pith. sign in

arxiv: 2606.22759 · v1 · pith:56ETWVK7new · submitted 2026-06-22 · ✦ hep-ex

Observation of psi(3770)to pbar p and Measurement of Electromagnetic Form Factors of Proton at sqrt{s} = 3.510-4.946 GeV

BESIII Collaboration: M. Ablikim , M. N. Achasov , P. Adlarson , X. C. Ai , C. S. Akondi , R. Aliberti , A. Amoroso , Q. An
show 752 more authors
Y. H. An Y. Bai O. Bakina H.-R. Bao X. L. Bao M. Barbagiovanni V. Batozskaya K. Begzsuren N. Berger M. Berlowski M. B. Bertani D. Bettoni F. Bianchi E. Bianco A. Bortone I. Boyko R. A. Briere A. Brueggemann D. Cabiati H. Cai M. H. Cai X. Cai A. Calcaterra G. F. Cao N. Cao S. A. Cetin X. Y. Chai J. F. Chang T. T. Chang G. R. Che Y. Z. Che C. H. Chen Chao Chen G. Chen H. S. Chen H. Y. Chen M. L. Chen S. J. Chen S. M. Chen T. Chen W. Chen X. R. Chen X. T. Chen X. Y. Chen Y. B. Chen Y. Q. Chen Z. K. Chen J. Cheng L. N. Cheng S. K. Choi X. Chu G. Cibinetto F. Cossio J. Cottee-Meldrum H. L. Dai J. P. Dai X. C. Dai A. Dbeyssi R. E. de Boer D. Dedovich C. Q. Deng Z. Y. Deng A. Denig I. Denisenko M. Destefanis F. De Mori E. Di Fiore X. X. Ding Y. Ding Y. X. Ding Yi. Ding J. Dong L. Y. Dong M. Y. Dong X. Dong M. C. Du S. X. Du Shaoxu Du X. L. Du Y. Q. Du Y. Y. Duan Z. H. Duan P. Egorov G. F. Fan J. J. Fan Y. H. Fan J. Fang Jin Fang S. S. Fang W. X. Fang Y. Q. Fang L. Fava F. Feldbauer G. Felici C. Q. Feng J. H. Feng L. Feng Q. X. Feng Y. T. Feng M. Fritsch C. D. Fu J. L. Fu Y. W. Fu H. Gao Y. Gao Y. N. Gao Y. Y. Gao Yunong Gao Z. Gao S. Garbolino I. Garzia L. Ge P. T. Ge Z. W. Ge C. Geng E. M. Gersabeck A. Gilman K. Goetzen J. Gollub J. B. Gong J. D. Gong L. Gong W. X. Gong W. Gradl S. Gramigna M. Greco M. D. Gu M. H. Gu C. Y. Guan A. Q. Guo H. Guo J. N. Guo L. B. Guo M. J. Guo R. P. Guo X. Guo Y. P. Guo Z. Guo A. Guskov J. Gutierrez J. Y. Han T. T. Han X. Han F. Hanisch K. D. Hao X. Q. Hao F. A. Harris C. Z. He K. K. He K. L. He F. H. Heinsius C. H. Heinz Y. K. Heng C. Herold P. C. Hong G. Y. Hou X. T. Hou Y. R. Hou Z. L. Hou H. M. Hu J. F. Hu Q. P. Hu S. L. Hu T. Hu Y. Hu Y. X. Hu Z. M. Hu G. S. Huang K. X. Huang L. Q. Huang P. Huang X. T. Huang Y. P. Huang Y. S. Huang T. Hussain N. H\"usken N. in der Wiesche J. Jackson Q. Ji Q. P. Ji W. Ji X. B. Ji X. L. Ji Y. Y. Ji L. K. Jia X. Q. Jia D. Jiang H. B. Jiang S. J. Jiang X. S. Jiang Y. Jiang J. B. Jiao J. K. Jiao Z. Jiao L. C. L. Jin S. Jin Y. Jin M. Q. Jing X. M. Jing T. Johansson S. Kabana X. L. Kang X. S. Kang B. C. Ke V. Khachatryan A. Khoukaz O. B. Kolcu B. Kopf L. Kr\"oger L. Kr\"ummel Y. Y. Kuang M. Kuessner X. Kui N. Kumar A. Kupsc W. K\"uhn Q. Lan W. N. Lan T. T. Lei M. Lellmann T. Lenz C. Li C. H. Li C. K. Li Chunkai Li Cong Li D. M. Li F. Li G. Li H. B. Li H. J. Li H. L. Li H. N. Li H. P. Li Hui Li J. N. Li J. S. Li J. W. Li K. Li K. L. Li L. J. Li Lei Li M. H. Li M. R. Li M. T. Li P. L. Li P. R. Li Q. M. Li Q. X. Li R. Li S. Li S. X. Li S. Y. Li Shanshan Li T. Li T. Y. Li W. D. Li W. G. Li X. Li X. H. Li X. K. Li X. L. Li X. Y. Li X. Z. Li Y. Li Y. G. Li Y. P. Li Z. H. Li Z. J. Li Z. L. Li Z. X. Li Z. Y. Li C. Liang H. Liang Y. F. Liang Y. T. Liang G. R. Liao L. B. Liao M. H. Liao Y. P. Liao J. Libby A. Limphirat C. C. Lin C. X. Lin D. X. Lin T. Lin B. J. Liu B. X. Liu C. Liu C. X. Liu F. Liu F. H. Liu Feng Liu G. M. Liu H. Liu H. B. Liu H. M. Liu Huihui Liu J. B. Liu J. J. Liu K. Liu K. Y. Liu Ke Liu Kun Liu L. Liu L. C. Liu Lu Liu M. H. Liu P. L. Liu Q. Liu S. B. Liu T. Liu W. M. Liu W. T. Liu X. Liu X. K. Liu X. L. Liu X. P. Liu X. Y. Liu Y. Liu Y. B. Liu Yi Liu Z. A. Liu Z. D. Liu Z. L. Liu Z. Q. Liu Z. X. Liu Z. Y. Liu X. C. Lou H. J. Lu J. G. Lu X. L. Lu Y. Lu Y. H. Lu Y. P. Lu Z. H. Lu C. L. Luo J. R. Luo J. S. Luo M. X. Luo T. Luo X. L. Luo Z. Y. Lv X. R. Lyu Y. F. Lyu Y. H. Lyu F. C. Ma H. L. Ma Heng Ma J. L. Ma L. L. Ma L. R. Ma Q. M. Ma R. Q. Ma R. Y. Ma T. Ma X. T. Ma X. Y. Ma Y. M. Ma F. E. Maas I. MacKay M. Maggiora S. Maity S. Malde Q. A. Malik H. X. Mao Y. J. Mao Z. P. Mao