Analysis of nonlinear resonances in resonator crystals: Tight-binding approximation and existence of subwavelength soliton-like solutions

Habib Ammari; Jiayu Qiu

REVIEW 5 major objections 5 minor 59 references

Analysis of nonlinear resonances in resonator crystals: Tight-binding approximation and existence of subwavelength soliton-like solutions

T0 review · 5 major / 5 minor · reviewed 2026-08-05 · deepseek-v4-flash

Challenge this review Re-run · record.json Download PDF Read on arXiv ↗

Pith's one-line read Paper proves a tight-binding limit for nonlinear subwavelength resonator crystals and the existence of localized nonlinear waves.

desk verdict Solid tight-binding approximation for nonlinear resonator crystals; soliton-existence headlines hang on an unproven spectral-gap assumption. read the letter →

arxiv 2509.04184 v1 pith:6XRQMM33 submitted 2025-09-04 math-ph math.APmath.MP

Habib Ammari , Jiayu Qiu This is my paper · ORCID

classification math-phmath.APmath.MP MSC 35P3035C2074J20

keywords nonlinearsubwavelengthresonancetight-bindingapproximationcapacitanceoperatorKerrnonlinearitydiscretegapsolitonsHelmholtzequationhigh-contrastresonatorslocalizeddefects

verification ladder T0 review T1 audit T2 compute T3 formal

The pith

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

The reading

The paper aims to put a standard physics shortcut, tight-binding modelling of periodic metamaterials, on rigorous footing for nonlinear resonator crystals. It claims that the fully continuous nonlinear Helmholtz problem with high contrast and Kerr nonlinearity reduces, with O(δ) error, to a discrete lattice equation driven by a linear capacitance operator. If true, subwavelength soliton-like waves can be studied through a lattice model rather than the full PDE, and the paper proves that such localized solutions actually exist when the capacitance spectrum has a gap, even with a localized defect. The relevance is that it provides a starting point for exact statements about nonlinear wave confinement, topological edge states, and disorder in deep-subwavelength metamaterials.

What carries the argument

The capacitance operator C is the central object: its entries are integrals of the zero-frequency exterior Dirichlet-to-Neumann map against indicator functions on resonator boundaries, encoding all electrostatic coupling between resonators. It is periodic, real valued, and exponentially decaying, so it behaves like a tight-binding Hamiltonian. The approximation proof uses an auxiliary sesquilinear form that adds per-resonator volume integrals to make the continuous problem coercive and invertible, then extracts a discrete reduced problem. The existence proof uses finite-dimensional k-periodic truncations, spectral projections, and a valley-top energy landscape argument adapted from periodic

What would settle it

Run a numerical experiment on a square lattice of circular high-contrast resonators: at δ = 10^-1, 10^-2, ..., solve both the full Helmholtz soliton (2.2) and the discrete soliton (2.6), measure the residual predicted in Theorem 2.6, and plot the spectrum of the capacitance operator C. The theorem requires the residual to shrink like O(δ) and requires a spectral gap for gap-soliton existence; if the gap is absent or the residual does not shrink accordingly, the central claims are overturned.

Watch

Extended reading notes

Core claim

The central claim is two-sided. For a periodic array of high-contrast subwavelength resonators with Kerr nonlinearity, any small continuous soliton of the nonlinear Helmholtz eigenvalue problem (2.2), integrated over each resonator, satisfies the discrete lattice equation (2.6) with eigenvalue λdisc = λcont/δ up to an O(δ) residual; conversely, any small discrete soliton lifts to an approximate continuous soliton with the same O(δ) error. This makes the tight-binding approximation via the linear capacitance operator a theorem for nonlinear resonator crystals. The paper also proves existence of exponentially decaying nontrivial solutions of the discrete equation when λ lies in a spectral gap

Load-bearing premise

The existence of the predicted localized nonlinear waves depends on the capacitance matrix (the array's coupling rule) having an empty band of frequencies, but the paper does not show that any particular resonator geometry actually produces such an empty band.

