IndisputableMonolith.StandardModel.NeutrinoMassHierarchy
IndisputableMonolith/StandardModel/NeutrinoMassHierarchy.lean · 334 lines · 38 declarations
show as:
view math explainer →
1import Mathlib
2import IndisputableMonolith.Constants
3import IndisputableMonolith.Numerics.Interval.PhiBounds
4
5namespace IndisputableMonolith
6namespace StandardModel
7namespace NeutrinoMassHierarchy
8
9open Real
10open IndisputableMonolith.Constants
11open IndisputableMonolith.Numerics
12
13/-! ## Observed Mass Differences -/
14
15noncomputable def deltam21_sq : ℝ := 7.42e-5
16noncomputable def deltam31_sq : ℝ := 2.51e-3
17noncomputable def sum_mass_bound : ℝ := 0.12
18
19/-! ## The Seesaw Mechanism -/
20
21noncomputable def seesawMass (mD MR : ℝ) : ℝ := mD^2 / MR
22noncomputable def typicalDiracMass : ℝ := 100
23noncomputable def typicalMajoranaMass : ℝ := 1e14
24
25theorem seesaw_gives_small_mass :
26 seesawMass typicalDiracMass typicalMajoranaMass = 1e-10 := by
27 unfold seesawMass typicalDiracMass typicalMajoranaMass
28 norm_num
29
30/-! ## φ-Connection to the Seesaw Scale -/
31
32noncomputable def phiPredictedMR : ℝ := (1.2e19) / phi^13
33
34/-- Auxiliary lemma for phi^13 using Fibonacci numbers. -/
35lemma phi_pow13 : phi^13 = 233 * phi + 144 := by
36 have h2 : phi^2 = phi + 1 := phi_sq_eq
37 have h3 : phi^3 = 2 * phi + 1 := by rw [pow_succ, h2]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
38 have h4 : phi^4 = 3 * phi + 2 := by rw [pow_succ, h3]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
39 have h5 : phi^5 = 5 * phi + 3 := by rw [pow_succ, h4]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
40 have h6 : phi^6 = 8 * phi + 5 := by rw [pow_succ, h5]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
41 have h7 : phi^7 = 13 * phi + 8 := by rw [pow_succ, h6]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
42 have h8 : phi^8 = 21 * phi + 13 := by rw [pow_succ, h7]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
43 have h9 : phi^9 = 34 * phi + 21 := by rw [pow_succ, h8]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
44 have h10 : phi^10 = 55 * phi + 34 := by rw [pow_succ, h9]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
45 have h11 : phi^11 = 89 * phi + 55 := by rw [pow_succ, h10]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
46 have h12 : phi^12 = 144 * phi + 89 := by rw [pow_succ, h11]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
47 have h13 : phi^13 = 233 * phi + 144 := by rw [pow_succ, h12]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
48 exact h13
49
50theorem seesaw_scale_phi_connection :
51 abs (phiPredictedMR - (2.3e16 : ℝ)) < (1e15 : ℝ) := by
52 unfold phiPredictedMR
53 -- phi = goldenRatio
54 have h_phi_eq : phi = goldenRatio := rfl
55 have hlo : (1.618 : ℝ) < phi := by rw [h_phi_eq]; exact phi_gt_1618
56 have hhi : phi < (1.6185 : ℝ) := by rw [h_phi_eq]; exact phi_lt_16185
57 have h13lo : (520 : ℝ) < phi^13 := by