S. Marcello A. Marshall F. M. Melendi Y. H. Meng Z. X. Meng G. Mezzadri H. Miao T. J. Min R. E. Mitchell X. H. Mo B. Moses N. Yu. Muchnoi J. Muskalla Y. Nefedov F. Nerling H. Neuwirth Z. Ning S. Nisar Q. L. Niu W. D. Niu Y. Niu C. Normand S. L. Olsen Q. Ouyang S. Pacetti X. Pan Y. Pan A. Pathak Y. P. Pei M. Pelizaeus G. L. Peng H. P. Peng X. J. Peng Y. Y. Peng K. Peters K. Petridis J. L. Ping R. G. Ping S. Plura V. Prasad L. P\"opping F. Z. Qi H. R. Qi M. Qi S. Qian W. B. Qian C. F. Qiao J. H. Qiao J. J. Qin J. L. Qin L. Q. Qin L. Y. Qin P. B. Qin X. P. Qin X. S. Qin Z. H. Qin J. F. Qiu Z. H. Qu J. Rademacker C. F. Redmer A. Rivetti M. Rolo G. Rong S. S. Rong F. Rosini Ch. Rosner M. Q. Ruan N. Salone A. Sarantsev Y. Schelhaas M. Schernau K. Schoenning M. Scodeggio W. Shan X. Y. Shan Z. J. Shang J. F. Shangguan L. G. Shao M. Shao C. P. Shen H. F. Shen W. H. Shen X. Y. Shen B. A. Shi Ch. Y. Shi H. Shi J. L. Shi J. Y. Shi M. H. Shi S. Y. Shi X. Shi H. L. Song J. J. Song M. H. Song T. Z. Song W. M. Song Y. X. Song Zirong Song S. Sosio S. Spataro S. Stansilaus F. Stieler M. Stolte S. S Su G. B. Sun G. X. Sun H. Sun H. K. Sun J. F. Sun K. Sun L. Sun R. Sun S. S. Sun T. Sun W. Y. Sun Y. C. Sun Y. H. Sun Y. J. Sun Y. Z. Sun Z. Q. Sun Z. T. Sun H. Tabaharizato C. J. Tang G. Y. Tang J. Tang J. J. Tang L. F. Tang Y. A. Tang Z. H. Tang L. Y. Tao M. Tat J. X. Teng J. Y. Tian W. H. Tian Y. Tian Z. F. Tian I. Uman E. van der Smagt B. Wang Bin Wang Bo Wang C. Wang Chao Wang Cong Wang D. Y. Wang H. J. Wang H. R. Wang J. Wang J. J. Wang J. P. Wang K. Wang L. L. Wang L. W. Wang M. Wang Mi Wang N. Y. Wang S. Wang Shun Wang T. Wang T. J. Wang W. Wang W. P. Wang X. F. Wang X. L. Wang X. N. Wang Xin Wang Y. Wang Y. D. Wang Y. F. Wang Y. H. Wang Y. J. Wang Y. L. Wang Y. N. Wang Yanning Wang Yaqian Wang Yi Wang Yuan Wang Z. Wang Z. L. Wang Z. Q. Wang Z. Y. Wang Zhi Wang Ziyi Wang D. Wei D. H. Wei D. J. Wei H. R. Wei F. Weidner H. R. Wen S. P. Wen U. Wiedner G. Wilkinson M. Wolke J. F. Wu L. H. Wu L. J. Wu Lianjie Wu S. G. Wu S. M. Wu X. W. Wu Z. Wu H. L. Xia L. Xia B. H. Xiang D. Xiao G. Y. Xiao H. Xiao Y. L. Xiao Z. J. Xiao C. Xie K. J. Xie Y. Xie Y. G. Xie Y. H. Xie Z. P. Xie T. Y. Xing D. B. Xiong C. J. Xu G. F. Xu H. Y. Xu Q. J. Xu Q. N. Xu T. D. Xu X. P. Xu Y. Xu Y. C. Xu Z. S. Xu F. Yan L. Yan W. B. Yan W. C. Yan W. H. Yan W. P. Yan X. Q. Yan Y. Y. Yan H. J. Yang H. L. Yang H. X. Yang J. H. Yang R. J. Yang X. Y. Yang Y. Yang Y. H. Yang Y. M. Yang Y. Q. Yang Y. Z. Yang Youhua Yang Z. Y. Yang Z. P. Yao M. Ye M. H. Ye Z. J. Ye Junhao Yin Z. Y. You B. X. Yu C. X. Yu G. Yu J. S. Yu L. W. Yu T. Yu X. D. Yu Y. C. Yu Yongchao Yu C. Z. Yuan H. Yuan J. Yuan Jie Yuan L. Yuan M. K. Yuan S. H. Yuan Y. Yuan C. X. Yue Ying Yue A. A. Zafar F. R. Zeng S. H. Zeng X. Zeng Y. J. Zeng Yujie Zeng Y. C. Zhai Y. H. Zhan B. L. Zhang B. X. Zhang D. H. Zhang G. Y. Zhang Gengyuan Zhang H. Zhang H. C. Zhang H. H. Zhang H. Q. Zhang H. R. Zhang H. Y. Zhang Han Zhang J. Zhang J. J. Zhang J. L. Zhang J. Q. Zhang J. S. Zhang J. W. Zhang J. X. Zhang J. Y. Zhang J. Z. Zhang Jianyu Zhang Jin Zhang Jiyuan Zhang L. M. Zhang Lei Zhang N. Zhang P. Zhang Q. Zhang Q. Y. Zhang Q. Z. Zhang R. Y. Zhang S. H. Zhang S. N. Zhang Shulei Zhang X. M. Zhang X. Y. Zhang Y. Zhang Y. T. Zhang Y. H. Zhang Y. P. Zhang Yu Zhang Z. Zhang Z. D. Zhang Z. H. Zhang Z. L. Zhang Z. X. Zhang Z. Y. Zhang Zh. Zh. Zhang Zhilong Zhang Ziyang Zhang Ziyu Zhang G. Zhao J.-P. Zhao J. Y. Zhao J. Z. Zhao L. Zhao Lei Zhao M. G. Zhao R. P. Zhao S. J. Zhao Y. B. Zhao Y. L. Zhao Y. P. Zhao Y. X. Zhao Z. G. Zhao A. Zhemchugov B. Zheng B. M. Zheng J. P. Zheng W. J. Zheng W. Q. Zheng X. R. Zheng Y. H. Zheng B. Zhong C. Zhong H. Zhou J. Q. Zhou S. Zhou X. Zhou X. K. Zhou X. R. Zhou X. Y. Zhou Y. X. Zhou Y. Z. Zhou A. N. Zhu J. Zhu K. Zhu K. J. Zhu K. S. Zhu L. X. Zhu Lin Zhu S. H. Zhu T. J. Zhu W. D. Zhu W. J. Zhu W. Z. Zhu Y. C. Zhu Z. A. Zhu X. Y. Zhuang M. Zhuge J. H. Zou J. Zu
This is my paper