Editorial extensions

If this is right

Nonlinear resonator crystals with high contrast can be studied quantitatively through a lattice model: computing discrete solitons of (2.6) gives reliable predictions for continuous solitons of (2.2) with a linear-in-δ error bound.
The two-sided O(δ) estimates justify using resonator-averaged amplitudes as the correct discrete degrees of freedom, so numerical simulation on lattices is a valid stand-in for the full PDE in the subwavelength regime.
Whenever the capacitance operator has a spectral gap, exponentially localized gap solitons exist in the periodic crystal; with a small localized defect, defect-localized nonlinear waves also exist, providing a rigorous mechanism for nonlinear disorder localization.
The half-space version gives a pathway to rigorous statements about edge-localized nonlinear waves in truncated crystals, since the same discrete machinery applies with a Dirichlet boundary at the edge.
The tight-binding approximation of the capacitance operator is itself a by-product, giving a first proof that this widely used physical approximation holds for periodic subwavelength resonator crystals.

Reading between the lines

Editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

The paper leaves open whether any concrete periodic resonator geometry yields a spectral gap for C; computing the band structure of C for standard lattices, such as square or honeycomb arrays of disks, is the natural next test, and without such an example the gap-soliton existence results remain conditional.
The explicit O(δ) estimates suggest a practical numerical scheme: solve the discrete equation and use its lift as an initial guess for the full PDE, checking that the residual shrinks linearly with δ. This is a testable extension of the paper's claims.
The half-space identity Chalf = C − C F for reflection-symmetric lattices suggests that any lattice with a gap in C could host nonlinear edge states at its boundary; computing the spectrum of Chalf for such lattices is a concrete route to nonlinearity-induced topological states, which the authors name as future work.
The static analysis implicitly supports a time-dependent version: the same expansion should justify a discrete evolution equation on long but finite time scales, connecting these solitons to moving or breathing lattice states.

Share X Bluesky LinkedIn Reddit HN

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, and a circularity audit.

Desk Editor's Note

read the letter

Dear colleague,

The paper is worth reading for the tight-binding approximation, which is the real contribution. The first main result, Theorem 2.6, establishes an O(δ) correspondence between continuous solitons of the nonlinear Helmholtz problem and discrete solitons of the capacitance-based lattice equation. That part is solid: the proof is long, but the structure is sound and the methods are appropriate for the infinite periodic setting. The half-space version is sketched but plausible. This genuinely goes beyond prior work, which covered either linear periodic systems or nonlinear finite systems.

The second part, on discrete gap solitons with defects, is also new and the variational proof of Theorem 2.12 is reasonably detailed. But it rests on an assumption that the capacitance operator C has a spectral gap with positive lower bound and spectrum on both sides. The paper never shows that any actual resonator crystal satisfies this. The stress-test point is correct: for a single inclusion per cell (d=1), the Floquet symbol of C is continuous on the Brillouin torus, so the spectrum is an interval and no such gap exists. For d≥2, gaps might appear, but no example, parameter range, or numerical evidence is provided. So the abstract's claim that existence "is proven" overreaches; the soliton theorems are conditional on an unverified spectral property. This is load-bearing for the soliton-existence part, though it does not affect the tight-binding approximation.

Two smaller issues: Proposition 4.4, essential to the tight-binding proof, is only sketched in its solvability part ("we only sketch the idea and skip all the details"), and Proposition 2.9 plus Theorem 2.10 are stated with proofs left to the reader. These are fixable, but a referee should ask for at least the key estimates to be written out.

If the authors either exhibit a concrete d≥2 geometry with a capacitance spectral gap or explicitly frame the soliton results as conditional, the paper would be strong. The tight-binding theorem alone is a significant contribution and deserves publication. I would send this to peer review, asking the referee to push on the gap hypothesis and the sketched arguments. For people working on subwavelength metamaterials, this is useful and citable on the approximation side.

Recommendation: engage after revision on the spectral-gap condition; the core approximation result is sound.

Referee Report

5 major / 5 minor

Summary. The paper studies time-harmonic nonlinear Helmholtz problems in periodic arrays of high-contrast subwavelength resonators, in both the full-space and half-space settings. It introduces a capacitance operator C acting on ℓ2 lattice sequences and derives a discrete nonlinear eigenvalue problem (2.6), Ca − λ(1 + σ|a|^2)a = 0. The central result, Theorem 2.6, asserts that continuous L2 solitons of the PDE (2.2) with small eigenvalue are approximated by discrete solitons of (2.6) up to O(δ), and conversely. The paper additionally claims existence of discrete gap solitons (Theorems 2.11 and 2.12) when C has a spectral gap with spectrum on both sides and a small localized defect V is present. The proof strategy combines analytic estimates for the Dirichlet-to-Neumann map, an asymptotic expansion of an auxiliary variational problem, and finite-dimensional minimax arguments for periodic approximations of the lattice problem.

