, B. Craps, J. Hernandez, M. Khramtsov and M. Knysh,Counting microstates of out-of-equilibrium black hole fluctuations,JHEP06(2025) 083 [2412.06884]

work page arXiv 2025
[20]

Boyd and L

S. Boyd and L. Vandenberghe,Convex optimization, Cambridge university press (2004). 11

2004