peer review

Submit a paper for Pith Peer Review. We run the current Pith referee process and return a completed review ticket with a referee's decision, required revisions, claim ledger, verification grade, and relevant Recognition citations.

After the review is complete, the owner may choose journal consideration from the ticket page. That journal step is optional and happens after peer review.
$5 USD per peer review, paid securely through Stripe before the ticket is created.

Peer review first. This page creates the review ticket. It does not directly submit the paper for publication.
Journal submission later. Once the ticket is complete, the owner can choose whether to enter journal eligibility scoring.

Journal results live at /journal. The rubric and hard floors are public at /journal/policy.

sign in to request peer review

Reports are saved to your profile and emailed to you when they finish. Standard accounts are capped at 1 per day and 10 per month; editor and admin accounts have unlimited reviews.

sign in
connect ORCID, Apple, or X
verify an email address - so we can mail your report when it’s done.

recent public peer reviews

done uploaded PDF Multidimensional Cost Geometry final 2026-05-12 12:02
done uploaded PDF RS Reality From One Distinction 2026-05-12 04:34
done uploaded PDF 2605.10402v1 2026-05-12 03:12
done uploaded PDF symmetry 4289850 2026-05-12 02:59
done uploaded PDF Gravity from Recognition: Linearized Regge Calculus and J-Cost Minimization on a Simplicial Ledger 2026-05-12 02:56
done uploaded PDF A Functional-Equation Encoding of Logical Consistency on Continuous Positive-Ratio Comparisons: A Conditional Rigidity Theorem 2026-05-12 00:57
done uploaded PDF A Functional-Equation Encoding of Logical Consistency on Continuous Positive-Ratio Comparisons: A Conditional Rigidity Theorem 2026-05-12 00:17
done arXiv:2603.16237 The d'Alembert Inevitability Theorem 2026-05-08 12:53
done uploaded PDF The Unified Forcing Chain: From Recognition Geometry to the Law of Logic 2026-05-07 23:55
done uploaded PDF RS Second Law Derivation 2026-05-07 19:57
done arXiv:2501.00001 Mathematical modelling of flow and adsorption in a gas chromatograph 2026-05-07 19:49
done arXiv:2605.04020 Late-Time Relaxation from Landau Singularities 2026-05-07 18:50
done arXiv:2510.12345 Carleman Estimates for Backward Anisotropic Stochastic Parabolic Equations with General Dynamic Boundary Conditions and Applications 2026-05-07 18:48

what the journal rubric reads

Referee's decision - publication recommendation and rationale.
Required revisions - stable R1, R2, ... actions the authors can answer one by one.
Claim ledger - every load-bearing claim with type, evidence, status, and reviewer note.
Verification grade - V0 through V5, from prose-only to independent formal audit.
Technical assessment - theorem statements, assumptions, proof strategy, counterexamples, notation, and literature positioning.
Recognition Science audit - exact Lean theorem comparisons and epistemic tags where the paper overlaps Recognition.
Cited Recognition theorems - Lean theorems that bear on the review, each linked to its module page.
Final recommendation - accept / metadata fixes / minor / major / formalization required / empirical evidence required / reject / out of scope / uncertain.

Recognition does not address every paper. When the paper is outside its scope we say so explicitly with canon_match_strength="none" and review on field-standard merits. The Recognition library is one tool, not a theory of everything.