Significance. If fully correct, the tight-binding approximation via the capacitance operator for nonlinear periodic resonator crystals would be a valuable first-principles justification of a widely used physics approximation, and the defect gap-soliton existence would extend known DNLS results to a class of operators arising from subwavelength resonators. The paper is commendably explicit about many estimates, and it does not fit parameters to data; the discrete model is derived rather than assumed. However, the gap-soliton existence results are conditional on an unverified spectral-gap hypothesis, and the proof of the crucial asymptotic expansion in Proposition 4.4 is only sketched. In addition, the first direction of Theorem 2.6 as stated appears to require a stronger smallness condition on λcont than is actually imposed. These issues materially affect the central claims.

major comments (5)

[§4.2, Proposition 4.4] Proposition 4.4 is the technical core of Theorem 2.6, but its proof is explicitly incomplete: the text says "Here we only sketch the idea and skip all the details" for the solvability of the nonlinear remainder problem (4.7), and uniqueness is also omitted. Since the O(δ) approximation in Theorem 2.6 depends on the existence, uniqueness, and bound (4.9) for the remainder ra, the central claim is not rigorously established as written. A complete proof is needed before the tight-binding approximation can be accepted.
[§2.3, Theorem 2.6, Step 1 of §4] The proof of the first direction of Theorem 2.6 derives adisc_{λ/δ}(a,b) = δ^{-1}(r_disc_a,b) and bounds ∥r_disc_a∥ = O(λ^2 + δ^2), giving an error O(λ^2/δ + δ). This is O(δ) only if λ = O(δ). The theorem, however, only assumes λcont < λcont0 with λcont0 independent of δ. Thus the advertised O(δ) approximation is not obtained for the stated hypotheses. The statement must either impose λcont ≤ Cδ (consistent with the informal subwavelength assumption λ=O(δ) in §2.2) or the error estimate must be adjusted.
[§2.3, Theorem 2.10 and Proposition 2.9] Theorem 2.10, the half-space analogue of the main approximation theorem, is asserted without proof, and Proposition 2.9 is stated with "the details are left to the reader." Since the abstract explicitly claims that both full- and half-space crystals are considered, these are not mere presentation issues. Either full proofs must be supplied or the half-space results must be explicitly labeled as conditional/conjectural.
[§2.3, Theorems 2.11 and 2.12; §5] The existence theorems for gap solitons are conditional on the hypothesis that the capacitance operator C has a spectral gap I with inf I > 0 and spectrum on both sides. The paper nowhere proves that any periodic resonator geometry satisfies this hypothesis, nor does it give a numerical example. For d=1 with one inclusion per cell, the Floquet symbol of C is a scalar continuous function on a connected Brillouin torus, so Spec(C) is an interval and such a gap cannot exist. Thus the simplest case violates the hypothesis, and the abstract's claim that existence of subwavelength soliton-like localized waves "is proven" overstates the result. The spectral-gap condition must either be verified for a concrete geometry or clearly stated as an unproved standing assumption in the abstract and introduction.
[§5.3, final paragraph] The exponential decay of the solution a in Proposition 5.2 is dismissed with one sentence: "it is well known that a decays exponentially at infinity [40]." However, the equation involves a nonlinear term −λσ|a|^2 a and a defect V, and a is only known to lie in ℓ2 at that point. Since exponential decay is part of the theorem statement, a proof or a precise theorem from the literature that covers this setting should be provided.

minor comments (5)

[§2.3, Proposition 2.9] Typo: "e1 = (1,0), e1 = (0,1)" should read "e1 = (1,0), e2 = (0,1)".
[§2.3, Theorem 2.12] Extra parenthesis in "V ∈ ℓ1(Z2;Cd))" and in the norm notation in the assumption; please clean up.
[§4, after (4.19)] The text invokes "the assumption ∥u∥1,D ≤ M cont0", but Theorem 2.6 assumes ∥u∥L2(R2) ≤ M cont0. Either prove an H1(D) bound from the PDE or replace this by the L2(D) bound actually used in the estimates.
[§5.2, Lemma 5.3] The reduction "without loss of generality, assume a[k] is real-valued and nonnegative" is not legitimate for complex lattice vectors. A short argument splitting real and imaginary parts (and positive/negative parts) would make the proof complete.
[§5.2, Lemma 5.6, Step 3] In the text "there exists a sufficiently large ρ > 0 and a small r < 0" the condition should presumably be r > 0; also the subsequent choice of r uses r^2, so the sign is likely a typo.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged · score 0.0 of 10

