Recognition: unknown
Bounding relative entropy for non-unitary excitations in quantum field theory
Pith reviewed 2026-05-10 03:20 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
Convexity of non-commutative L^p norms bounds relative entropy between a faithful state and arbitrary excitations in general von Neumann algebras.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
We show how one can use the convexity of non-commutative L^p norms to bound the relative entropy between a faithful state on a von Neumann algebra and an arbitrary excitation thereof. Our results hold for general von Neumann algebras, including the local algebras of type III that are ubiquitous in quantum field theory, and do not require knowledge of the relative modular operator. As an application of our results, we prove that for the chiral current on a light ray, the relative entropy between the vacuum and a dense set of single-particle states is uniformly bounded.
What carries the argument
The convexity of non-commutative L^p norms, used to derive relative-entropy bounds that avoid any explicit reference to the relative modular operator.
If this is right
- Relative entropy between faithful states and excitations can be bounded in any von Neumann algebra, including the type III local algebras of quantum field theory.
- The bound holds uniformly for a dense set of single-particle states of the chiral current on a light ray.
- No knowledge of the relative modular operator is needed to obtain the bound.
- The technique supplies a general tool for estimating entropy changes under non-unitary excitations.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- The same convexity argument might supply practical estimates in other quantum field theories where modular operators are hard to compute explicitly.
- Uniform bounds on relative entropy could constrain how much information can be gained by certain classes of excitations in algebraic quantum field theory.
- The method opens the possibility of deriving similar bounds for multi-particle states or for currents in higher-dimensional models.
Load-bearing premise
That the convexity property of non-commutative L^p norms directly supplies a useful bound on relative entropy for arbitrary excitations in type III von Neumann algebras without further technical conditions.
What would settle it
An explicit single-particle excitation of the chiral current for which the relative entropy with the vacuum grows unbounded, or a concrete type III algebra in which the L^p-norm convexity argument fails to produce a finite bound.
read the original abstract
We show how one can use the convexity of non-commutative $L^p$ norms to bound the relative entropy between a faithful state on a von Neumann algebra and an arbitrary excitation thereof. Our results hold for general von Neumann algebras, including the local algebras of type III that are ubiquitous in quantum field theory, and do not require knowledge of the relative modular operator. As an application of our results, we prove that for the chiral current on a light ray, the relative entropy between the vacuum and a dense set of single-particle states is uniformly bounded.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The paper shows how convexity of non-commutative L^p norms can be used to bound the relative entropy S(ω|φ) between a faithful state ω on a general von Neumann algebra and an arbitrary excitation φ, without requiring knowledge of the relative modular operator. The results apply to type III factors that arise in QFT. As an application, the authors prove that the relative entropy between the vacuum and a dense set of single-particle states for the chiral current on a light ray is uniformly bounded.
Significance. If the central claims hold, the work supplies a practical tool for obtaining relative-entropy bounds in QFT settings where explicit modular operators are unavailable. The uniform bound for single-particle excitations of the chiral current is a concrete, falsifiable result. The approach is parameter-free and relies only on standard convexity of L^p norms, which is a methodological strength. The generality to type III algebras is the most novel aspect, but its technical justification must be fully verified.
major comments (2)
- [general theorem] The general theorem (presumably §2 or §3): the claim that the convexity argument applies to arbitrary excitations on type III factors without any reference to the modular automorphism group of ω is not yet load-bearing. The Haagerup/Kosaki construction of L^p spaces for type III algebras is defined via the modular action; the manuscript must exhibit an explicit operator affiliated with the excitation that lies in the correct L^p space without implicitly invoking that action.
- [application] Application section (chiral current on light ray): the statement that the relative entropy is 'uniformly bounded' for a dense set of single-particle states requires the explicit form of the bound and the precise definition of the dense set. Without these, it is unclear whether the bound is independent of the excitation parameters or merely finite for each fixed state.
minor comments (2)
- [preliminaries] Notation for the non-commutative L^p norms should be introduced with a brief reminder of the precise definition used (Haagerup or Kosaki) to avoid ambiguity for readers unfamiliar with the type III case.
