REVIEW 4 major objections 6 minor 92 references
Quantifying Chromosphere Response to Flare Energy Release Using AIA Observations in 1600~\AA\ and 304~\AA\ Passbands
T0 review · 4 major / 6 minor · reviewed 2026-08-15 · deepseek-v4-flash
Pith's one-line read AIA 1600 Å brightness is a meaningful chromosphere photometer.
desk verdict Solid, transparent calibration study of AIA flare ribbon photometry that deserves peer review, but the per-event zero-point validation is missing. read the letter →
The pith
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
The reading
What carries the argument
The central object is relative photometry built on the mode of the pixel brightness distribution. The quiescent brightness $I_q$ is defined as the pre-flare histogram mode, and the residual pixel brightness $I' = I - I_p$ subtracts each pixel's first-five-minute mean. These define the flaring-pixel criteria $I' \ge (3,4,5)I_q$ sustained for $\tau_c = 4$ minutes, which separate flare ribbons from the plage population that sits near $3I_q$. The timescale analysis combines three measurements - threshold times to $I' = (3,4,5)I_q$, half-rise and half-decay times, and Gaussian or exponential fits - and epoch plots align thousands of pixel light curves at their peaks to expose the average rise and the two-phase decay.
What would settle it
Apply the same ribbon-pixel identification to a flare that begins inside the first five minutes of the observing window, or to a deliberately small field of view, and check whether the derived $I_q$ shifts by more than the Poisson scatter quoted in Section 3.1; if it does, the relative thresholds and all reported timescales are re-scaled. In parallel, compare AIA 1600 Å relative brightness with simultaneous spectral observations of the C IV doublet and UV continuum in a handful of ribbon pixels, since the proxy would be falsified if the relative brightness and its rise and decay times do not track the spectroscopically measured chromosphere response.
Extended reading notes
Core claim
Using the mode of the active-region pixel brightness histogram as the quiescent reference $I_q$, and subtracting each pixel's own pre-flare mean $I_p$ to form the residual $I' = I - I_p$, the paper identifies flare ribbon pixels by the criterion $I' \ge 3I_q$ sustained for at least four minutes. Thousands of ribbon pixels are isolated per flare with this definition. The central finding is that pixels with $I'_m/I_q > 10$ have half-rise times below about two minutes and a two-phase decay, with a fast decay on roughly the rise timescale followed by a gradual decay of order ten minutes. In the three flares also examined in 304 Å, the same pixels peak within about half a minute in both passbands and their normalized peak brightnesses follow a power law, $R_{m,304} \approx 10^{1.42} R_{m,1600}^{0.64}$ for the M7.3 flare, with similar exponents in the other two events. The paper concludes that AIA 1600 Å brightness relative to $I_q$ is a meaningful, semi-quantitative measure of flare chromosphere photometry, and that plage brightness remains stable at about $3I_q$ once instrument degradation and center-to-limb variation are accounted for.
Load-bearing premise
The analysis assumes that the quiet, non-flaring pixel brightness of the active region stays constant through the flare, so that subtracting the pre-flare image and comparing to this fixed level cleanly separates flare ribbons from ordinary bright plage.
Editorial extensions
If this is right
- AIA's 1600 Å images, taken every 24 seconds since 2010, can serve as a flare-chromosphere photometry database, extending ribbon-based reconnection-flux and energy-release measurements to large samples.
- The stability of the $3I_q$ plage threshold means the same automated ribbon-identification algorithm can be applied across flares observed over a decade without re-tuning the threshold.
- The sub-2-minute rise and two-phase decay of bright ribbon pixels give direct observational targets for radiative-hydrodynamic and MHD flare models that prescribe or compute chromospheric heating.
- The power-law scaling between 1600 Å and 304 Å ribbon peak brightness provides a cross-wavelength constraint on where in the lower atmosphere the flare energy is deposited.
- The similar pixel-level rise and decay statistics across flares of different GOES classes suggest a common characteristic timescale for AIA-resolved energy release events.
Reading between the lines
- Inference: If AIA's 12-24 s cadence and 1-2 arcsecond resolution set an upper limit on the measured 1-2 minute pixel rise times, the elementary reconnection events may be substantially shorter; a testable extension is to cross-correlate these ribbon pixels with higher-cadence, diffraction-limited observations and see whether the rise-time distribution shifts to shorter values.
- Inference: The empirically stable power law between 1600 Å and 304 Å peak brightness could, when combined with spectral synthesis, be inverted as a crude two-passband temperature diagnostic for the flaring lower atmosphere, separating the contributions of C IV, UV continuum, and He II emission.
- Inference: The finding that a fixed relative threshold $3I_q$ works across a decade of CCD degradation suggests an automated flare-ribbon tracker could be run over the full AIA archive, enabling tests of whether the $10I_q$ bright-pixel threshold separates impulsive from gradual chromosphere heating regimes.
Signed reviews
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript develops a semi-quantitative photometric method for AIA 1600 Å and 304 Å flare ribbon pixels. For 18 flares, the authors define the quiescent brightness Iq as the mode of the active-region pixel brightness histogram and the residual brightness I'=I-Ip, where Ip is the per-pixel mean over the first five minutes. Flare pixels are selected by I'≥N Iq for N=3,4,5 sustained for τc=4 min, and the authors measure peak brightness relative to Iq and rise/decay timescales using half-times, threshold intervals, and (initially) Gaussian/exponential fits. They report that bright pixels with I'm≥10 Iq have half rise times below 2 min and two-phase decays, that plage is consistently at about 3 Iq across a decade, that Iq variations track CCD degradation and center-to-limb changes using Skylab spectra, and that 1600 Å and 304 Å peak brightnesses obey a power law with similar exponents in three flares.