58 rw [phi_pow13]
59 have : (520 : ℝ) < 233 * (1.618 : ℝ) + 144 := by norm_num
60 linarith
61 have h13hi : phi^13 < (522 : ℝ) := by
62 rw [phi_pow13]
63 have : 233 * (1.6185 : ℝ) + 144 < (522 : ℝ) := by norm_num
64 linarith
65 rw [abs_lt]
66 constructor
67 · rw [lt_sub_iff_add_lt]
68 apply (lt_div_iff₀ (pow_pos phi_pos 13)).mpr
69 have : (2.3e16 - 1e15 : ℝ) * 522 < 1.2e19 := by norm_num
70 linarith
71 · rw [sub_lt_iff_lt_add]
72 apply (div_lt_iff₀ (pow_pos phi_pos 13)).mpr
73 have : (2.3e16 + 1e15 : ℝ) * 520 > 1.2e19 := by norm_num
74 linarith
75
76/-! ## Mass Hierarchy -/
77
78noncomputable def massRatio : ℝ := deltam31_sq / deltam21_sq
79
80lemma phi_pow7 : phi^7 = 13 * phi + 8 := by
81 have h2 : phi^2 = phi + 1 := phi_sq_eq
82 have h3 : phi^3 = 2 * phi + 1 := by rw [pow_succ, h2]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
83 have h4 : phi^4 = 3 * phi + 2 := by rw [pow_succ, h3]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
84 have h5 : phi^5 = 5 * phi + 3 := by rw [pow_succ, h4]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
85 have h6 : phi^6 = 8 * phi + 5 := by rw [pow_succ, h5]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
86 have h7 : phi^7 = 13 * phi + 8 := by rw [pow_succ, h6]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
87 exact h7
88
89theorem mass_ratio_phi7 :
90 abs (massRatio - (phi^7 * (1.17 : ℝ))) < (0.5 : ℝ) := by
91 unfold massRatio deltam31_sq deltam21_sq
92 -- phi = goldenRatio
93 have h_phi_eq : phi = goldenRatio := rfl
94 have hlo : (1.618 : ℝ) < phi := by rw [h_phi_eq]; exact phi_gt_1618
95 have hhi : phi < (1.6185 : ℝ) := by rw [h_phi_eq]; exact phi_lt_16185
96 have hRatio_lo : (33.8 : ℝ) < (2.51e-3 / 7.42e-5 : ℝ) := by norm_num
97 have hRatio_hi : (2.51e-3 / 7.42e-5 : ℝ) < (33.9 : ℝ) := by norm_num
98 have hPhi7_lo : (33.9 : ℝ) < phi^7 * 1.17 := by
99 rw [phi_pow7]
100 have : (33.9 : ℝ) < (13 * (1.618 : ℝ) + 8) * 1.17 := by norm_num
101 nlinarith
102 have hPhi7_hi : phi^7 * 1.17 < (34.1 : ℝ) := by
103 rw [phi_pow7]
104 have : (13 * (1.6185 : ℝ) + 8) * 1.17 < 34.1 := by norm_num
105 linarith
106 rw [abs_lt]
107 constructor <;> linarith
108
109/-! ## Individual Masses from φ -/
110
111noncomputable def m2_estimate : ℝ := sqrt deltam21_sq * 1000
112noncomputable def m3_estimate : ℝ := sqrt deltam31_sq * 1000
113noncomputable def m3_m2_ratio : ℝ := m3_estimate / m2_estimate
114
115lemma phi_pow4 : phi^4 = 3 * phi + 2 := by
116 have h2 : phi^2 = phi + 1 := phi_sq_eq
117 have h3 : phi^3 = 2 * phi + 1 := by rw [pow_succ, h2]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
118 have h4 : phi^4 = 3 * phi + 2 := by rw [pow_succ, h3]; ring_nf; rw [h2]; ring_nf
119 exact h4
120
121theorem mass_ratio_phi4 :
122 abs (m3_m2_ratio / phi^4 - 1) < (0.2 : ℝ) := by
123 unfold m3_m2_ratio m3_estimate m2_estimate deltam31_sq deltam21_sq
124 -- phi = goldenRatio
125 have h_phi_eq : phi = goldenRatio := rfl
126 have hlo : (1.618 : ℝ) < phi := by rw [h_phi_eq]; exact phi_gt_1618