- [introduction] The abstract states that the results 'do not require knowledge of the relative modular operator'; this phrasing appears again in the introduction and should be qualified once in the text to indicate that the modular group of the reference state ω is still used to define the L^p spaces.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for their thorough review and constructive comments. We address each major comment point by point below.
read point-by-point responses
-
Referee: [general theorem] The general theorem (presumably §2 or §3): the claim that the convexity argument applies to arbitrary excitations on type III factors without any reference to the modular automorphism group of ω is not yet load-bearing. The Haagerup/Kosaki construction of L^p spaces for type III algebras is defined via the modular action; the manuscript must exhibit an explicit operator affiliated with the excitation that lies in the correct L^p space without implicitly invoking that action.
Authors: We appreciate this observation on the technical foundations. The convexity of the non-commutative L^p norms is applied to the positive operator X affiliated with the algebra that implements the excitation via the standard formula for the perturbed state. While the Haagerup-Kosaki L^p spaces are indeed defined using the modular operator of the reference state ω, the derivation of the relative-entropy bound uses only the convexity inequality on these norms and does not require explicit computation or invocation of the modular automorphism group. To make this fully load-bearing and address the referee's concern, we will add a clarifying paragraph in the general theorem section that exhibits the explicit form of the affiliated operator for an arbitrary excitation and confirms its membership in the appropriate L^p space. revision: partial
-
Referee: [application] Application section (chiral current on light ray): the statement that the relative entropy is 'uniformly bounded' for a dense set of single-particle states requires the explicit form of the bound and the precise definition of the dense set. Without these, it is unclear whether the bound is independent of the excitation parameters or merely finite for each fixed state.
Authors: We agree that the application section would benefit from additional precision. The dense set consists of single-particle excitations generated by test functions belonging to a dense subspace (specifically, the Schwartz space) of the one-particle Hilbert space for the chiral current. The bound is independent of the choice of test function within this set because the relevant L^p norms remain uniformly controlled by the algebraic properties of the current. We will revise the section to include both the precise definition of the dense set and the explicit expression for the uniform bound. revision: yes
Circularity Check
No significant circularity; standard convexity applied to general von Neumann algebras
full rationale
The paper's central claim applies the known convexity of non-commutative L^p norms (a standard result in operator algebra theory) to bound relative entropy for excitations in general von Neumann algebras, including type III factors common in QFT. This does not reduce by construction to the paper's own fitted inputs, self-definitions, or load-bearing self-citations. The abstract and claimed results explicitly state that the bounds hold without knowledge of the relative modular operator, and the application to the chiral current is derived as a consequence rather than presupposed. No equations or steps in the provided description exhibit the patterns of self-definitional reduction, fitted inputs renamed as predictions, or ansatz smuggling. The derivation remains self-contained against external mathematical benchmarks.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
axioms (1)
- standard math Convexity of non-commutative L^p norms applies to the relevant von Neumann algebras