Pith reviewed 2026-06-26 06:41 UTC · model grok-4.3

classification ✦ hep-ex
keywords charmonium decaysproton electromagnetic form factorsBESIIIe+e- annihilationBorn cross sectiontime-like momentum transferψ(3770)
0
0 comments X

The pith

The BESIII experiment observes the decay ψ(3770) to proton-antiproton with 6.6 sigma significance and measures proton electromagnetic form factors.

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The paper searches for charmonium states decaying to proton-antiproton by examining the energy dependence of the production cross section in electron-positron collisions. It establishes the observation of ψ(3770) decaying to this final state at 6.6 sigma. A possible additional structure around 4.2 GeV is identified with 4.6 to 4.8 sigma significance. The work also extracts the ratio of electric to magnetic form factors and the magnetic form factor of the proton from the angular distribution of the protons with improved precision. These results offer experimental input on charmonium decay mechanisms and nucleon structure in the time-like domain.

Core claim

The decay ψ(3770)→p p-bar is observed with a significance of 6.6σ including systematic uncertainties. A structure near 4.2 GeV is observed with significances of 4.6σ or 4.8σ for the ψ(4160) or Y(4230) hypotheses including systematic uncertainties, respectively. The moduli of the form factor ratios |G_E/G_M| and of the magnetic form factors |G_M| are extracted by analyzing the proton polar angle distribution with higher precision at large time-like squared momentum transfer.

What carries the argument

Fit to the Born cross section of e^+e^- → p p-bar across 47 center-of-mass energies from 3.510 to 4.946 GeV combined with analysis of the proton polar angle distribution.

Load-bearing premise

The background model and resonance line shapes used in the fit to the Born cross section do not produce a spurious excess at the ψ(3770) mass.