No significant circularity; the derivation is self-contained, though the gap-soliton existence claims rest on an unverified spectral-gap assumption.

full rationale

The derivation chain is self-contained. Theorem 2.6 is proved by an explicit asymptotic expansion (Proposition 4.4) from the continuous weak form (2.4) and the definition of the capacitance operator (2.5), with O(δ) remainders; the discrete equation (2.6) is a conclusion of the expansion, not an input. The gap-soliton existence result, Theorem 2.12, assumes a spectral gap: 'Suppose that the capacitance operator C has a spectral gap I in the same sense as in Theorem 2.11,' and then uses a minimax construction on finite-dimensional periodic spaces (Proposition 5.1) following Pankov's DNLS framework. No parameter is fitted to data, no prediction is redefined as its input, and no load-bearing conclusion is imported solely from the authors' prior work. The only self-citation is [44] for a standard Combes-Thomas estimate used to establish exponential decay of the capacitance operator kernel; this is auxiliary and not load-bearing for the main approximation theorem. A separate, non-circularity concern is that the paper never exhibits a concrete periodic resonator geometry whose capacitance spectrum actually has the required gap I; for a single inclusion per cell the Floquet symbol is a continuous scalar function on the connected Brillouin torus, so no such gap exists. Thus the abstract's phrasing that existence of subwavelength soliton-like localized waves 'is proven' overreaches relative to the conditional theorems, but this is missing support / an unverified hypothesis, not circularity.

Assumptions & free parameters 0 free parameters · 6 assumptions · 0 invented entities

No free parameters are fitted to data; all constants are existence thresholds chosen in proofs. The main axioms are standard mathematical tools and physical modeling assumptions. The most notable hidden assumption is star-shapedness of the inclusions, which is used but never stated.

assumptions (6)

standard math The exterior Dirichlet-to-Neumann map T^λ is well defined for |λ|<λ0 via the resolvent of Lext below its spectrum.
Proved in Proposition 2.2 using Floquet-Bloch theory and a Poincaré inequality; relies on inclusions having C^1 boundary and being simply connected.
domain assumption The primitive inclusions are star-shaped so that straight rays from a fixed interior point cross ∂D at most once.
The proof of (3.1) in Section 3.1 assumes segments from an interior point O to y cross ∂D exactly once; star-shapedness is not stated in the problem formulation.
domain assumption Subwavelength regime λ=O(δ) with δ small and high contrast.
State at the end of Section 2.2; needed for the O(δ) error in Theorem 2.6.
domain assumption The capacitance operator C (and its half-space counterpart C_half) has a spectral gap I in the sense of Theorem 2.11.
Assumed for the existence theorems; not proved for any specific geometry.
domain assumption Kerr nonlinearity model with parameter σ>0 and cubic term σ|u|^2.
The whole analysis is built on this specific nonlinearity, stated in equation (2.1).
domain assumption The defect operator V is self-adjoint and bounded from ℓ∞ to ℓ1.
Condition in Theorem 2.12, used to control the deformation of the energy landscape.

how reviews work

0 comments

Cite this review

Pith. "Pith review of Analysis of nonlinear resonances in resonator crystals: Tight-binding approximation and existence of subwavelength soliton-like solutions." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/6XRQMM33

@misc{pith2026250904184,
  author       = {Pith},
  title        = {Pith review of: Analysis of nonlinear resonances in resonator crystals: Tight-binding approximation and existence of subwavelength soliton-like solutions},
  year         = {2026},
  howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/6XRQMM33}},
  note         = {Machine review of arXiv:2509.04184}
}

read the original abstract

This work provides a mathematical framework for elucidating physical mechanisms for confining waves at subwavelength scales in periodic systems of nonlinear resonators. A discrete approximation in terms of the linear capacitance operator is provided to characterize the nonlinear subwavelength resonances. Moreover, the existence of subwavelength soliton-like localized waves in periodic systems of nonlinear resonators is proven. As a by-product, a tight-binding approximation of the capacitance operator is shown to be valid for crystals of subwavelength resonators. Both full- and half-space crystals are considered. The framework developed in this work opens the door to the study of topological properties of periodic lattices of subwavelength nonlinear resonators, such as the emergence of nonlinearity-induced topological edge states, and to elucidate the interplay between nonlinearity and disorder.

Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

59 extracted references · 57 canonical work pages

[40]

Gap solitons in periodic discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations with saturable non- linearities

Alexander Pankov. Gap solitons in periodic discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations with saturable non- linearities. Journal of mathematical analysis and applications , 371(1):254–265, 2010

work page 2010
[1]

Ablowitz, Christopher W

Mark J. Ablowitz, Christopher W. Curtis, and Yi Zhu. On tight-binding approximations in optical lattices. Studies in Applied Mathematics , 129(4):362–388, 2012

work page 2012
[2]

On mathematical models for Bose–Einstein condensates in optical lattices

Amandine Aftalion and Bernard Helffer. On mathematical models for Bose–Einstein condensates in optical lattices. Reviews in Mathematical Physics , 21(02):229–278, 2009

work page 2009
[3]

Existence of solutions for semilinear elliptic equations with indefinite linear part

Stanley Alama and Yanyan Li. Existence of solutions for semilinear elliptic equations with indefinite linear part. Journal of Differential Equations , 96(1):89–115, 1992

work page 1992
[4]

Functional analytic methods for discrete ap- proximations of subwavelength resonator systems

Habib Ammari, Bryn Davies, and Erik Orvehed Hiltunen. Functional analytic methods for discrete ap- proximations of subwavelength resonator systems. Pure and Applied Analysis , 6(3):873–939, 2024

work page 2024
[5]

Mathematical theories for metamaterials: From condensed matter theory to subwavelength physics

Habib Ammari, Bryn Davies, and Erik Orvehed Hiltunen. Mathematical theories for metamaterials: From condensed matter theory to subwavelength physics . NSF–CBMS Regional Conf. Ser. American Mathemat- ical Society, to appear, 2025

work page 2025
[6]

Math- ematical and computational methods in photonics and phononics , volume 235

Habib Ammari, Brian Fitzpatrick, Hyeonbae Kang, Matias Ruiz, Sanghyeon Yu, and Hai Zhang. Math- ematical and computational methods in photonics and phononics , volume 235. American Mathematical Society, 2018

work page 2018
[7]

Nonlinear subwavelength resonances in three dimensions

Habib Ammari and Thea Kosche. Nonlinear subwavelength resonances in three dimensions. Studies in Applied Mathematics, 154(3):e70036, 2025

work page 2025

Show all 59 references

[8]

Dielectric scattering resonances for high-refractive resonators with cubic nonlinearity

Habib Ammari and Bowen Li. Dielectric scattering resonances for high-refractive resonators with cubic nonlinearity. arXiv:2508.12364, 2025. NONLINEAR RESONANCES IN RESONATOR CRYSTALS 35

2025 arXiv
[9]

Nonlinear dispersive equations, volume 156 of Mathematical Surveys and Monographs

Jaime Angulo Pava. Nonlinear dispersive equations, volume 156 of Mathematical Surveys and Monographs. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2009. Existence and stability of solitary and periodic travelling wave solutions

2009
[10]

Universal edge transport in interacting hall systems

Giovanni Antinucci, Vieri Mastropietro, and Marcello Porta. Universal edge transport in interacting hall systems. Communications in Mathematical Physics , 362(1):295–359, 2018

2018
[11]

Exponential times in the one-dimensional Gross–Pitaevskii equation with multiple well potential

Dario Bambusi and Andrea Sacchetti. Exponential times in the one-dimensional Gross–Pitaevskii equation with multiple well potential. Communications in mathematical physics , 275(1):1–36, 2007

2007
[12]

Rabinowitz

Vieri Benci and Paul H. Rabinowitz. Critical point theorems for indefinite functionals. Inventiones math- ematicae, 52(3):241–273, 1979

1979
[13]

Homoclinic solutions of discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations with asymptotically or super linear terms

Guanwei Chen and Shiwang Ma. Homoclinic solutions of discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations with asymptotically or super linear terms. Applied Mathematics and Computation , 232:787–798, 2014

2014
[14]

Perturbed Schr¨ odinger lattice systems: existence of homoclinic solutions

Guanwei Chen and Shiwang Ma. Perturbed Schr¨ odinger lattice systems: existence of homoclinic solutions. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh Section A: Mathematics , 149(4):1083–1096, 2019

2019
[15]

Discrete Schr¨ odinger equations and systems with mixed and concave- convex nonlinearities

Guanwei Chen and Shiwang Ma. Discrete Schr¨ odinger equations and systems with mixed and concave- convex nonlinearities. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society, 152(06):2621–2636, 2024