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Umegaki,Conditional expectation in an operator algebra, IV (Entropy and information), Kodai Math
H. Umegaki,Conditional expectation in an operator algebra, IV (Entropy and information), Kodai Math. Sem. Rep.14(1962) 59
1962
-
[2]
Araki,Inequalities in von Neumann algebras,Rencontr
H. Araki,Inequalities in von Neumann algebras,Rencontr. phys.-math. de Strasbourg -RCP2522(1975) 1
1975
-
[3]
Araki,Relative Entropy of States of von Neumann Algebras,Publ
H. Araki,Relative Entropy of States of von Neumann Algebras,Publ. RIMS, Kyoto Univ.11 (1976) 809
1976
-
[4]
Uhlmann,Relative Entropy and the Wigner-Yanase-Dyson-Lieb Concavity in an Interpolation Theory,Commun
A. Uhlmann,Relative Entropy and the Wigner-Yanase-Dyson-Lieb Concavity in an Interpolation Theory,Commun. Math. Phys.54(1977) 21
1977
-
[5]
Haagerup,The standard form of von Neumann algebras,Math
U. Haagerup,The standard form of von Neumann algebras,Math. Scand.37(1975) 271
1975
-
[6]
O. Bratteli and D.W. Robinson,Operator Algebras and Quantum Statistical Mechanics 1, Theoretical and Mathematical Physics, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, Germany (1987), 10.1007/978-3-662-02520-8
-
[7]
Araki and T
H. Araki and T. Masuda,Positive Cones andLp-Spaces for von Neumann Algebras,Publ. RIMS, Kyoto Univ.18(1982) 339
1982
-
[8]
Bisognano and E.H
J.J. Bisognano and E.H. Wichmann,On the duality condition for a Hermitian scalar field,J. Math. Phys.16(1975) 985
1975
-
[9]
Bisognano and E.H
J.J. Bisognano and E.H. Wichmann,On the duality condition for quantum fields,J. Math. Phys.17(1976) 303
1976
-
[10]
R. Brunetti, K. Fredenhagen and N. Pinamonti,Thermodynamical Aspects of Fermions in External Electromagnetic Fields,Commun. Math. Phys.406(2025) 292 [2505.22413]
-
[11]
Jenčová,Rényi Relative Entropies and NoncommutativeLp-Spaces,Ann
A. Jenčová,Rényi Relative Entropies and NoncommutativeLp-Spaces,Ann. H. Poincaré19 (2018) 2513–2542 [1609.08462]
-
[12]
Jenčová,Rényi Relative Entropies and NoncommutativeLp-Spaces II,Ann
A. Jenčová,Rényi Relative Entropies and NoncommutativeLp-Spaces II,Ann. H. Poincaré 22(2021) 3235 [1707.00047]
-
[13]
M. Berta, V.B. Scholz and M. Tomamichel,Rényi Divergences as Weighted Non-commutative Vector-ValuedL p-Spaces,Ann. H. Poincaré19(2018) 1843 [1608.05317]
-
[14]
Bekenstein,Universal upper bound on the entropy-to-energy ratio for bounded systems, Phys
J.D. Bekenstein,Universal upper bound on the entropy-to-energy ratio for bounded systems, Phys. Rev. D23(1981) 287
1981
-
[15]
Page,Comment on a universal upper bound on the entropy-to-energy ratio for bounded systems,Phys
D.N. Page,Comment on a universal upper bound on the entropy-to-energy ratio for bounded systems,Phys. Rev. D26(1982) 947
1982
-
[16]
Sorkin,Toward a Proof of Entropy Increase in the Presence of Quantum Black Holes, Phys
R.D. Sorkin,Toward a Proof of Entropy Increase in the Presence of Quantum Black Holes, Phys. Rev. Lett.56(1986) 1885
1986
-
[17]
Dimensional Reduction in Quantum Gravity
G. ’t Hooft,Dimensional reduction in quantum gravity,Conf. Proc. C930308(1993) 284 [gr-qc/9310026]
work page Pith review arXiv 1993
-
[18]
A Covariant entropy conjecture,
R. Bousso,A covariant entropy conjecture,JHEP07(1999) 004 [hep-th/9905177]. – 29 –
-
[19]
E.E. Flanagan, D. Marolf and R.M. Wald,Proof of classical versions of the Bousso entropy bound and of the generalized second law,Phys. Rev. D62(2000) 084035 [hep-th/9908070]
- [20]
-
[21]
Pesci,From Unruh temperature to the generalized Bousso bound,Class
A. Pesci,From Unruh temperature to the generalized Bousso bound,Class. Quant. Grav.24 (2007) 6219 [0708.3729]
-
[22]
Page,Defining entropy bounds,JHEP10(2008) 007 [hep-th/0007238]
D.N. Page,Defining entropy bounds,JHEP10(2008) 007 [hep-th/0007238]
-
[23]
A.C. Wall,Proof of the generalized second law for rapidly changing fields and arbitrary horizon slices,Phys. Rev. D85(2012) 104049 [1105.3445]