What would settle it

A re-analysis of the same or larger dataset with an alternative background parametrization that reduces the excess at 3.77 GeV below 5 sigma significance.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 2606.22759 by A. Amoroso, A. A. Zafar, A. Bortone, A. Brueggemann, A. Calcaterra, A. Dbeyssi, A. Denig, A. Gilman, A. Guskov, A. Khoukaz, A. Kupsc, A. Limphirat, A. Marshall, A. N. Zhu, A. Pathak, A. Q. Guo, A. Rivetti, A. Sarantsev, A. Zhemchugov, B. A. Shi, B. C. Ke, BESIII Collaboration: M. Ablikim, B. H. Xiang, Bin Wang, B. J. Liu, B. Kopf, B. L. Zhang, B. Moses, B. M. Zheng, Bo Wang, B. Wang, B. X. Liu, B. X. Yu, B. X. Zhang, B. Zheng, B. Zhong, C. C. Lin, C. D. Fu, C. F. Qiao, C. F. Redmer, C. Geng, Chao Chen, Chao Wang, C. H. Chen, C. Herold, C. H. Heinz, C. H. Li, Ch. Rosner, Chunkai Li, Ch. Y. Shi, C. J. Tang, C. J. Xu, C. K. Li, C. Li, C. Liang, C. Liu, C. L. Luo, C. Normand, Cong Li, Cong Wang, C. P. Shen, C. Q. Deng, C. Q. Feng, C. S. Akondi, C. Wang, C. Xie, C. X. Lin, C. X. Liu, C. X. Yu, C. X. Yue, C. Y. Guan, C. Z. He, C. Zhong, C. Z. Yuan, D. Bettoni, D. B. Xiong, D. Cabiati, D. Dedovich, D. H. Wei, D. H. Zhang, D. Jiang, D. J. Wei, D. M. Li, D. Wei, D. Xiao, D. X. Lin, D. Y. Wang, E. Bianco, E. Di Fiore, E. M. Gersabeck, E. van der Smagt, F. A. Harris, F. Bianchi, F. C. Ma, F. Cossio, F. De Mori, F. E. Maas, Feng Liu, F. Feldbauer, F. Hanisch, F. H. Heinsius, F. H. Liu, F. Li, F. Liu, F. M. Melendi, F. Nerling, F. Rosini, F. R. Zeng, F. Stieler, F. Weidner, F. Yan, F. Z. Qi, G. B. Sun, G. Chen, G. Cibinetto, Gengyuan Zhang, G. F. Cao, G. Felici, G. F. Fan, G. F. Xu, G. Li, G. L. Peng, G. Mezzadri, G. M. Liu, G. R. Che, G. R. Liao, G. Rong, G. S. Huang, G. Wilkinson, G. X. Sun, G. Y. Hou, G. Y. Tang, G. Yu, G. Y. Xiao, G. Y. Zhang, G. Zhao, Han Zhang, H. B. Jiang, H. B. Li, H. B. Liu, H. Cai, H. C. Zhang, Heng Ma, H. F. Shen, H. Gao, H. Guo, H. H. Zhang, H. J. Li, H. J. Lu, H. J. Wang, H. J. Yang, H. K. Sun, H. L. Dai, H. Liang, H. Liu, H. L. Li, H. L. Ma, H. L. Song, H. L. Xia, H. L. Yang, H. M. Hu, H. Miao, H. M. Liu, H. Neuwirth, H. N. Li, H. P. Li, H. P. Peng, H. Q. Zhang, H.-R. Bao, H. R. Qi, H. R. Wang, H. R. Wei, H. R. Wen, H. R. Zhang, H. S. Chen, H. Shi, H. Sun, H. Tabaharizato, Huihui Liu, Hui Li, H. Xiao, H. X. Mao, H. X. Yang, H. Y. Chen, H. Yuan, H. Y. Xu, H. Y. Zhang, H. Zhang, H. Zhou, I. Boyko, I. Denisenko, I. Garzia, I. Mackay, I. Uman, J. B. Gong, J. B. Jiao, J. B. Liu, J. Cheng, J. Cottee-Meldrum, J. D. Gong, J. Dong, J. Fang, J. F. Chang, J. F. Hu, J. F. Qiu, J. F. Shangguan, J. F. Sun, J. F. Wu, J. G. Lu, J. Gollub, J. Gutierrez, J. H. Feng, J. H. Qiao, J. H. Yang, J. H. Zou, Jianyu Zhang, Jie Yuan, Jin Fang, Jin Zhang, Jiyuan Zhang, J. Jackson, J. J. Fan, J. J. Liu, J. J. Qin, J. J. Song, J. J. Tang, J. J. Wang, J. J. Zhang, J. K. Jiao, J. L. Fu, J. Libby, J. L. Ma, J. L. Ping, J. L. Qin, J. L. Shi, J. L. Zhang, J. Muskalla, J. N. Guo, J. N. Li, J. P. Dai, J. P. Wang, J.-P. Zhao, J. P. Zheng, J. Q. Zhang, J. Q. Zhou, J. Rademacker, J. R. Luo, J. S. Li, J. S. Luo, J. S. Yu, J. S. Zhang, J. Tang, Junhao Yin, J. Wang, J. W. Li, J. W. Zhang, J. X. Teng, J. X. Zhang, J. Y. Han, J. Y. Shi, J. Y. Tian, J. Yuan, J. Y. Zhang, J. Y. Zhao, J. Zhang, J. Zhu, J. Zu, J. Z. Zhang, J. Z. Zhao, K. Begzsuren, K. D. Hao, Ke Liu, K. Goetzen, K. J. Xie, K. J. Zhu, K. K. He, K. L. He, K. Li, K. Liu, K. L. Li, K. Peters, K. Petridis, K. Schoenning, K. Sun, K. S. Zhu, Kun Liu, K. Wang, K. X. Huang, K. Y. Liu, K. Zhu, L. B. Guo, L. B. Liao, L. C. Liu, L. C. L. Jin, Lei Li, Lei Zhang, Lei Zhao, L. Fava, L. Feng, L. F. Tang, L. Ge, L. Gong, L. G. Shao, L. H. Wu, Lianjie Wu, Lin Zhu, L. J. Li, L. J. Wu, L. K. Jia, L. Kr\"oger, L. Kr\"ummel, L. Liu, L. L. Ma, L. L. Wang, L. M. Zhang, L. N. Cheng, L. P\"opping, L. Q. Huang, L. Q. Qin, L. R. Ma, L. Sun, Lu Liu, L. W. Wang, L. W. Yu, L. Xia, L. X. Zhu, L. Yan, L. Y. Dong, L. Y. Qin, L. Y. Tao, L. Yuan, L. Zhao, M. Barbagiovanni, M. B. Bertani, M. Berlowski, M. C. Du, M. Destefanis, M. D. Gu, M. Fritsch, M. Greco, M. G. Zhao, M. H. Cai, M. H. Gu, M. H. Li, M. H. Liao, M. H. Liu, M. H. Shi, M. H. Song, M. H. Ye, Mi Wang, M. J. Guo, M. Kuessner, M. K. Yuan, M. L. Chen, M. Lellmann, M. Maggiora, M. N. Achasov, M. Pelizaeus, M. Qi, M. Q. Jing, M. Q. Ruan, M. R. Li, M. Rolo, M. Schernau, M. Scodeggio, M. Shao, M. Stolte, M. Tat, M. T. Li, M. Wang, M. Wolke, M. X. Luo, M. Y. Dong, M. Ye, M. Zhuge, N. Berger, N. Cao, N. H\"usken, N. in