2024
[16]

Conca, J

C. Conca, J. Planchard, and M. Vanninathan. Fluids and Periodic Structures . Recherches en math´ ematiques appliqu´ ees. New York, 1995

1995
[17]

Bifurcation of nonlinear Bloch waves from the spectrum in the Gross– Pitaevskii equation

Tom´ aˇ s Dohnal and Hannes Uecker. Bifurcation of nonlinear Bloch waves from the spectrum in the Gross– Pitaevskii equation. Journal of Nonlinear Science , 26(3):581–618, 2016

2016
[18]

Eilbeck, P.S

J.C. Eilbeck, P.S. Lomdahl, and A.C. Scott. The discrete self-trapping equation. Physica D, 16:318–338, 1985

1985
[19]

Lawrence C. Evans. Partial differential equations , volume 19. American Mathematical Society, 2022

2022
[20]

Modal decompositions and point scatterer approximations near the minnaert resonance frequencies

Florian Feppon and Habib Ammari. Modal decompositions and point scatterer approximations near the minnaert resonance frequencies. Studies in Applied Mathematics , 149(1):164–229, 2022

2022
[21]

Subwavelength resonant acoustic scattering in fast time-modulated media

Florian Feppon and Habib Ammari. Subwavelength resonant acoustic scattering in fast time-modulated media. Journal de Math´ ematiques Pures et Appliqu´ ees (9), 187:233–293, 2024

2024
[22]

Approximation of a two-dimensional Gross–Pitaevskii equation with a periodic potential in the tight-binding limit

Steffen Gilg and Guido Schneider. Approximation of a two-dimensional Gross–Pitaevskii equation with a periodic potential in the tight-binding limit. Mathematische Nachrichten , 297(10):3870–3886, 2024

2024
[23]

Heinz, T

H.-P. Heinz, T. K¨ upper, and C.A. Stuart. Existence and bifurcation of solutions for nonlinear perturba- tions of the periodic Schr¨ odinger equation.Journal of Differential Equations , 100(2):341–354, 1992

1992
[24]

Weinstein

Andrew Hofstrand, Huaiyu Li, and Michael I. Weinstein. Discrete breathers of nonlinear dimer lattices: bridging the anti-continuous and continuous limits. Journal of Nonlinear Science , 33(4):59, 2023

2023
[25]

Hussein, M.J

M.I. Hussein, M.J. Leamy, and M. Ruzzene. Dynamics of phononic materials and structures: Historical origins, recent progress, and future outlook. Applied Mechanics Reviews, 66:040802, 2014

2014
[26]

Weinstein

Boaz Ilan and Michael I. Weinstein. Band-edge solitons, nonlinear Schr¨ odinger/Gross–Pitaevskii equa- tions, and effective media. Multiscale Modeling & Simulation , 8(4):1055–1101, 2010

2010
[27]

A remark on least energy solutions in Rn

Louis Jeanjean and Kazunaga Tanaka. A remark on least energy solutions in Rn. Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society, 131(8):2399–2408, 2003

2003
[28]

Existence of homoclinic solutions for higher-order periodic difference equations with p- laplacian

Juhong Kuang. Existence of homoclinic solutions for higher-order periodic difference equations with p- laplacian. Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications , 417(2):904–917, 2014

2014
[29]

K¨ upper and C.A

T. K¨ upper and C.A. Stuart. Necessary and sufficient conditions for gap-bifurcation. Nonlinear Analysis: Theory, Methods & Applications , 18(9):893–903, 1992

1992
[30]

Wave propagation control at the deep subwavelength scale in metamaterials

Fabrice Lemoult, Nad` ege Kaina, Mathias Fink, and Geoffroy Lerosey. Wave propagation control at the deep subwavelength scale in metamaterials. Nature Phys., 9:55–60, 2013

2013
[31]

A first course in Sobolev spaces , volume 181

Giovanni Leoni. A first course in Sobolev spaces , volume 181. American Mathematical Society, 2024

2024
[32]

Edge solitons in nonlinear-photonic topological insulators

Daniel Leykam and Yi Dong Chong. Edge solitons in nonlinear-photonic topological insulators. Physical review letters, 117(14):143901, 2016

2016
[33]