- [24]
-
[25]
D.D. Blanco and H. Casini,Localization of Negative Energy and the Bekenstein Bound,Phys. Rev. Lett.111(2013) 221601 [1309.1121]
-
[26]
Casini,Relative entropy and the Bekenstein bound,Class
H. Casini,Relative entropy and the Bekenstein bound,Class. Quant. Grav.25(2008) 205021 [0804.2182]
-
[27]
Longo,A Bekenstein-Type Bound in QFT,Commun
R. Longo,A Bekenstein-Type Bound in QFT,Commun. Math. Phys.406(2025) 95
2025
-
[28]
S. Hollands and R. Longo,Bekenstein Bound for Approximately Local Charged States,Rev. Math. Phys.online first(2025) 2461008 [2501.03849]
-
[29]
R. Longo and F. Xu,Comment on the Bekenstein bound,J. Geom. Phys.130(2018) 113 [1802.07184]
-
[30]
J. Kudler-Flam, S. Leutheusser, A.A. Rahman, G. Satishchandran and A.J. Speranza, Covariant regulator for entanglement entropy: Proofs of the Bekenstein bound and the quantum null energy condition,Phys. Rev. D111(2025) 105001 [2312.07646]
-
[31]
Petz,Quasi-entropies for States of a von Neumann Algebra,Publ
D. Petz,Quasi-entropies for States of a von Neumann Algebra,Publ. RIMS, Kyoto Univ.21 (1985) 787–800
1985
-
[32]
Petz,Quasi-entropies for finite quantum systems,Rept
D. Petz,Quasi-entropies for finite quantum systems,Rept. Math. Phys.23(1986) 57
1986
-
[33]
M.B. Fröb and L. Sangaletti,Petz–Rényi relative entropy in QFT from modular theory,Lett. Math. Phys.115(2025) 30 [2411.09696]
-
[34]
Hiai,Quantum f-divergences in von Neumann algebras
F. Hiai,Quantum f-divergences in von Neumann algebras. II. Maximal f-divergences,J. Math. Phys.60(2019) 012203 [1807.03118]
-
[35]
Kato,Onα-z-Rényi divergence in the von Neumann algebra setting,J
S. Kato,Onα-z-Rényi divergence in the von Neumann algebra setting,J. Math. Phys.65 (2024) 042202 [2311.01748]
-
[36]
Araki,Some properties of modular conjugation operator of von Neumann algebras and a non-commutative Radon-Nikodym theorem with a chain rule,Pacific J
H. Araki,Some properties of modular conjugation operator of von Neumann algebras and a non-commutative Radon-Nikodym theorem with a chain rule,Pacific J. Math.50(1974) 309
1974
-
[37]
Araki,Relative Entropy of States of von Neumann Algebras II,Publ
H. Araki,Relative Entropy of States of von Neumann Algebras II,Publ. RIMS, Kyoto Univ. 13(1977) 173
1977
-
[38]
Petz,Properties of the relative entropy of states of von Neumann algebras,Acta Math
D. Petz,Properties of the relative entropy of states of von Neumann algebras,Acta Math. Hung.47(1986) 65
1986
-
[39]
M. Takesaki,Theory of operator algebras II, vol. 125 ofEncyclopaedia of Mathematical Sciences, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, Germany (2003), 10.1007/978-3-662-10451-4. – 30 –
-
[40]
Murray and J
F.J. Murray and J. v. Neumann,On rings of operators,Annals Math.37(1936) 116
1936
-
[41]
Hollands,Trace- and Improved Data-Processing Inequalities for von Neumann Algebras, Publ
S. Hollands,Trace- and Improved Data-Processing Inequalities for von Neumann Algebras, Publ. RIMS Kyoto Univ.59(2023) 687 [2102.07479]
-
[42]
H. Bostelmann, D. Cadamuro and L. Sangaletti,QuantumLp inequalities in thermal states, 2511.18932
-
[43]
Sangaletti,On Quantum Liouvillian Density Inequalities in the Thermal Sector, Dissertation, Universität Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany, 30.06.2025
L. Sangaletti,On Quantum Liouvillian Density Inequalities in the Thermal Sector, Dissertation, Universität Leipzig, Leipzig, Germany, 30.06.2025. https://nbn-resolving.org/urn:nbn:de:bsz:15-qucosa2-1020354
2025
-
[44]
Figliolini and D
F. Figliolini and D. Guido,The Tomita operator for the free scalar field,Ann. Inst. H. Poincaré51(1989) 419
1989
-
[45]
Figliolini and D
F. Figliolini and D. Guido,On the type of second quantization factors,J. Oper. Theory31 (1994) 229
1994
-
[46]
Buchholz and S.J
D. Buchholz and S.J. Summers,An Algebraic Characterization of Vacuum States in Minkowski Space,Commun. Math. Phys.155(1993) 449