der Wiesche, N. Kumar, N. Salone, N. Yu. Muchnoi, N. Y. Wang, N. Zhang, O. Bakina, O. B. Kolcu, P. Adlarson, P. B. Qin, P. C. Hong, P. Egorov, P. Huang, P. L. Li, P. L. Liu, P. R. Li, P. T. Ge, P. Zhang, Q. A. Malik, Q. An, Q. Ji, Q. J. Xu, Q. Lan, Q. Liu, Q. L. Niu, Q. M. Li, Q. M. Ma, Q. N. Xu, Q. Ouyang, Q. P. Hu, Q. P. Ji, Q. X. Feng, Q. X. Li, Q. Y. Zhang, Q. Zhang, Q. Z. Zhang, R. A. Briere, R. Aliberti, R. E. de Boer, R. E. Mitchell, R. G. Ping, R. J. Yang, R. Li, R. P. Guo, R. P. Zhao, R. Q. Ma, R. Sun, R. Y. Ma, R. Y. Zhang, S. A. Cetin, S. B. Liu, S. Garbolino, S. Gramigna, S. G. Wu, Shanshan Li, Shaoxu Du, Shulei Zhang, Shun Wang, S. H. Yuan, S. H. Zeng, S. H. Zhang, S. H. Zhu, S. J. Chen, S. Jin, S. J. Jiang, S. J. Zhao, S. Kabana, S. K. Choi, S. L. Hu, S. Li, S. L. Olsen, S. Maity, S. Malde, S. Marcello, S. M. Chen, S. M. Wu, S. Nisar, S. N. Zhang, S. Pacetti, S. Plura, S. P. Wen, S. Qian, S. S. Fang, S. Sosio, S. Spataro, S. S. Rong, S. S Su, S. S. Sun, S. Stansilaus, S. Wang, S. X. Du, S. X. Li, S. Y. Li, S. Y. Shi, S. Zhou, T. Chen, T. D. Xu, T. Hu, T. Hussain, T. J. Min, T. Johansson, T. J. Wang, T. J. Zhu, T. Lenz, T. Li, T. Lin, T. Liu, T. Luo, T. Ma, T. Sun, T. T. Chang, T. T. Han, T. T. Lei, T. Wang, T. Y. Li, T. Yu, T. Y. Xing, T. Z. Song, U. Wiedner, V. Batozskaya, V. Khachatryan, V. Prasad, W. B. Qian, W. B. Yan, W. Chen, W. C. Yan, W. D. Li, W. D. Niu, W. D. Zhu, W. G. Li, W. Gradl, W. H. Shen, W. H. Tian, W. H. Yan, W. Ji, W. J. Zheng, W. J. Zhu, W. K\"uhn, W. M. Liu, W. M. Song, W. N. Lan, W. P. Wang, W. P. Yan, W. Q. Zheng, W. Shan, W. T. Liu, W. Wang, W. X. Fang, W. X. Gong, W. Y. Sun, W. Z. Zhu, X. B. Ji, X. Cai, X. C. Ai, X. C. Dai, X. Chu, X. C. Lou, X. Dong, X. D. Yu, X. F. Wang, X. Guo, X. Han, X. H. Li, X. H. Mo, Xin Wang, X. J. Peng, X. K. Li, X. K. Liu, X. Kui, X. K. Zhou, X. L. Bao, X. L. Du, X. Li, X. Liu, X. L. Ji, X. L. Kang, X. L. Li, X. L. Liu, X. L. Lu, X. L. Luo, X. L. Wang, X. M. Jing, X. M. Zhang, X. N. Wang, X. Pan, X. P. Liu, X. P. Qin, X. P. Xu, X. Q. Hao, X. Q. Jia, X. Q. Yan, X. R. Chen, X. R. Lyu, X. R. Zheng, X. R. Zhou, X. Shi, X. S. Jiang, X. S. Kang, X. S. Qin, X. T. Chen, X. T. Hou, X. T. Huang, X. T. Ma, X. W. Wu, X. X. Ding, X. Y. Chai, X. Y. Chen, X. Y. Li, X. Y. Liu, X. Y. Ma, X. Y. Shan, X. Y. Shen, X. Y. Yang, X. Y. Zhang, X. Y. Zhou, X. Y. Zhuang, X. Zeng, X. Zhou, X. Z. Li, Yanning Wang, Yaqian Wang, Y. A. Tang, Y. Bai, Y. B. Chen, Y. B. Liu, Y. B. Zhao, Y. C. Sun, Y. C. Xu, Y. C. Yu, Y. C. Zhai, Y. C. Zhu, Y. Ding, Y. D. Wang, Y. F. Liang, Y. F. Lyu, Y. F. Wang, Y. Gao, Y. G. Li, Y. G. Xie, Y. H. An, Y. H. Fan, Y. H. Lu, Y. H. Lyu, Y. H. Meng, Y. H. Sun, Y. Hu, Y. H. Wang, Y. H. Xie, Y. H. Yang, Y. H. Zhan, Y. H. Zhang, Y. H. Zheng, Yi. Ding, Yi Liu, Ying Yue, Yi Wang, Y. Jiang, Y. Jin, Y. J. Mao, Y. J. Sun, Y. J. Wang, Y. J. Zeng, Y. K. Heng, Y. Li, Y. Liu, Y. Lu, Y. L. Wang, Y. L. Xiao, Y. L. Zhao, Y. M. Ma, Y. M. Yang, Y. Nefedov, Y. N. Gao, Y. Niu, Y. N. Wang, Yongchao Yu, Youhua Yang, Y. Pan, Y. P. Guo, Y. P. Huang, Y. P. Li, Y. P. Liao, Y. P. Lu, Y. P. Pei, Y. P. Zhang, Y. P. Zhao, Y. Q. Chen, Y. Q. Du, Y. Q. Fang, Y. Q. Yang, Y. R. Hou, Y. Schelhaas, Y. S. Huang, Y. T. Feng, Y. Tian, Y. T. Liang, Y. T. Zhang, Yuan Wang, Yujie Zeng, Yunong Gao, Yu Zhang, Y. Wang, Y. W. Fu, Y. X. Ding, Y. X. Hu, Y. Xie, Y. X. Song, Y. Xu, Y. X. Zhao, Y. X. Zhou, Y. Yang, Y. Y. Duan, Y. Y. Gao, Y. Y. Ji, Y. Y. Kuang, Y. Y. Peng, Y. Yuan, Y. Y. Yan, Y. Z. Che, Y. Zhang, Y. Z. Sun, Y. Z. Yang, Y. Z. Zhou, Z. A. Liu, Z. A. Zhu, Z. D. Liu, Z. D. Zhang, Z. F. Tian, Z. Gao, Z. Guo, Z. G. Zhao, Z. H. Duan, Zhilong Zhang, Zhi Wang, Z. H. Li, Z. H. Lu, Z. H. Qin, Z. H. Qu, Z. H. Tang, Z. H. Zhang, Zh. Zh. Zhang, Zirong Song, Ziyang Zhang, Ziyi Wang, Ziyu Zhang, Z. Jiao, Z. J. Li, Z. J. Shang, Z. J. Xiao, Z. J. Ye, Z. K. Chen, Z. L. Hou, Z. L. Li, Z. L. Liu, Z. L. Wang, Z. L. Zhang, Z. M. Hu, Z. Ning, Z. P. Mao, Z. P. Xie, Z. P. Yao, Z. Q. Liu, Z. Q. Sun, Z. Q. Wang, Z. S. Xu, Z. T. Sun, Z. Wang, Z. W. Ge, Z. Wu, Z. X. Li, Z. X. Liu, Z. X. Meng, Z. X. Zhang, Z. Y. Deng, Z. Y. Li, Z. Y. Liu, Z. Y. Lv, Z. Y. Wang, Z. Y. Yang, Z. Y. You, Z. Y. Zhang, Z. Zhang.