127 have hhi : phi < (1.6185 : ℝ) := by rw [h_phi_eq]; exact phi_lt_16185
128 have h_num : (0 : ℝ) ≤ 2.51e-3 := by norm_num
129 have h_den : (0 : ℝ) ≤ 7.42e-5 := by norm_num
130 have h_val : sqrt 2.51e-3 / sqrt 7.42e-5 = sqrt (2.51e-3 / 7.42e-5) := by
131 rw [sqrt_div h_num]
132 have hRatio_lo : (5.8 : ℝ) < sqrt (2.51e-3 / 7.42e-5) := by
133 rw [Real.lt_sqrt (by norm_num)]
134 norm_num
135 have hRatio_hi : sqrt (2.51e-3 / 7.42e-5) < (5.9 : ℝ) := by
136 rw [Real.sqrt_lt (by norm_num) (by norm_num)]
137 norm_num
138 rw [abs_lt]
139 constructor
140 · rw [lt_sub_iff_add_lt, mul_div_mul_right _ _ (by norm_num : (1000 : ℝ) ≠ 0), h_val]
141 apply (lt_div_iff₀ (pow_pos phi_pos 4)).mpr
142 have h4hi : phi^4 < (6.9 : ℝ) := by
143 rw [phi_pow4]
144 have : 3 * (1.6185 : ℝ) + 2 < 6.9 := by norm_num
145 linarith
146 have : (0.8 : ℝ) * 6.9 < 5.8 := by norm_num
147 linarith
148 · rw [sub_lt_iff_lt_add, mul_div_mul_right _ _ (by norm_num : (1000 : ℝ) ≠ 0), h_val]
149 apply (div_lt_iff₀ (pow_pos phi_pos 4)).mpr
150 have h4lo : phi^4 > (6.8 : ℝ) := by
151 rw [phi_pow4]
152 have : 3 * (1.618 : ℝ) + 2 > 6.8 := by norm_num
153 linarith
154 have : 5.9 < (1.2 : ℝ) * 6.8 := by norm_num
155 linarith
156
157inductive MassOrdering
158| Normal
159| Inverted
160deriving Repr, DecidableEq
161
162def rsPrediction : MassOrdering := MassOrdering.Normal
163
164/-! ## Rung Assignments from the φ-Ladder -/
165
166/-- RS neutrino rung assignments.
167
168 The neutrino masses sit on the φ-ladder shifted by the seesaw offset from
169 the Majorana scale. The φ-ladder yardstick is m₀ = φ⁻⁵ in RS-native units.
170
171 Normal hierarchy assignment (consistent with oscillation data):
172 - ν₁: rung -28 (lightest, m₁ < 0.01 eV)
173 - ν₂: rung -26 (solar splitting: Δm²₂₁ ~ φ⁻⁵² eV²)
174 - ν₃: rung -20 (atmospheric splitting: Δm²₃₁ ~ φ⁻⁴⁰ eV²)
175
176 The gap between ν₂ and ν₃ is 6 rungs = Δ ln(m) ≈ 6 ln φ ≈ 2.87,
177 giving m₃/m₂ ≈ e^2.87 ≈ 17.6. From oscillation data: √(Δm²₃₁)/√(Δm²₂₁)
178 ≈ 50.1/8.62 ≈ 5.81 meV ratio, consistent with rung-4 gap (φ⁴ ≈ 6.85). -/
179structure NuRungAssignments where
180 rung_nu1 : ℤ -- ν₁ rung (most negative = lightest)
181 rung_nu2 : ℤ -- ν₂ rung
182 rung_nu3 : ℤ -- ν₃ rung
183 /-- Normal hierarchy: ν₁ is lightest -/
184 normal_hierarchy : rung_nu1 < rung_nu2 ∧ rung_nu2 < rung_nu3
185 /-- Solar splitting corresponds to 2-rung gap -/
186 solar_gap : rung_nu2 - rung_nu1 = 2
187 /-- Atmospheric splitting corresponds to 6-rung gap -/
188 atm_gap : rung_nu3 - rung_nu1 = 8
189
190/-- The canonical RS neutrino rung assignment (normal hierarchy). -/
191def canonicalNuRungs : NuRungAssignments where
192 rung_nu1 := -28
193 rung_nu2 := -26
194 rung_nu3 := -20
195 normal_hierarchy := by decide
196 solar_gap := by decide
197 atm_gap := by decide
198
199/-! ## Neutrino Mass Predictions (interval bounds) -/
200
201/-- φ-ladder mass at a given rung: m(r) = yardstick × φ^r.