1993
-
[47]
D. Buchholz, O. Dreyer, M. Florig and S.J. Summers,Geometric modular action and space-time symmetry groups,Rev. Math. Phys.12(2000) 475 [math-ph/9805026]
-
[48]
O. Bratteli and D.W. Robinson,Operator Algebras and Quantum Statistical Mechanics 2, Theoretical and Mathematical Physics, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, Germany (1996), 10.1007/978-3-662-03444-6
- [49]
-
[50]
Longo,Entropy of coherent excitations,Lett
R. Longo,Entropy of coherent excitations,Lett. Math. Phys.109(2019) 2587 [1901.02366]
- [51]
- [52]
-
[53]
Hollands,Relative entropy for coherent states in chiral CFT,Lett
S. Hollands,Relative entropy for coherent states in chiral CFT,Lett. Math. Phys.110(2020) 713 [1903.07508]
-
[54]
Panebianco,A formula for the relative entropy in chiral CFT,Lett
L. Panebianco,A formula for the relative entropy in chiral CFT,Lett. Math. Phys.110 (2020) 2363 [1911.10136]
- [55]
-
[56]
H. Bostelmann, D. Cadamuro and S. Del Vecchio,Relative Entropy of Coherent States on General CCR Algebras,Commun. Math. Phys.389(2022) 661 [2012.14401]
-
[57]
M.S. Guimaraes, I. Roditi, S.P. Sorella and A.F. Vieira,Relative entropy of single-mode squeezed states in Quantum Field Theory,Eur. Phys. J. C85(2025) 717 [2504.13148]
-
[58]
D. Cadamuro, M.B. Fröb, D. Katsinis and J. Mandrysch,Relative entropy for locally squeezed states,2511.11203
-
[59]
Araki,Relative Hamiltonian for Faithful Normal States of a von Neumann Algebra,Publ
H. Araki,Relative Hamiltonian for Faithful Normal States of a von Neumann Algebra,Publ. RIMS Kyoto Univ9(1973) 165. – 31 –
1973
-
[60]
Dereziński, V
J. Dereziński, V. Jakšić and C.-A. Pillet,Perturbation Theory ofW∗-dynamics, Liouvilleans and KMS-States,Rev. Math. Phys.15(2003) 447
2003
-
[61]
N. Lashkari, H. Liu and S. Rajagopal,Modular flow of excited states,JHEP09(2021) 166 [1811.05052]
- [62]
-
[63]
N. Lashkari, H. Liu and S. Rajagopal,Perturbation theory for the logarithm of a positive operator,JHEP11(2023) 097 [1811.05619]
- [64]
- [65]
-
[66]
Borchers,When Does Lorentz Invariance Imply Wedge Duality?,Lett
H.J. Borchers,When Does Lorentz Invariance Imply Wedge Duality?,Lett. Math. Phys.35 (1995) 39
1995
-
[67]
Lechner,Polarization-Free Quantum Fields and Interaction,Lett
G. Lechner,Polarization-Free Quantum Fields and Interaction,Lett. Math. Phys.64(2003) 137 [hep-th/0303062]
work page internal anchor Pith review arXiv 2003
-
[68]
Duell,N-Particle Scattering in Relativistic Wedge-Local Quantum Field Theory, Commun
M. Duell,N-Particle Scattering in Relativistic Wedge-Local Quantum Field Theory, Commun. Math. Phys.364(2018) 203 [1711.02569]
-
[69]
R. Falcone and C. Conti,Reeh-Schlieder approximation for coherent states,2509.09021
-
[70]
Schroer and T
B. Schroer and T. Truong,Equivalence of the sine-Gordon and Thirring models and cumulative mass effects,Phys. Rev. D15(1977) 1684
1977
-
[71]
Borchers,The CPT-Theorem in Two-dimensional Theories of Local Observables, Commun
H.J. Borchers,The CPT-Theorem in Two-dimensional Theories of Local Observables, Commun. Math. Phys.143(1992) 315
1992
-
[72]
H.J. Borchers and J. Yngvason,Modular groups of quantum fields in thermal states,J. Math. Phys.40(1999) 601 [math-ph/9805013]
-
[73]
P. Fries and I.A. Reyes,Entanglement and relative entropy of a chiral fermion on the torus, Phys. Rev. D100(2019) 105015 [1906.02207]
-
[74]
Xu,Singular Limits of Relative Entropy in Two Dimensional Massive Free Fermion Theory,Commun
F. Xu,Singular Limits of Relative Entropy in Two Dimensional Massive Free Fermion Theory,Commun. Math. Phys.401(2023) 2391
2023
-
[75]
S. Galanda, A. Much and R. Verch,Relative Entropy of Fermion Excitation States on the CAR Algebra,Math. Phys. Anal. Geom.26(2023) 21 [2305.02788]
-
[76]
F. Finster and A. Much,The Relative Fermionic Entropy in Two-Dimensional Rindler Spacetime,2505.14076. – 32 –
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.