Figure 1
Figure 1. Figure 1: FIG. 1. Fit to the proton momentum distribution at [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p002_1.png] view at source ↗
Figure 2
Figure 2. Figure 2: FIG. 2. The measured Born cross sections (top) and proton [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p002_2.png] view at source ↗
Figure 3
Figure 3. Figure 3: FIG. 3. Fits to the dressed cross sections for the [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p004_3.png] view at source ↗
Figure 4
Figure 4. Figure 4: FIG. 4. The contour of Γ [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p004_4.png] view at source ↗
Figure 5
Figure 5. Figure 5: FIG. 5. Proton form factors in the [PITH_FULL_IMAGE:figures/full_fig_p005_5.png] view at source ↗
read the original abstract

We search for possible charmonium(-like) states decaying into the $p\bar{p}$ final state by studying the Born cross sections of the $e^+e^-\to p\bar{p}$ reaction, and we determine the proton electromagnetic form factors by analyzing the proton angular distribution. The measurement is performed using a sample of $e^+e^-$ collision data collected at 47 center-of-mass energies from 3.510 to 4.946 GeV, corresponding to an integrated luminosity of 26 fb$^{-1}$, recorded by the BESIII detector collected at the BEPCII collider. The decay $\psi(3770)\to p\bar{p}$ is observed with a significance of 6.6$\sigma$ including systematic uncertainties. Furthermore, a structure near 4.2 GeV is observed with significances of $4.6\sigma$ or $4.8\sigma$ for the $\psi(4160)$ or $Y(4230)$ hypotheses including systematic uncertainties, respectively; these interpretations cannot presently be distinguished. In addition, the moduli of the form factor ratios $|G_{E}/G_{M}|$ and of the magnetic form factors $|G_{M}|$ are extracted by analyzing the proton polar angle distribution with higher precision at large time-like squared momentum transfer. These results provide important experimental insights into both the decay mechanisms of charmonium(-like) states in the open charm region and the internal structure of proton.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, simulated authors' rebuttal, and a circularity audit. Tearing a paper down is the easy half of reading it; the pith above is the substance, this is the friction.

Referee Report

1 major / 2 minor

Summary. The manuscript claims the observation of the decay ψ(3770)→p¯p with a significance of 6.6σ (including systematic uncertainties) from a study of the Born cross section of e⁺e⁻→p¯p at 47 center-of-mass energies between 3.510 and 4.946 GeV using 26 fb⁻¹ of BESIII data. It also reports a structure near 4.2 GeV with significances of 4.6σ or 4.8σ depending on the resonance hypothesis, and extracts the moduli of the proton electromagnetic form factor ratios |G_E/G_M| and |G_M| from the proton angular distributions.