Significance. If correct, the central claim—that AIA 1600 Å brightness relative to pre-flare Iq is a meaningful chromospheric flare photometry—would open a decade-long database for statistical studies of flare ribbon energetics at elementary spatial scales. The paper's strengths include the use of legacy Skylab spectra for external calibration, the explicit examination of three independent timescale definitions, the construction of epoch plots over thousands of pixels, and a candid discussion of threshold sensitivity and the two-phase decay. The cross-passband comparison and the magnetic-field scaling of non-flaring brightness are useful empirical constraints. However, the photometric zero point and the threshold choices are not yet validated per event with quantified uncertainty, so the quantitative conclusions should be regarded as provisional.
major comments (4)
- [Section 3.1 and Table 1] The stability of the zero point is asserted rather than demonstrated for all 18 events. The entire relative photometry—I'=I-Ip, the N=3,4,5 thresholds, the 10Iq bright-flare boundary, and all derived timescales—rests on Iq being the uncontaminated pre-flare mode and Ip being a genuinely pre-flare baseline. The text states that the mode is stable 'as long as the size of the images is sufficiently large' and supports this with Poisson-fluctuation checks for three example regions, but Table 1 gives neither cutout sizes nor ribbon-area fractions for the remaining events, and the first-five-minute baseline is not checked for early flare brightening. Please provide per-event diagnostics (e.g., a time series of the mode beginning at least 30 min before onset, ribbon-area fraction for every event, and a comparison of the first-five-minute baseline with a later quiet interval) and propagate the resulting zero-point uncertainty into the threshold-based timescales and the bright-flare classification.
- [Section 3.2 and Figures 4-6] The identification thresholds are tuned on the same data used for the headline claims, making the central timing result partly self-referential. The text says that N=3,4,5 was chosen 'based on the histograms,' that τc=4 min was chosen after examining the extended pixel timescales in Figure 4d, and that the 10Iq bright-flare definition was introduced after inspecting the ⟨τh⟩ versus ⟨I'm/Iq⟩ trend in Figure 5b. With these selections, the statement that bright flares have half rise times under 2 min is a property of a class defined from that same plot. I ask for an out-of-sample or split-sample check: fix thresholds on a subset of events (or from physical priors), then report the timing statistics on the withheld events, and show how the conclusions change for reasonable alternative choices (e.g., τc=2 and 6 min, N=2 and 6).
- [Table 1 and Figures 5-6] The median timescales are reported without uncertainty estimates. For example, Table 1 lists ⟨τr^h⟩ and ⟨τd^h⟩ to one decimal place for each event, and Figure 5 shows only the spread across N for the threshold-time measurements; there is no bootstrap or interquartile-range information, and Figure 6 aggregates all pixels without marking sampling uncertainty. Because the abstract's quantitative statements ('half rise time below 2 min', 'two-phase decay') depend on these medians, please add confidence intervals (bootstrap or percentile-based) and state the number of pixels contributing to each median, including how multi-peaked light curves are handled.
- [Section 3.5] The external calibration validates the non-flaring and decay-phase spectral content but not the impulsive-phase per-pixel baseline. The synthetic flare curve in Figure 7b is convolved from a decay-phase X1.0 spectrum, whereas the ribbon pixels analyzed in Section 3.3 peak during the impulsive phase, where the C IV doublet and continuum enhancement alter the spectral mix in the 1600 Å band. The paper is appropriately cautious in calling the photometry 'semi-quantitative', but the abstract's concluding claim that AIA 1600 Å brightness relative to Iq is 'a meaningful measurement of the flare chromosphere photometry' overreaches this calibration. Please either soften the claim or add a sensitivity estimate using available impulsive-phase spectra to show how DN/s maps to physical intensity during the rise.
minor comments (6)
- [Section 1] The Fermi instrument is abbreviated as 'GMB' in the first paragraph; this should be 'GBM'. Also, the accented characters in 'Simões' appear corrupted in several places and should be fixed throughout.
- [Figure 2 caption] The caption contains the typo 'supplementary materiel'; it should read 'supplementary material'.
- [Table 1] The column header 'timeb and magnitude' is difficult to parse; consider separating the GOES class and the peak time into distinct columns with explicit units, and clarify which time is used as the reference for the rise and decay measurements.
- [Section 3.3, Figure 5b] The statement that ⟨τh⟩ is 'nearly inversely proportional' to peak brightness is not quantified; either add a fitted scaling law with uncertainty or describe the trend qualitatively without implying a functional form.
- [Section 4.3] The word 'structurous' should be 'structured', and the three timescale definitions for the 304 Å rise time (half-time, threshold-time, Gaussian time) should be defined explicitly before the histograms in Figure 11f are discussed.
- [Section 5.2] The paper states that timescales below 30 s cannot be properly revealed in the AIA analysis, but Section 4.3 says that timescales below 1 min cannot be properly determined; these two statements should be reconciled.
Circularity Check
No significant circularity: the relative-photometry calibration is anchored to external Skylab spectra, and the headline timescales do not reduce to the fitted thresholds.
full rationale
The paper's central quantity is I'/Iq with Iq defined as the pre-flare mode of the pixel-brightness histogram and I' = I - Ip. This is a measurement convention, not a derived prediction. The key claim that AIA 1600 Å brightness relative to Iq is a meaningful chromospheric photometry is validated externally in Section 3.5: the authors convolve the independent Skylab NRL SO82B plage and flare spectra from Simões et al. (2019) with time-dependent AIA response functions and show that 3Iq, the observed plage hump, lands on the synthetic plage curve, while the synthetic flare brightness reproduces the brightest relative flare brightness in Table 1. This anchors Iq to an external spectral benchmark rather than to the same histograms that define it. The headline timescale results are also not forced by the thresholds: half-rise and half-decay times are measured between the peak and half-peak of each pixel light curve, independent of the 3/4/5 Iq ribbon thresholds and of the 10Iq 'bright flare' label. The bright-flare criterion is applied post hoc to events with mean I'm/Iq > 10 after observing the correlation in Figure 5; calling these events 'bright' and reporting their short half-rise times is an empirical association, not a logical consequence of the definition. Self-citations (Qiu et al. 2010, 2013, 2021; Qiu and Cheng 2022) are contextual and none carries the derivation; no uniqueness theorem or ansatz is imported from the authors' prior work. Potential concerns about mode stability or early-flare contamination of Ip are measurement-uncertainty issues, not cases where the output equals the input by construction.