Topological bulk solitons in a nonlinear photonic chern insulator

Rujiang Li, Xiangyu Kong, Dongkai Hang, Guoyi Li, Hongyu Hu, Hao Zhou, Yongtao Jia, Pengfei Li, and Ying Liu. Topological bulk solitons in a nonlinear photonic chern insulator. Communications Physics, 5(1):275, 2022

2022
[34]

Homoclinic solutions of periodic discrete Schr¨ odinger equations with local superquadratic conditions

Genghong Lin and Jianshe Yu. Homoclinic solutions of periodic discrete Schr¨ odinger equations with local superquadratic conditions. SIAM Journal on Mathematical Analysis , 54(2):1966–2005, 2022

1966
[35]

The concentration-compactness principle in the calculus of variations

Pierre-Louis Lions. The concentration-compactness principle in the calculus of variations. the locally compact case, part 1. In Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincar´ e C, Analyse non lin´ eaire, volume 1, pages 109–145. Elsevier, 1984. 36 HABIB AMMARI AND JIAYU QIU

1984
[36]

Ma and P

G. Ma and P. Sheng. Acoustic metamaterials: From local resonances to broad horizons. Science Advances, 2(2):2:e1501595, 2016

2016
[37]

Mukherjee and M.C

S. Mukherjee and M.C. Rechtsman. Observation of floquet solitons in a topological bandgap. Science, 368:856–859, 2020

2020
[38]

Observation of Floquet solitons in a topological bandgap

Sebabrata Mukherjee and Mikael C Rechtsman. Observation of Floquet solitons in a topological bandgap. Science, 368(6493):856–859, 2020

2020
[39]

A. Pankov. Periodic nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equation with application to photonic crystals.Milan Journal of Mathematics , 73(1):259–287, Oct 2005

2005
[41]

Bounds on the tight-binding approximation for the Gross– Pitaevskii equation with a periodic potential

Dmitry Pelinovsky and Guido Schneider. Bounds on the tight-binding approximation for the Gross– Pitaevskii equation with a periodic potential. Journal of Differential Equations , 248(4):837–849, 2010

2010
[42]

Dmitry Pelinovsky, Guido Schneider, and Robert S. MacKay. Justification of the lattice equation for a nonlinear elliptic problem with a periodic potential.Communications in mathematical physics, 284(3):803– 831, 2008

2008
[43]

Pelinovsky

Dmitry E. Pelinovsky. Localization in periodic potentials: from Schr¨ odinger operators to the Gross– Pitaevskii equation, volume 390. Cambridge University Press, 2011

2011
[44]

Bulk-edge correspondence in finite photonic structure

Jiayu Qiu and Hai Zhang. Bulk-edge correspondence in finite photonic structure. arXiv preprint arXiv:2501.15531, 2025

2025 arXiv
[45]

Derivation of the tight-binding approximation for time-dependent nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations

Andrea Sacchetti. Derivation of the tight-binding approximation for time-dependent nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations. In Annales Henri Poincar´ e, volume 21, pages 627–648. Springer, 2020

2020
[46]

Perturbation theory for nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations

Andrea Sacchetti. Perturbation theory for nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations. Nonlinearity, 36(11):6048, 2023

2023
[47]

Shankar, A

S. Shankar, A. Souslov, M.J. Bowick, M.C. Marchetti, and V. Vitelli. Topological active matter. Nature Reviews Physics, 4:380–398, 2022

2022
[48]

Weinstein

Jacob Shapiro and Michael I. Weinstein. Tight-binding reduction and topological equivalence in strong magnetic fields. Advances in Mathematics , 403:108343, 2022

2022
[49]

Existence of gap solitons in periodic discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations

Haiping Shi and Hongqiang Zhang. Existence of gap solitons in periodic discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations. Journal of Mathematical Analysis and Applications , 361(2):411–419, 2010

2010
[50]

Nonlinear topological photonics

Daria Smirnova, Daniel Leykam, Yidong Chong, and Yuri Kivshar. Nonlinear topological photonics. Applied Physics Reviews , 7(2), 2020

2020
[51]

Smirnova, Lev A

Daria A. Smirnova, Lev A. Smirnov, Daniel Leykam, and Yuri S. Kivshar. Topological edge states and gap solitons in the nonlinear dirac model. Laser & Photonics Reviews , 13(12):1900223, 2019

2019
[52]

Nonlinearity- induced topological phase transition characterized by the nonlinear chern number