Significance. If the central observation holds, this would constitute the first reported observation of ψ(3770) decaying to p¯p, offering experimental input on charmonium decay mechanisms in the open-charm region. The form-factor results add precision data on the proton in the time-like domain at large |q²|. The analysis rests on direct extraction from collision data rather than any parameter-free or circular derivation, which is a methodological strength.

major comments (1)
  1. [Born cross section measurement and subsequent global fit] The 6.6σ significance for ψ(3770)→p¯p is obtained from a global fit to the 47-point Born cross-section scan. The manuscript does not demonstrate that this significance remains stable under reasonable variations of the background functional form or under the inclusion/exclusion of additional nearby resonances, leaving open the possibility that the quoted excess could be influenced by the choice of parametrization.
minor comments (2)
  1. [Abstract and fit description] The abstract states that significances include systematic uncertainties; the main text should explicitly describe how these uncertainties are propagated into the global fit likelihood.
  2. [Form factor extraction section] The description of the proton angular distribution analysis would benefit from a clearer statement of the efficiency correction procedure and any acceptance corrections applied before extracting |G_E/G_M| and |G_M|.

Simulated Author's Rebuttal

1 responses · 0 unresolved

We thank the referee for the detailed review and the constructive comment on the robustness of our fit. We address the point below and will revise the manuscript to incorporate additional checks as requested.

read point-by-point responses

  1. Referee: The 6.6σ significance for ψ(3770)→p¯p is obtained from a global fit to the 47-point Born cross-section scan. The manuscript does not demonstrate that this significance remains stable under reasonable variations of the background functional form or under the inclusion/exclusion of additional nearby resonances, leaving open the possibility that the quoted excess could be influenced by the choice of parametrization.

    Authors: We agree that explicit demonstration of fit stability is necessary for a robust claim. In the revised manuscript we will add a dedicated subsection presenting the results of systematic variations: (i) alternative background parametrizations (different polynomial degrees and exponential forms), and (ii) fits with and without the nearby structures near 4.2 GeV. The resulting significances for the ψ(3770) signal will be tabulated; preliminary internal checks indicate the observation remains above 5σ in all tested configurations, but the full study and tables will be included in the revision. revision: yes

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged

No circularity: direct experimental measurement from collision data

full rationale

This is an experimental hep-ex paper reporting Born cross sections, decay significances, and proton form factors extracted from 47 energy points of e+e- collision data. The claimed observation (6.6σ for ψ(3770)→p p-bar) and |G_E/G_M|, |G_M| values arise from standard fits to angular distributions and invariant-mass spectra; no derivation chain reduces these quantities to their own inputs by construction. No self-definitional equations, fitted parameters renamed as predictions, or load-bearing self-citations of uniqueness theorems appear. The analysis is self-contained against external benchmarks.

Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger

0 free parameters · 0 axioms · 0 invented entities

Abstract provides no explicit free parameters, axioms, or invented entities. Standard particle-physics analysis assumptions (background parametrization, detector efficiency, resonance line shapes) are implicitly used but not detailed.

pith-pipeline@v0.9.1-grok · 9935 in / 1185 out tokens · 27971 ms · 2026-06-26T06:41:59.444299+00:00 · methodology

discussion (0)

Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

47 extracted references

  1. [1]

    (fb)p p→ -e+ (eBσT his workBESIII (2014) CLEO-c B ABAR3.4 3.6 3.8 4 4.2 4.4 4.6 4.8 5 (GeV) s1 −101 10 ) -310×(s) (effG FIG. 2. The measured Born cross sections (top) and proton effective form factors (bottom) fore +e− →p¯pas a function of the c.m. energy, in comparison to the previous measurements from BESIII [32], CLEO-c [33], andBABAR[34]. The uncer- t...

    arXiv 2014

  2. [2]

    J. J. Aubertet al.(E598 Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 33, 1404 (1974)

    1974

  3. [3]

    J. E. Augustinet al.(SLAC-SP-017), Phys. Rev. Lett. 33, 1406 (1974)

    1974

  4. [4]

    Navaset al.(Particle Data Group), Phys

    S. Navaset al.(Particle Data Group), Phys. Rev. D110, 030001 (2024)

    2024

  5. [5]

    Eichten, K

    E. Eichten, K. Gottfried, T. Kinoshita, J. B. Kogut, K. D. Lane, and T.-M. Yan, Phys. Rev. Lett.34, 369 (1975), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.Lett. 36, 1276 (1976)]

    1975

  6. [6]

    Eichten, K

    E. Eichten, K. Gottfried, T. Kinoshita, K. D. Lane, and T.-M. Yan, Phys. Rev. D17, 3090 (1978)

    1978

  7. [7]

    Eichten, K

    E. Eichten, K. Gottfried, T. Kinoshita, K. D. Lane, and T.-M. Yan, Phys. Rev. D21, 203 (1980)

    1980

  8. [8]

    Barnes, S

    T. Barnes, S. Godfrey, and E. S. Swanson, Phys. Rev. D72, 054026 (2005)

    2005

  9. [9]

    S. F. Radford and W. W. Repko, Phys. Rev. D75, 074031 (2007)

    2007

  10. [10]

    M. A. Sultan, N. Akbar, B. Masud, and F. Akram, Phys. Rev. D90, 054001 (2014)

    2014

  11. [11]

    H.-X. Chen, W. Chen, X. Liu, and S.-L. Zhu, Phys. Rept.639, 1 (2016)

    2016

  12. [12]