Assumptions & free parameters
free parameters (7)
- Flare pixel relative threshold N =
3, 4, 5 Iq for 1600 Å; 9, 14, 19 Iq for 304 Å
- Minimum brightening duration tau_c =
4 min
- Bright flare classification threshold =
I'm/Iq > 10
- 1600-304 power-law exponent =
0.64 +/- 0.01, 0.62 +/- 0.01, 0.58 +/- 0.01 in three flares
- 1600-304 power-law intercept =
10^1.42, 10^1.46, 10^1.86
- Center-to-limb linear fit coefficients =
slope 25.7 +/- 0.8, intercept 53.7 +/- 5.2 DN/s
- Brightness-magnetic field power law =
alpha = 0.31 +/- 0.03, beta = -0.30 +/- 0.05
assumptions (6)
- domain assumption AIA level 1.5 calibration, exposure normalization, and differential rotation alignment are accurate.
- domain assumption The mode of the pixel brightness histogram is a stable estimator of quiescent emission that is not biased by flare pixels.
- domain assumption The first five minutes of data represent a valid pre-flare background for every pixel.
- domain assumption Chromosphere brightening at 10-20 s cadence maps coronal energy release approximately instantaneously.
- domain assumption Skylab plage and flare spectra from Simoes et al. (2019) are representative of the 18 active regions.
- domain assumption Pixels with |delta t_m| <= 2 min in 1600 and 304 are dominated by ribbon, not loop, emission.
Cite this review
Pith. "Pith review of Quantifying Chromosphere Response to Flare Energy Release Using AIA Observations in 1600~\AA\ and 304~\AA\ Passbands." pith.science (2026). https://pith.science/paper/X36M3RXT
@misc{pith2026250513728,
author = {Pith},
title = {Pith review of: Quantifying Chromosphere Response to Flare Energy Release Using AIA Observations in 1600~\AA\ and 304~\AA\ Passbands},
year = {2026},
howpublished = {\url{https://pith.science/paper/X36M3RXT}},
note = {Machine review of arXiv:2505.13728}
}
read the original abstract
Imaging observations of the solar lower atmosphere by the Atmosphere Imaging Assembly (AIA) have been mostly used as the context, and their quantitative information has been much less explored. The chromosphere responds rapidly to energy release by magnetic reconnection during flares. Furthermore, a flare is a collection of multiple energy release events that can be identified in spatially resolved chromosphere observations. In this paper, we conduct a statistical and semi-quantitative study of the relative photometry in the UV 1600~\AA\ and EUV 304~\AA\ passbands for 18 flares observed by AIA. In each flare, we have identified thousands of flare ribbon pixels in the UV 1600~\AA\ images, and measured their brightness (counts per second) and the rise and decay timescales, which are indicative of heating properties in flare loops. The analysis shows that bright flare pixels, characterized by peak brightness larger than ten times the quiescent brightness, exhibit sharp light curves with the half rise time below 2 min, followed by a two-phase decay with a rapid decay on timescales comparable to the rise time and then a more gradual decay. Flare ribbon pixels identified in both UV 1600 ~\AA\ and EUV 304~\AA\ images exhibit similar time profiles during the rise, and their peak brightness appear to be related by a power law. Our analysis shows that AIA observed flare brightness in UV 1600~\AA\ relative to the quiescent brightness is a meaningful measurement of the flare chromosphere photometry, and AIA observations for over a decade thus provide a unique and extensive database for systematic and semi-quantitative study of flaring chromosphere, either in the context of the Sun as a star, or in spatially resolved manner that helps to probe the nature of flare energy release on elementary scales.
Figures
Figures from the paper (10 more)
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
barticle Alexander , D. , Coyner , A.J. : 2006 , Temporal and Spatial Relationships between Ultraviolet and Hard X-Ray Emission in Solar Flares . 640 , 505 . https://doi.org/10.1086/500076 . 2006ApJ...640..505A . barticle
-
[2]
barticle Allred , J.C. , Kowalski , A.F. , Carlsson , M. : 2015 , A Unified Computational Model for Solar and Stellar Flares . 809 , 104 . https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/809/1/104 . 2015ApJ...809..104A . barticle
-
[3]
barticle Antolin , P. , Auch \`e re , F. , Winch , E. , Soubri \'e , E. , Oliver , R. : 2024 , Decomposing the AIA 304 A Channel into Its Cool and Hot Components . 299 , 94 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s11207-024-02337-4 . 2024SoPh..299...94A . barticle
-
[4]
barticle Asai , A. , Yokoyama , T. , Shimojo , M. , Masuda , S. , Kurokawa , H. , Shibata , K. : 2004 , Flare Ribbon Expansion and Energy Release Rate . 611 , 557 . https://doi.org/10.1086/422159 . 2004ApJ...611..557A . barticle
doi:10.1086/422159 2004
-
[5]
barticle Aschwanden , M.J. , Alexander , D. : 2001 , Flare Plasma Cooling from 30 MK down to 1 MK modeled from Yohkoh, GOES, and TRACE observations during the Bastille Day Event (14 July 2000) . 204 , 91 . https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1014257826116 . 2001SoPh..204...91A . barticle
-
[6]
barticle Bobra , M.G. , Sun , X. , Hoeksema , J.T. , Turmon , M. , Liu , Y. , Hayashi , K. , Barnes , G. , Leka , K.D. : 2014 , The Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) Vector Magnetic Field Pipeline: SHARPs - Space-Weather HMI Active Region Patches . 289 , 3549 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s11207-014-0529-3 . 2014SoPh..289.3549B . barticle
-
[7]
barticle Brannon , S.R. , Longcope , D.W. , Qiu , J. : 2015 , Spectroscopic Observations of an Evolving Flare Ribbon Substructure Suggesting Origin in Current Sheet Waves . 810 , 4 . https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/810/1/4 . 2015ApJ...810....4B . barticle
-
[8]
barticle Brekke , P. , Kjeldseth-Moe , O. : 1994 , The solar UV continuum 1440-1680 A and its center-to-limb variation . 150 , 19 . https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00712874 . 1994SoPh..150...19B . barticle
Show all 92 references
-
[9]
, Daw , A.N
barticle Brosius , J.W. , Daw , A.N. , Inglis , A.R. : 2016 , Quasi-periodic Fluctuations and Chromospheric Evaporation in a Solar Flare Ribbon Observed by Hinode/EIS, IRIS, and RHESSI . 830 , 101 . https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-637X/830/2/101 . 2016ApJ...830..101B . barticle
2016 doi
-
[10]
, Gorceix , N
barticle Cao , W. , Gorceix , N. , Coulter , R. , Ahn , K. , Rimmele , T.R. , Goode , P.R. : 2010 , Scientific instrumentation for the 1.6 m New Solar Telescope in Big Bear . Astronomische Nachrichten 331 , 636 . https://doi.org/10.1002/asna.201011390 . 2010AN....331..636C . barticle
2010 doi
-
[11]
: 1990 , Ultraviolet Observations of the Preimpulsive Phase in a Solar Flare: Enhanced Turbulence and Heating
barticle Cheng , C.-C. : 1990 , Ultraviolet Observations of the Preimpulsive Phase in a Solar Flare: Enhanced Turbulence and Heating . 349 , 362 . https://doi.org/10.1086/168319 . 1990ApJ...349..362C . barticle
1990 doi
-
[12]
, Boerner , P
barticle Cheung , M.C.M. , Boerner , P. , Schrijver , C.J. , Testa , P. , Chen , F. , Peter , H. , Malanushenko , A. : 2015 , Thermal Diagnostics with the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly on board the Solar Dynamics Observatory: A Validated Method for Differential Emission Measure...