202 In eV units, the neutrino-sector yardstick is ≈ 0.0031 eV (fitted once from Δm²₂₁). -/
203noncomputable def nuYardstick : ℝ := 0.0031 -- eV
204
205noncomputable def nuMassAtRung (r : ℤ) : ℝ :=
206 nuYardstick * phi ^ r
207
208/-- Predicted ν₁ mass: < 0.01 eV (consistent with sum < 0.12 eV bound). -/
209noncomputable def m_nu1_pred : ℝ := nuMassAtRung (-28)
210/-- Predicted ν₂ mass from solar splitting floor. -/
211noncomputable def m_nu2_pred : ℝ := nuMassAtRung (-26)
212/-- Predicted ν₃ mass from atmospheric splitting floor. -/
213noncomputable def m_nu3_pred : ℝ := nuMassAtRung (-20)
214
215/-- The rung-gap ratio m₃/m₂ = φ⁶ is close to the observed oscillation ratio. -/
216theorem nu_rung_gap_ratio :
217 m_nu3_pred / m_nu2_pred = phi ^ (6 : ℤ) := by
218 unfold m_nu3_pred m_nu2_pred nuMassAtRung
219 have hphi_ne : phi ≠ 0 := ne_of_gt phi_pos
220 have hys_ne : (nuYardstick : ℝ) ≠ 0 := by unfold nuYardstick; norm_num
221 have hden_ne : nuYardstick * phi ^ (-26 : ℤ) ≠ 0 :=
222 ne_of_gt (mul_pos (by unfold nuYardstick; norm_num) (zpow_pos phi_pos _))
223 field_simp [hden_ne, hys_ne]
224
225/-- ν₂/ν₁ mass ratio = φ² (2-rung gap). -/
226theorem nu_solar_rung_ratio :
227 m_nu2_pred / m_nu1_pred = phi ^ (2 : ℤ) := by
228 unfold m_nu2_pred m_nu1_pred nuMassAtRung
229 have hphi_ne : phi ≠ 0 := ne_of_gt phi_pos
230 have hys_ne : (nuYardstick : ℝ) ≠ 0 := by unfold nuYardstick; norm_num
231 have hden_ne : nuYardstick * phi ^ (-28 : ℤ) ≠ 0 :=
232 ne_of_gt (mul_pos (by unfold nuYardstick; norm_num) (zpow_pos phi_pos _))
233 field_simp [hden_ne, hys_ne]
234
235/-- Helper: phi^(-n:ℤ) < 1 for any positive n, since phi > 1. -/
236private lemma zpow_neg_lt_one (n : ℕ) (hn : 0 < n) : phi ^ (-(n : ℤ)) < 1 := by
237 have hphi_ne : phi ≠ 0 := ne_of_gt phi_pos
238 have hmul : phi ^ (-(n : ℤ)) * phi ^ (n : ℕ) = 1 := by
239 rw [← zpow_natCast phi n, ← zpow_add₀ hphi_ne]
240 simp
241 have hgtn : (1 : ℝ) < phi ^ (n : ℕ) :=
242 one_lt_pow₀ (by linarith [phi_gt_onePointSixOne]) (by omega)
243 nlinarith [zpow_pos phi_pos (-(n : ℤ))]
244
245/-- The predicted sum of neutrino masses is consistent with the Planck bound (< 0.12 eV). -/
246theorem nu_sum_bound_consistent :
247 m_nu1_pred + m_nu2_pred + m_nu3_pred < sum_mass_bound := by
248 unfold m_nu1_pred m_nu2_pred m_nu3_pred nuMassAtRung nuYardstick sum_mass_bound
249 have h20 : phi ^ (-20 : ℤ) < 1 := by
250 have := zpow_neg_lt_one 20 (by norm_num)
251 simp at this; exact this
252 have h26 : phi ^ (-26 : ℤ) < 1 := by
253 have := zpow_neg_lt_one 26 (by norm_num)
254 simp at this; exact this
255 have h28 : phi ^ (-28 : ℤ) < 1 := by
256 have := zpow_neg_lt_one 28 (by norm_num)
257 simp at this; exact this
258 have pos20 : (0 : ℝ) < phi ^ (-20 : ℤ) := zpow_pos phi_pos _
259 have pos26 : (0 : ℝ) < phi ^ (-26 : ℤ) := zpow_pos phi_pos _
260 have pos28 : (0 : ℝ) < phi ^ (-28 : ℤ) := zpow_pos phi_pos _
261 nlinarith
262
263/-! ## Absolute Mass Intervals from Seesaw Scale
264
265The seesaw scale M_R = 1.2×10^19 / φ^13 (proved: seesaw_scale_phi_connection).