    S. L. Olsen, T. Skwarnicki, and D. Zieminska, Rev. Mod. Phys.90, 015003 (2018)

    2018

  13. [13]

    F.-K. Guo, C. Hanhart, U.-G. Meißner, Q. Wang, Q. Zhao, and B.-S. Zou, Rev. Mod. Phys.90, 015004 (2018)

    2018

  14. [14]

    H.-X. Chen, W. Chen, X. Liu, Y.-R. Liu, and S.-L. Zhu, Rept. Prog. Phys.86, 026201 (2023)

    2023

  15. [15]

    Wang and Q

    Q. Wang and Q. Zhao, Chin. Phys. Lett.42, 110201 (2025)

    2025

  16. [16]

    X. Wang, X. Liu, and Y. Gao, Rev. Mod. Phys.98, 021001 (2026)

    2026

  17. [17]

    Bai, D.-Y

    Z.-Y. Bai, D.-Y. Chen, Qi-Huang, X. Liu, S.-Q. Luo, and J.-Z. Wang, arXiv:2602.19887 (2026)

    arXiv 2026

  18. [18]

    Pakhlovaet al.(Belle Collaboration), Phys

    G. Pakhlovaet al.(Belle Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 172001 (2008)

    2008

  19. [19]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Phys

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett.120, 132001 (2018)

    2018

  20. [20]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII), Phys

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII), Phys. Rev. Lett.131, 191901 (2023)

    2023

  21. [21]

    K. G. Wilson, Phys. Rev. D10, 2445 (1974)

    1974

  22. [22]

    Fritzsch and M

    H. Fritzsch and M. Gell-Mann, eConfC720906V2, 135 (1972)

    1972

  23. [23]

    Hofstadter and R

    R. Hofstadter and R. W. McAllister, Phys. Rev.98, 217 (1955)

    1955

  24. [24]

    Pacetti, R

    S. Pacetti, R. Baldini Ferroli, and E. Tomasi-Gustafsson, Phys. Rept.550-551, 1 (2015)

    2015

  25. [25]

    S. J. Brodsky and G. R. Farrar, Phys. Rev. Lett.31, 1153 (1973)

    1973

  26. [26]

    K. K. Seth, S. Dobbs, Z. Metreveli, A. Tomaradze, T. Xiao, and G. Bonvicini, Phys. Rev. Lett.110, 022002 (2013)

    2013

  27. [27]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Chin

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Chin. Phys. C 39, 093001 (2015)

    2015

  28. [28]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Chin

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Chin. Phys. C 46, 113003 (2022)

    2022

  29. [29]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Nucl

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A614, 345 (2010)

    2010

  30. [30]

    Yuet al., in7th International Particle Accelerator Conference(2016) p

    C. Yuet al., in7th International Particle Accelerator Conference(2016) p. TUYA01

    2016

  31. [31]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration),Accompanied PRD version, Phys

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration),Accompanied PRD version, Phys. Rev. Dxx, xxxx (xxx)

  32. [32]

    W. Sun, T. Liu, M. Jing, L. Wang, B. Zhong, and W. Song, Front. Phys. (Beijing)16, 64501 (2021)

    2021

  33. [33]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Phys

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Phys. Lett. B 735, 101 (2014)

    2014

  34. [34]

    Dobbs, K

    S. Dobbs, K. K. Seth, A. Tomaradze, T. Xiao, and G. Bonvicini, Phys. Rev. D96, 092004 (2017)

    2017

  35. [35]

    Aubertet al.(BABARCollaboration), Phys

    B. Aubertet al.(BABARCollaboration), Phys. Rev. D 73, 012005 (2006)

    2006

  36. [36]

    Mo, HEPNP30, 140 (2006)

    X.-H. Mo, HEPNP30, 140 (2006)

    2006

  37. [37]

    Mo, HEPNP31, 745 (2007)

    X.-H. Mo, HEPNP31, 745 (2007)

    2007

  38. [38]

    Mo and Y

    X.-H. Mo and Y. S. Zhu, HEPNP27, 747 (2003)

    2003

  39. [39]

    Mo and Y

    X.-H. Mo and Y. S. Zhu, HEPNP27, 371 (2003)

    2003

  40. [40]

    Bai and D.-Y

    Y. Bai and D.-Y. Chen, Phys. Rev. D99, 072007 (2019)

    2019

  41. [41]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Chin

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Chin. Phys. C 45, 103001 (2021)

    2021

  42. [42]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Phys

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Phys. Rev. D 91, 112004 (2015)

    2015

  43. [43]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Phys

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett.124, 042001 (2020)

    2020

  44. [44]

    J. P. Leeset al.(BABARCollaboration), Phys. Rev. D 88, 072009 (2013)

    2013

  45. [45]

    Andreottiet al., Phys

    M. Andreottiet al., Phys. Lett. B559, 20 (2003)

    2003

  46. [46]

    A. F. Sillet al., Phys. Rev. D48, 29 (1993)

    1993

  47. [47]

    Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Phys

    M. Ablikimet al.(BESIII Collaboration), Phys. Rev. Lett.118, 092001 (2017). 7 M. Ablikim1 , M. N. Achasov 4,c , P. Adlarson81 , X. C. Ai 87 , C. S. Akondi 31A,31B , R. Aliberti 39 , A. Amoroso80A,80C , Q. An 77,64,†, Y. H. An 87 , Y. Bai 62 , O. Bakina 40 , H.-R. Bao 70 , X. L. Bao 49 , M. Barbagiovanni80C , V. Batozskaya1,48 , K. Begzsuren 35, N. Berger ...

    2017