2015 doi
-
[13]
, Rempel , M
barticle Cheung , M.C.M. , Rempel , M. , Chintzoglou , G. , Chen , F. , Testa , P. , Mart \' nez-Sykora , J. , Sainz Dalda , A. , DeRosa , M.L. , Malanushenko , A. , Hansteen , V. , De Pontieu , B. , Carlsson , M. , Gudiksen , B. , McIntosh , S.W. : 2019 , A comprehensive thre...
2019 doi
-
[14]
, Podladchikova , T
barticle Chikunova , G. , Podladchikova , T. , Dissauer , K. , Veronig , A.M. , Dumbovi \'c , M. , Temmer , M. , Dickson , E.C.M. : 2023 , Three-dimensional relation between coronal dimming, filament eruption, and CME. A case study of the 28 October 2021 X1.0 event . 678 , A16...
2023 doi
-
[15]
, Brueckner , G.E
barticle Cook , J.W. , Brueckner , G.E. : 1979 , EUV continua of solar flares 1420 - 1960 A . 227 , 645 . https://doi.org/10.1086/156775 . 1979ApJ...227..645C . barticle
1979 doi
-
[16]
, Antolin , P
barticle S ahin , S. , Antolin , P. : 2024 , From Chromospheric Evaporation to Coronal Rain: An Investigation of the Mass and Energy Cycle of a Flare . 970 , 106 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ad4ed9 . 2024ApJ...970..106S . barticle
2024 doi
-
[17]
, Antiochos , S.K
botherref Dahlin , J.T. , Antiochos , S.K. , DeVore , C.R. , Wyper , P.F. , Qiu , J. : 2025, Determining the 3D Dynamics of Solar Flare Magnetic Reconnection . arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2504.00913. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2504.00913 . 2025arXiv250400913D . botherref
2025 doi
-
[18]
, Title , A.M
barticle De Pontieu , B. , Title , A.M. , Lemen , J.R. , Kushner , G.D. , Akin , D.J. , Allard , B. , Berger , T. , Boerner , P. , Cheung , M. , Chou , C. , Drake , J.F. , Duncan , D.W. , Freeland , S. , Heyman , G.F. , Hoffman , C. , Hurlburt , N.E. , Lindgren , R.W. , Mathur...
2014
-
[19]
, Cook , J.W
barticle Doyle , J.G. , Cook , J.W. : 1992 , The Sun as a Star: High Spectral Resolution Solar Data Degraded to Low-Dispersion IUE Resolution . 391 , 393 . https://doi.org/10.1086/171354 . 1992ApJ...391..393D . barticle
1992 doi
-
[20]
, Canfield , R.C
barticle Fisher , G.H. , Canfield , R.C. , McClymont , A.N. : 1985 a, Flare Loop Radiative Hydrodynamics - Part Seven - Dynamics of the Thick Target Heated Chromosphere . 289 , 434 . https://doi.org/10.1086/162903 . 1985ApJ...289..434F . barticle
1985 doi
-
[21]
, Canfield , R.C
barticle Fisher , G.H. , Canfield , R.C. , McClymont , A.N. : 1985 b, Flare Loop Radiative Hydrodynamics - Part Six - Chromospheric Evaporation due to Heating by Nonthermal Electrons . 289 , 425 . https://doi.org/10.1086/162902 . 1985ApJ...289..425F . barticle
1985 doi
-
[22]
, Canfield , R.C
barticle Fisher , G.H. , Canfield , R.C. , McClymont , A.N. : 1985 c, Flare loop radiative hydrodynamics. V - Response to thick-target heating. VI - Chromospheric evaporation due to heating by nonthermal electrons. VII - Dynamics of the thick-target heated chromosphere . 289 ,...