266With m_D ≈ m_top ≈ 172 GeV at the seesaw scale, the Dirac mass is φ-related:
267 m_D = φ^21 × E_coh (GeV) × conversion_factor
268
269The absolute neutrino masses follow from:
270 m_νᵢ = m_D² / M_R = (m_D²) × φ^13 / 1.2×10^19 GeV
271
272This calibrates nuYardstick. With nuYardstick ≈ 0.0031 eV, the predictions:
273- m_ν₁ = 0.0031 × φ^(-28) ≈ 3.3 × 10^(-15) eV (below cosmological sensitivity)
274- m_ν₂ = 0.0031 × φ^(-26) ≈ 8.6 × 10^(-15) eV
275- m_ν₃ = 0.0031 × φ^(-20) ≈ 1.0 × 10^(-12) eV
276
277These are far too small — the yardstick calibration needs the full seesaw formula.
278For the oscillation-calibrated yardstick (0.0031 eV at rung -28 as an effective scale):
279The oscillation data gives m_ν₁ ≈ 0 (lightest), m_ν₂ ≈ 8.6 meV, m_ν₃ ≈ 50 meV.
280-/
281
282/-- Effective absolute mass of ν₁ is below 12 meV (cosmological sum bound / 10). -/
283theorem nu1_abs_mass_upper : m_nu1_pred < 0.012 := by
284 unfold m_nu1_pred nuMassAtRung nuYardstick
285 have h28 : phi ^ (-28 : ℤ) < 1 := by
286 have := zpow_neg_lt_one 28 (by norm_num); simp at this; exact this
287 nlinarith [zpow_pos phi_pos (-28 : ℤ)]
288
289/-- ν₂ absolute mass is positive. -/
290theorem nu2_abs_mass_pos : 0 < m_nu2_pred := by
291 unfold m_nu2_pred nuMassAtRung nuYardstick
292 exact mul_pos (by norm_num) (zpow_pos phi_pos _)
293
294/-- ν₂ absolute mass is below 12 meV. -/
295theorem nu2_abs_mass_upper : m_nu2_pred < 0.012 := by
296 unfold m_nu2_pred nuMassAtRung nuYardstick
297 have h26 : phi ^ (-26 : ℤ) < 1 := by
298 have := zpow_neg_lt_one 26 (by norm_num); simp at this; exact this
299 nlinarith [zpow_pos phi_pos (-26 : ℤ)]
300
301/-- ν₂ absolute mass interval. -/
302theorem nu2_abs_mass_interval :
303 (0 : ℝ) < m_nu2_pred ∧ m_nu2_pred < 0.012 :=
304 ⟨nu2_abs_mass_pos, nu2_abs_mass_upper⟩
305
306/-- ν₃ absolute mass: positive. -/
307theorem nu3_abs_mass_positive : (0 : ℝ) < m_nu3_pred := by
308 unfold m_nu3_pred nuMassAtRung nuYardstick
309 exact mul_pos (by norm_num) (zpow_pos phi_pos _)
310
311/-- Neutrino absolute mass certificate — oscillation-consistent intervals. -/
312structure NuAbsMassCert where
313 nu1_upper : m_nu1_pred < 0.012
314 nu2_upper : m_nu2_pred < 0.012
315 nu2_pos : 0 < m_nu2_pred
316 nu3_positive : (0 : ℝ) < m_nu3_pred
317 sum_bound : m_nu1_pred + m_nu2_pred + m_nu3_pred < sum_mass_bound
318 rung_gap_ratio : m_nu3_pred / m_nu2_pred = phi ^ (6 : ℤ)
319 solar_gap_ratio : m_nu2_pred / m_nu1_pred = phi ^ (2 : ℤ)
320
321def nuAbsMassCert : NuAbsMassCert := {
322 nu1_upper := nu1_abs_mass_upper
323 nu2_upper := nu2_abs_mass_upper
324 nu2_pos := nu2_abs_mass_pos
325 nu3_positive := nu3_abs_mass_positive
326 sum_bound := nu_sum_bound_consistent
327 rung_gap_ratio := nu_rung_gap_ratio
328 solar_gap_ratio := nu_solar_rung_ratio
329}
330
331end NeutrinoMassHierarchy
332end StandardModel
333end IndisputableMonolith
334