Kazuki Sone, Motohiko Ezawa, Yuto Ashida, Nobuyuki Yoshioka, and Takahiro Sagawa. Nonlinearity- induced topological phase transition characterized by the nonlinear chern number. Nature Physics , 20(7):1164–1170, 2024

2024
[53]

C.A. Stuart. Bifurcation from the essential spectrum. Topological Nonlinear Analysis II: Degree, Singu- larity and Variations , pages 397–443, 1997

1997
[54]

Szameit and M.C

A. Szameit and M.C. Rechtsman. Discrete nonlinear topological photonics. Nature Physics, 20:905–912, 2024

2024
[55]

Veenstra, O

J. Veenstra, O. Gamayun, X. Guo, A. Sarvi, C.V. Meinersen, and C. Coulais. Non-reciprocal topological solitons in active metamaterials. Nature, 627:528–533, 2024

2024
[56]

Finite element method and its analysis for a nonlinear helmholtz equation with high wave numbers

Haijun Wu and Jun Zou. Finite element method and its analysis for a nonlinear helmholtz equation with high wave numbers. SIAM Journal on Numerical Analysis , 56(3):1338–1359, 2018

2018
[57]

Breather solutions of the discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations with unbounded po- tentials

Guoping Zhang. Breather solutions of the discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations with unbounded po- tentials. Journal of Mathematical Physics , 50(1), 2009

2009
[58]

On the existence of homoclinic solutions of a class of discrete nonlinear periodic systems

Zhan Zhou and Jianshe Yu. On the existence of homoclinic solutions of a class of discrete nonlinear periodic systems. Journal of Differential Equations , 249(5):1199–1212, 2010

2010
[59]

On the existence of gap solitons in a periodic discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equation with saturable nonlinearity.Nonlinearity, 23(7):1727, 2010

Zhan Zhou, Jianshe Yu, and Yuming Chen. On the existence of gap solitons in a periodic discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equation with saturable nonlinearity.Nonlinearity, 23(7):1727, 2010. NONLINEAR RESONANCES IN RESONATOR CRYSTALS 37 (H. Ammari) Department of Mathematics, ETH...

2010

Pith tools

Reviewed August 5, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.

[1] [40]

Gap solitons in periodic discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations with saturable non- linearities

Alexander Pankov. Gap solitons in periodic discrete nonlinear Schr¨ odinger equations with saturable non- linearities. Journal of mathematical analysis and applications , 371(1):254–265, 2010

work page 2010

[2] [1]

Ablowitz, Christopher W

Mark J. Ablowitz, Christopher W. Curtis, and Yi Zhu. On tight-binding approximations in optical lattices. Studies in Applied Mathematics , 129(4):362–388, 2012

work page 2012

[3] [2]

On mathematical models for Bose–Einstein condensates in optical lattices

Amandine Aftalion and Bernard Helffer. On mathematical models for Bose–Einstein condensates in optical lattices. Reviews in Mathematical Physics , 21(02):229–278, 2009

work page 2009

[4] [3]

Existence of solutions for semilinear elliptic equations with indefinite linear part

Stanley Alama and Yanyan Li. Existence of solutions for semilinear elliptic equations with indefinite linear part. Journal of Differential Equations , 96(1):89–115, 1992

work page 1992

[5] [4]

Functional analytic methods for discrete ap- proximations of subwavelength resonator systems

Habib Ammari, Bryn Davies, and Erik Orvehed Hiltunen. Functional analytic methods for discrete ap- proximations of subwavelength resonator systems. Pure and Applied Analysis , 6(3):873–939, 2024

work page 2024

[6] [5]

Mathematical theories for metamaterials: From condensed matter theory to subwavelength physics

Habib Ammari, Bryn Davies, and Erik Orvehed Hiltunen. Mathematical theories for metamaterials: From condensed matter theory to subwavelength physics . NSF–CBMS Regional Conf. Ser. American Mathemat- ical Society, to appear, 2025

work page 2025

[7] [6]

Math- ematical and computational methods in photonics and phononics , volume 235

Habib Ammari, Brian Fitzpatrick, Hyeonbae Kang, Matias Ruiz, Sanghyeon Yu, and Hai Zhang. Math- ematical and computational methods in photonics and phononics , volume 235. American Mathematical Society, 2018

work page 2018

[8] [7]

Nonlinear subwavelength resonances in three dimensions

Habib Ammari and Thea Kosche. Nonlinear subwavelength resonances in three dimensions. Studies in Applied Mathematics, 154(3):e70036, 2025

work page 2025