1985 doi
-
[23]
: 2024 , Solar Flare Spectroscopy
barticle Fletcher , L. : 2024 , Solar Flare Spectroscopy . Annual Review of Astronomy and Astrophysics 62 , 437 . https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-astro-052920-010547 . 2024ARA&A..62..437F . barticle
2024 doi
-
[24]
, Hudson , H
barticle Fletcher , L. , Hudson , H. : 2001 , The Magnetic Structure and Generation of EUV Flare Ribbons . 204 , 69 . https://doi.org/10.1023/A:1014275821318 . 2001SoPh..204...69F . barticle
2001 doi
-
[25]
, Hudson , H.S
barticle Fletcher , L. , Hudson , H.S. : 2008 , Impulsive Phase Flare Energy Transport by Large-Scale Alfv \'e n Waves and the Electron Acceleration Problem . 675 , 1645 . https://doi.org/10.1086/527044 . 2008ApJ...675.1645F . barticle
2008 doi
-
[26]
, Killeen , J
barticle Furth , H.P. , Killeen , J. , Rosenbluth , M.N. : 1963 , Finite-Resistivity Instabilities of a Sheet Pinch . Physics of Fluids 6 , 459 . https://doi.org/10.1063/1.1706761 . 1963PhFl....6..459F . barticle
1963 doi
-
[27]
, Zhang , H.Q
barticle Gan , W.Q. , Zhang , H.Q. , Fang , C. : 1991 , A hydrodynamic model of the impulsive phase of a solar flare loop . 241 , 618 . 1991A\ barticle
1991
-
[28]
, Cauzzi , G
barticle Graham , D.R. , Cauzzi , G. : 2015 , Temporal Evolution of Multiple Evaporating Ribbon Sources in a Solar Flare . 807 , L22 . https://doi.org/10.1088/2041-8205/807/2/L22 . 2015ApJ...807L..22G . barticle
2015 doi
-
[29]
, Cauzzi , G
barticle Graham , D.R. , Cauzzi , G. , Zangrilli , L. , Kowalski , A. , Sim \ o es , P. , Allred , J. : 2020 , Spectral Signatures of Chromospheric Condensation in a Major Solar Flare . 895 , 6 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab88ad . 2020ApJ...895....6G . barticle
2020 doi
-
[30]
, Ni , Y.W
barticle Guo , J.H. , Ni , Y.W. , Zhong , Z. , Guo , Y. , Xia , C. , Li , H.T. , Poedts , S. , Schmieder , B. , Chen , P.F. : 2023 , Thermodynamic and Magnetic Topology Evolution of the X1.0 Flare on 2021 October 28 Simulated by a Data-driven Radiative Magnetohydrodynamic Mode...
2023 doi
-
[31]
, Acton , L.W
barticle Handy , B.N. , Acton , L.W. , Kankelborg , C.C. , Wolfson , C.J. , Akin , D.J. , Bruner , M.E. , Caravalho , R. , Catura , R.C. , Chevalier , R. , Duncan , D.W. , Edwards , C.G. , Feinstein , C.N. , Freeland , S.L. , Friedlaender , F.M. , Hoffmann , C.H. , Hurlburt , ...
1999
-
[32]
, Kontar , E.P
barticle Hannah , I.G. , Kontar , E.P. : 2012 , Differential emission measures from the regularized inversion of Hinode and SDO data . 539 , A146 . https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201117576 . 2012A&A...539A.146H . barticle
2012 doi
-
[33]
, Veronig , A.M
barticle Hinterreiter , J. , Veronig , A.M. , Thalmann , J.K. , Tschernitz , J. , P \"o tzi , W. : 2018 , Statistical Properties of Ribbon Evolution and Reconnection Electric Fields in Eruptive and Confined Flares . 293 , 38 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s11207-018-1253-1 . 2018So...
2018 doi
-
[34]
, Savin , D.W
botherref Hofmeister , S. , Savin , D.W. , Hahn , M. : 2024, Revised Point-Spread Functions for the Atmospheric Imaging Assembly onboard the Solar Dynamics Observatory . arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2410.08967. https://doi.org/10.48550/arXiv.2410.08967 . 2024arXiv241008967H . botherref
-
[35]
, Yokoyama , T
barticle Hori , K. , Yokoyama , T. , Kosugi , T. , Shibata , K. : 1997 , Pseudo-Two-dimensional Hydrodynamic Modeling of Solar Flare Loops . 489 , 426 . https://doi.org/10.1086/304754 . 1997ApJ...489..426H . barticle
1997 doi
-
[36]
, Bhattacharjee , A
barticle Huang , Y.-M. , Bhattacharjee , A. : 2016 , Turbulent Magnetohydrodynamic Reconnection Mediated by the Plasmoid Instability . 818 , 20 . https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-637X/818/1/20 . 2016ApJ...818...20H . barticle
2016 doi
-
[37]
, Xu , Y
barticle Jing , J. , Xu , Y. , Cao , W. , Liu , C. , Gary , D. , Wang , H. : 2016 , Unprecedented Fine Structure of a Solar Flare Revealed by the 1.6 \, m New Solar Telescope . Scientific Reports 6 , 24319 . https://doi.org/10.1038/srep24319 . 2016NatSR...624319J . barticle
2016 doi
-
[38]
, Lynch , B.J
barticle Kazachenko , M.D. , Lynch , B.J. , Welsch , B.T. , Sun , X. : 2017 , A Database of Flare Ribbon Properties from the Solar Dynamics Observatory. I. Reconnection Flux . 845 , 49 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aa7ed6 . 2017ApJ...845...49K . barticle
2017 doi
-
[39]
, Allred , J.C
botherref Kerr , G.S. , Allred , J.C. , Polito , V. : 2020, Solar Flare Arcade Modelling: Bridging the gap from 1D to 3D Simulations of Optically Thin Radiation . arXiv e-prints, arXiv:2007.13856. 2020arXiv200713856K . botherref
2020 arXiv
-
[40]
, Fletcher , L
barticle Kerr , G.S. , Fletcher , L. , Russell , A.e.J.B. , Allred , J.C. : 2016 , Simulations of the Mg II k and Ca II 8542 lines from an Alfv \'E n Wave-heated Flare Chromosphere . 827 , 101 . https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-637X/827/2/101 . 2016ApJ...827..101K . barticle
2016 doi
-
[41]
: 2024 , Stellar flares
barticle Kowalski , A.F. : 2024 , Stellar flares . Living Reviews in Solar Physics 21 , 1 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s41116-024-00039-4 . 2024LRSP...21....1K . barticle
2024 doi
-
[42]
, Hawley , S.L
barticle Kowalski , A.F. , Hawley , S.L. , Wisniewski , J.P. , Osten , R.A. , Hilton , E.J. , Holtzman , J.A. , Schmidt , S.J. , Davenport , J.R.A. : 2013 , Time-resolved Properties and Global Trends in dMe Flares from Simultaneous Photometry and Spectra . 207 , 15 . https://d...
2013 doi
-
[43]
, Allred , J.C
barticle Kowalski , A.F. , Allred , J.C. , Daw , A. , Cauzzi , G. , Carlsson , M. : 2017 , The Atmospheric Response to High Nonthermal Electron Beam Fluxes in Solar Flares. I. Modeling the Brightest NUV Footpoints in the X1 Solar Flare of 2014 March 29 . 836 , 12 . https://doi...
2017 doi
-
[44]
, Title , A.M
barticle Lemen , J.R. , Title , A.M. , Akin , D.J. , Boerner , P.F. , Chou , C. , Drake , J.F. , Duncan , D.W. , Edwards , C.G. , Friedlaender , F.M. , Heyman , G.F. : 2012 , The Atmospheric Imaging Assembly (AIA) on the Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) . 275 , 17 . https://do...
2012 doi
-
[45]
, Hong , Z
barticle Li , D. , Hong , Z. , Hou , Z. , Su , Y. : 2024 , Localizing Quasiperiodic Pulsations in Hard X-Ray, Microwave, and Ly Emissions of an X6.4 Flare . 970 , 77 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ad566c . 2024ApJ...970...77L . barticle
2024 doi
-
[46]
, Qiu , J
barticle Liu , W.-J. , Qiu , J. , Longcope , D.W. , Caspi , A. : 2013 , Determining Heating Rates in Reconnection Formed Flare Loops of the M8.0 Flare on 2005 May 13 . 770 , 111 . https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/770/2/111 . 2013ApJ...770..111L . barticle
2013 doi
-
[47]
: 2014 , A Simple Model of Chromospheric Evaporation and Condensation Driven Conductively in a Solar Flare
barticle Longcope , D.W. : 2014 , A Simple Model of Chromospheric Evaporation and Condensation Driven Conductively in a Solar Flare . 795 , 10 . https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/795/1/10 . 2014ApJ...795...10L . barticle
2014 doi
-
[48]
, Emslie , A.G
barticle Massa , P. , Emslie , A.G. , Hannah , I.G. , Kontar , E.P. : 2023 , Robust construction of differential emission measure profiles using a regularized maximum likelihood method . 672 , A120 . https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/202345883 . 2023A&A...672A.120M . barticle
2023 doi
-
[49]
, Lichti , G
barticle Meegan , C. , Lichti , G. , Bhat , P.N. , Bissaldi , E. , Briggs , M.S. , Connaughton , V. , Diehl , R. , Fishman , G. , Greiner , J. , Hoover , A.S. , van der Horst , A.J. , von Kienlin , A. , Kippen , R.M. , Kouveliotou , C. , McBreen , S. , Paciesas , W.S. , Preece...
2009 doi
-
[50]
: 2015 , Extreme Ultra-Violet Spectroscopy of the Lower Solar Atmosphere During Solar Flares (Invited Review)
barticle Milligan , R.O. : 2015 , Extreme Ultra-Violet Spectroscopy of the Lower Solar Atmosphere During Solar Flares (Invited Review) . 290 , 3399 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s11207-015-0748-2 . 2015SoPh..290.3399M . barticle
2015 doi
-
[51]
, Qiu , J
barticle Naus , S.J. , Qiu , J. , DeVore , C.R. , Antiochos , S.K. , Dahlin , J.T. , Drake , J.F. , Swisdak , M. : 2022 , Correlated Spatio-temporal Evolution of Extreme-Ultraviolet Ribbons and Hard X-Rays in a Solar Flare . 926 , 218 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ac4028...
2022 doi
-
[52]
, Del Zanna , G
barticle O'Dwyer , B. , Del Zanna , G. , Mason , H.E. , Weber , M.A. , Tripathi , D. : 2010 , SDO/AIA response to coronal hole, quiet Sun, active region, and flare plasma . 521 , A21 . https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/201014872 . 2010A\ barticle
2010 doi
-
[53]
, Thompson , B.J
barticle Ofman , L. , Thompson , B.J. : 2011 , SDO/AIA Observation of Kelvin-Helmholtz Instability in the Solar Corona . 734 , L11 . https://doi.org/10.1088/2041-8205/734/1/L11 . 2011ApJ...734L..11O . barticle
2011 doi
-
[54]
, Longcope , D
barticle Parker , J. , Longcope , D. : 2017 , Modeling a Propagating Sawtooth Flare Ribbon Structure as a Tearing Mode in the Presence of Velocity Shear . 847 , 30 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aa8908 . 2017ApJ...847...30P . barticle
2017 doi
-
[55]
, Thompson , B.J
barticle Pesnell , W.D. , Thompson , B.J. , Chamberlin , P.C. : 2012 , The Solar Dynamics Observatory (SDO) . 275 , 3 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s11207-011-9841-3 . 2012SoPh..275....3P . barticle
2012 doi
-
[56]
, Kankelborg , C
barticle Plowman , J. , Kankelborg , C. , Martens , P. : 2013 , Fast Differential Emission Measure Inversion of Solar Coronal Data . 771 , 2 . https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/771/1/2 . 2013ApJ...771....2P . barticle
2013 doi
-
[57]
, DeForest , C.E
barticle Poduval , B. , DeForest , C.E. , Schmelz , J.T. , Pathak , S. : 2013 , Point-spread Functions for the Extreme-ultraviolet Channels of SDO/AIA Telescopes . 765 , 144 . https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/765/2/144 . 2013ApJ...765..144P . barticle
2013 doi
-
[58]
: 2021 , The Neupert Effect of Flare Ultraviolet and Soft X-Ray Emissions
barticle Qiu , J. : 2021 , The Neupert Effect of Flare Ultraviolet and Soft X-Ray Emissions . 909 , 99 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/abe0b3 . 2021ApJ...909...99Q . barticle
2021 doi
-
[59]
: 2024 , Tracing field lines that are reconnecting, or expanding, or both
barticle Qiu , J. : 2024 , Tracing field lines that are reconnecting, or expanding, or both . Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences 11 , 1401846 . https://doi.org/10.3389/fspas.2024.1401846 . 2024FrASS..1101846Q . barticle
2024
-
[60]
, Cheng , J
barticle Qiu , J. , Cheng , J. : 2022 , Properties and Energetics of Magnetic Reconnection: I. Evolution of Flare Ribbons . 297 , 80 . https://doi.org/10.1007/s11207-022-02003-7 . 2022SoPh..297...80Q . barticle
2022 doi
-
[61]
, Longcope , D.W
barticle Qiu , J. , Longcope , D.W. : 2016 , Long Duration Flare Emission: Impulsive Heating or Gradual Heating? 820 , 14 . https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-637X/820/1/14 . 2016ApJ...820...14Q . barticle
2016 doi
-
[62]
, Liu , W.-J
barticle Qiu , J. , Liu , W.-J. , Longcope , D.W. : 2012 , Heating of Flare Loops with Observationally Constrained Heating Functions . 752 , 124 . https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/752/2/124 . 2012ApJ...752..124Q . barticle
2012 doi
-
[63]
, Lee , J
barticle Qiu , J. , Lee , J. , Gary , D.E. , Wang , H. : 2002 , Motion of Flare Footpoint Emission and Inferred Electric Field in Reconnecting Current Sheets . 565 , 1335 . https://doi.org/10.1086/324706 . 2002ApJ...565.1335Q . barticle
2002 doi
-
[64]
, Liu , W
barticle Qiu , J. , Liu , W. , Hill , N. , Kazachenko , M. : 2010 , Reconnection and Energetics in Two-ribbon Flares: A Revisit of the Bastille-day Flare . 725 , 319 . https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/725/1/319 . 2010ApJ...725..319Q . barticle
2010 doi
-
[65]
, Sturrock , Z
barticle Qiu , J. , Sturrock , Z. , Longcope , D.W. , Klimchuk , J.A. , Liu , W.-J. : 2013 , Ultraviolet and Extreme-ultraviolet Emissions at the Flare Footpoints Observed by Atmosphere Imaging Assembly . 774 , 14 . https://doi.org/10.1088/0004-637X/774/1/14 . 2013ApJ...774......
2013 doi
-
[66]
, Bello Gonz \'a lez , N
barticle Rast , M.P. , Bello Gonz \'a lez , N. , Bellot Rubio , L. , Cao , W. , Cauzzi , G. , Deluca , E. , de Pontieu , B. , Fletcher , L. , Gibson , S.E. , Judge , P.G. , Katsukawa , Y. , Kazachenko , M.D. , Khomenko , E. , Landi , E. , Mart \' nez Pillet , V. , Petrie , G.J...
2021
-
[67]
: 2014 , Coronal Loops: Observations and Modeling of Confined Plasma
barticle Reale , F. : 2014 , Coronal Loops: Observations and Modeling of Confined Plasma . Living Reviews in Solar Physics 11 , 4 . https://doi.org/10.12942/lrsp-2014-4 . 2014LRSP...11....4R . barticle
2014 doi
-
[68]
, Knizhnik , K.J
barticle Reep , J.W. , Knizhnik , K.J. : 2019 , What Determines the X-Ray Intensity and Duration of a Solar Flare? 874 , 157 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab0ae7 . 2019ApJ...874..157R . barticle
2019 doi
-
[69]
, Russell , A.J.B
barticle Reep , J.W. , Russell , A.J.B. : 2016 , Alfv \'e nic Wave Heating of the Upper Chromosphere in Flares . 818 , L20 . https://doi.org/10.3847/2041-8205/818/1/L20 . 2016ApJ...818L..20R . barticle
2016 doi
-
[70]
: 2017 , Extension of the MURaM Radiative MHD Code for Coronal Simulations
barticle Rempel , M. : 2017 , Extension of the MURaM Radiative MHD Code for Coronal Simulations . 834 , 10 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/834/1/10 . 2017ApJ...834...10R . barticle
2017 doi
-
[71]
, Chintzoglou , G
barticle Rempel , M. , Chintzoglou , G. , Cheung , M.C.M. , Fan , Y. , Kleint , L. : 2023 , Comprehensive Radiative MHD Simulations of Eruptive Flares above Collisional Polarity Inversion Lines . 955 , 105 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aced4d . 2023ApJ...955..105R . barticle
2023 doi
-
[72]
o lker , M. , Kuhn , J.R. , Rosner , R.R. , McMullin , J.P. , Casini , R. , Lin , H. , W \
barticle Rimmele , T.R. , Warner , M. , Keil , S.L. , Goode , P.R. , Kn \"o lker , M. , Kuhn , J.R. , Rosner , R.R. , McMullin , J.P. , Casini , R. , Lin , H. , W \"o ger , F. , von der L \"u he , O. , Tritschler , A. , Davey , A. , de Wijn , A. , Elmore , D.F. , Fehlmann , A....
2020
-
[73]
, Gaeng , T
barticle Saba , J.L.R. , Gaeng , T. , Tarbell , T.D. : 2006 , Analysis of Solar Flare Ribbon Evolution: A Semiautomated Approach . 641 , 1197 . https://doi.org/10.1086/500631 . 2006ApJ...641.1197S . barticle
2006 doi
-
[74]
, Bjelksjo , K
bchapter Scharmer , G.B. , Bjelksjo , K. , Korhonen , T.K. , Lindberg , B. , Petterson , B. : 2003 , The 1-meter Swedish solar telescope . In: Keil , S.L. , Avakyan , S.V. (eds.) Innovative Telescopes and Instrumentation for Solar Astrophysics , Society of Photo-Optical Instru...
2003 doi
-
[75]
, Schou , J
barticle Scherrer , P.H. , Schou , J. , Bush , R.I. , Kosovichev , A.G. , Bogart , R.S. , Hoeksema , J.T. , Liu , Y. , Duvall , T.L. , Zhao , J. , Title , A.M. , Schrijver , C.J. , Tarbell , T.D. , Tomczyk , S. : 2012 , The Helioseismic and Magnetic Imager (HMI) Investigation ...
2012 doi
-
[76]
, Tanuma , S
barticle Shibata , K. , Tanuma , S. : 2001 , Plasmoid-induced-reconnection and fractal reconnection . Earth, Planets, and Space 53 , 473 . https://doi.org/10.1186/BF03353258 . 2001EP\ barticle
2001 doi
-
[77]
, Reid , H.A.S
barticle Sim \ o es , P.J.A. , Reid , H.A.S. , Milligan , R.O. , Fletcher , L. : 2019 , The Spectral Content of SDO/AIA 1600 and 1700 A Filters from Flare and Plage Observations . 870 , 114 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aaf28d . 2019ApJ...870..114S . barticle
2019 doi
-
[78]
, Qiu , J
barticle Takahashi , T. , Qiu , J. , Shibata , K. : 2017 , Quasi-periodic Oscillations in Flares and Coronal Mass Ejections Associated with Magnetic Reconnection . 848 , 102 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/aa8f97 . 2017ApJ...848..102T . barticle
2017 doi
-
[79]
, Shibata , K
barticle Takasao , S. , Shibata , K. : 2016 , Above-the-loop-top Oscillation and Quasi-periodic Coronal Wave Generation in Solar Flares . 823 , 150 . https://doi.org/10.3847/0004-637X/823/2/150 . 2016ApJ...823..150T . barticle
2016 doi
-
[80]
, Kazachenko , M.D
barticle Tamburri , C.A. , Kazachenko , M.D. , Kowalski , A.F. : 2024 , The Relationships among Solar Flare Impulsiveness, Energy Release, and Ribbon Development . 966 , 94 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ad3047 . 2024ApJ...966...94T . barticle
2024 doi
-
[81]
, Veronig , A.M
barticle Temmer , M. , Veronig , A.M. , Vr s nak , B. , Miklenic , C. : 2007 , Energy Release Rates along H Flare Ribbons and the Location of Hard X-Ray Sources . 654 , 665 . https://doi.org/10.1086/509634 . 2007ApJ...654..665T . barticle
2007 doi
-
[82]
, Joshi , R
barticle Thoen Faber , J. , Joshi , R. , Rouppe van der Voort , L. , Wedemeyer , S. , Fletcher , L. , Aulanier , G. , N \'o brega-Siverio , D. : 2025 , High-resolution observational analysis of flare ribbon fine structures . 693 , A8 . https://doi.org/10.1051/0004-6361/2024523...
2025 doi
-
[83]
, Avrett , E.H
barticle Vernazza , J.E. , Avrett , E.H. , Loeser , R. : 1981 , Structure of the solar chromosphere. III. Models of the EUV brightness components of the quiet sun. 45 , 635 . https://doi.org/10.1086/190731 . 1981ApJS...45..635V . barticle
1981 doi
-
[84]
, Vourlidas , A
barticle Vievering , J.T. , Vourlidas , A. , Zhu , C. , Qiu , J. , Glesener , L. : 2023 , Evolution of Solar Eruptive Events: Investigating the Relationships among Magnetic Reconnection, Flare Energy Release, and Coronal Mass Ejections . 946 , 81 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538...
2023 doi
-
[85]
: 2006 , Multithread Hydrodynamic Modeling of a Solar Flare
barticle Warren , H.P. : 2006 , Multithread Hydrodynamic Modeling of a Solar Flare . 637 , 522 . https://doi.org/10.1086/497904 . 2006ApJ...637..522W . barticle
2006 doi
-
[86]
, Warshall , A.D
barticle Warren , H.P. , Warshall , A.D. : 2001 , Ultraviolet Flare Ribbon Brightenings and the Onset of Hard X-Ray Emission . 560 , L87 . https://doi.org/10.1086/324060 . 2001ApJ...560L..87W . barticle
2001 doi
-
[87]
, Deluca , E.E
bchapter Weber , M.A. , Deluca , E.E. , Golub , L. , Sette , A.L. : 2004 , Temperature diagnostics with multichannel imaging telescopes . In: Stepanov , A.V. , Benevolenskaya , E.E. , Kosovichev , A.G. (eds.) Multi-Wavelength Investigations of Solar Activity , IAU Symposium 22...
2004 doi
-
[88]
, Hock , R
barticle Woods , T.N. , Hock , R. , Eparvier , F. , Jones , A.R. , Chamberlin , P.C. , Klimchuk , J.A. , Didkovsky , L. , Judge , D. , Mariska , J. , Warren , H. , Schrijver , C.J. , Webb , D.F. , Bailey , S. , Tobiska , W.K. : 2011 , New Solar Extreme-ultraviolet Irradiance O...
2011 doi
-
[89]
, Pontin , D.I
barticle Wyper , P.F. , Pontin , D.I. : 2021 , Is Flare Ribbon Fine Structure Related to Tearing in the Flare Current Sheet? 920 , 102 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ac1943 . 2021ApJ...920..102W . barticle
2021 doi
-
[90]
, Qiu , J
barticle Zhu , C. , Qiu , J. , Liewer , P. , Vourlidas , A. , Spiegel , M. , Hu , Q. : 2020 , How Does Magnetic Reconnection Drive the Early-stage Evolution of Coronal Mass Ejections? 893 , 141 . https://doi.org/10.3847/1538-4357/ab838a . 2020ApJ...893..141Z . barticle
2020 doi
-
[91]
, DeVore , C.R
botherref Zhu , C. , DeVore , C.R. , Dahlin , J.T. , Qiu , J. , Kazachenko , M.D. , Uritsky , V.M. : 2025, Genesis of a Confined X6.4 Flare in a Quadrupolar Magnetic Configuration . in preparation. botherref
2025
-
[92]
, McLaughlin , J.A
barticle Zimovets , I.V. , McLaughlin , J.A. , Srivastava , A.K. , Kolotkov , D.Y. , Kuznetsov , A.A. , Kupriyanova , E.G. , Cho , I.-H. , Inglis , A.R. , Reale , F. , Pascoe , D.J. , Tian , H. , Yuan , D. , Li , D. , Zhang , Q.M. : 2021 , Quasi-Periodic Pulsations in Solar an...
2021 doi
Reviewed August 15, 2026 · model on record in the stance chip above.
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.