Physical properties and the maximum compactness bound of a class of compact stars in f(Q) gravity
Pith reviewed 2026-05-23 21:02 UTC · model grok-4.3
The pith
In linear f(Q) gravity the maximum compactness of a compact star depends only on the Vaidya-Tikekar curvature parameter K.
A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.
Core claim
By adopting f(Q) = alpha Q + beta together with the Vaidya-Tikekar ansatz and the Karmarkar condition, the authors obtain an exact interior solution whose physical quantities (density, pressures, anisotropy) are fully determined. Imposing regularity at the center produces a compactness upper bound that depends only on the curvature parameter K of the Vaidya-Tikekar metric; the bound recovers the classic Buchdahl value 4/9 precisely when K = 0. Integration of the modified hydrostatic equilibrium equation then yields mass-radius curves whose maximum mass and radius both decrease with increasing alpha, permitting the construction of stable ultra-compact configurations and the fitting of radii (
What carries the argument
Vaidya-Tikekar metric ansatz together with the Karmarkar embedding condition inside linear f(Q) gravity
If this is right
- The bound collapses exactly to the Buchdahl value 4/9 when K=0, recovering the isotropic homogeneous case.
- Larger alpha produces smaller maximum mass and radius and shifts the stable branch toward ultra-compact objects.
- The model supports stable configurations of comparatively low mass whose radii can be adjusted to fit observed pulsars.
- Mass-radius relations are obtained by direct numerical integration of the modified Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff equation using the derived density and radial pressure profiles.
Where Pith is reading between the lines
- The K-dependent bound supplies a new, parameter-free way to translate future radius measurements of pulsars into constraints on the non-metricity coupling alpha.
- If the same Vaidya-Tikekar ansatz continues to work in other modified-gravity theories, the same compactness formula may apply beyond f(Q).
- The reduction in maximum mass with alpha suggests that f(Q) corrections could help reconcile theoretical mass limits with the lightest observed neutron stars.
Load-bearing premise
The interior geometry is exactly described by the Vaidya-Tikekar metric ansatz combined with the Karmarkar condition, which permits a closed-form solution matched to the Schwarzschild exterior.
What would settle it
A single compact star whose measured compactness exceeds the analytic upper bound computed from its independently determined Vaidya-Tikekar parameter K would falsify the central claim.
Figures
read the original abstract
Motivation: Motivated by the growing interest in understanding the role of non-metricity in describing dense stellar systems, in this paper, we study compact stellar configurations within the framework of linear $f(Q)$ gravity. Methodology: By adopting a linear modification of the form $f(Q) = \alpha Q+\beta$, we analyze the internal structure and physical properties of an anisotropic relativistic star within the framework of $f(Q)$ gravity. We employ the Karmarkar's condition together with the Vaidya-Tikekar metric ansatz to obtain a closed-form interior solution of the star. The interior solution is then matched to the Schwarzschild exterior solution across the boundary of the star. By varying the model parameters, we analyze physical features of the resultant stellar configuration. Results: We note distinctive features in the density, pressure, anisotropy and total mass of the star under a such modification. By enforcing the condition that the central pressure remains finite, we obtain the maximum compactness bound which is shown to depend solely on the Vaidya-Tikekar curvature parameter $K$. We recover the Buchdahl bound for the curvature parameter $K=0$, which corresponds to the solution for an isotropic and homogeneous fluid sphere. Utilizing the energy density and radial pressure profiles, we numerically integrate the modified Tolman-Oppenheimer-Volkoff equations and obtain the mass-radius ($M-R$) relationships for different values of the model parameter $\alpha$. We note that for higher values of $\alpha$, the maximum mass and radius decrease, shifting the stable branch towards ultra-compact configurations. An interesting observation in our analysis is that a linearly modified $f(Q)$ gravity model can support comparatively low mass stars. Utilizing the observed mass of some known pulsars, we demonstrate how our model can be used to fine-tune the radius of the star.
Editorial analysis
A structured set of objections, weighed in public.
Referee Report
Summary. The manuscript studies anisotropic compact stars in linear f(Q) gravity with f(Q)=αQ+β. Adopting the Vaidya-Tikekar ansatz together with the Karmarkar condition yields a closed-form interior solution that is matched to the Schwarzschild exterior. Enforcing finite central pressure produces a maximum compactness bound that depends only on the ansatz parameter K (recovering the Buchdahl bound at K=0). Physical quantities are examined by varying α and β; the modified TOV equation is integrated numerically to generate M-R curves, which are then compared with observed pulsar masses to illustrate radius tuning.
Significance. If the exterior matching and field-equation verification hold, the work supplies an explicit K-dependent compactness bound in f(Q) gravity and demonstrates that linear non-metricity modifications can accommodate low-mass compact objects with tunable radii. The closed-form interior solution is a technical strength, though the bound remains tied to the chosen metric ansatz and the M-R analysis incorporates a fitting step.
major comments (2)
- [Matching to exterior] Matching to exterior (§ on junction conditions): The interior solution is matched to the Schwarzschild metric without an explicit demonstration that the Schwarzschild line element satisfies the vacuum f(Q) field equations for arbitrary α and β. Because the junction conditions fix the integration constants that enter the compactness bound (obtained from the finite-central-pressure requirement), this consistency check is load-bearing for the central claim.
- [Compactness bound derivation] Compactness bound derivation (section deriving the bound from central pressure): The bound is expressed solely in terms of the free parameter K inserted by the Vaidya-Tikekar ansatz. While the K=0 case recovers Buchdahl, the subsequent M-R curves are generated by varying α and then using observed pulsar masses to tune radii; this fitting step reduces the predictive content of the model relative to the claimed bound.
minor comments (1)
- The abstract states that the modified TOV equation is integrated numerically, yet no error estimates, convergence tests, or verification that the numerical solution satisfies the field equations pointwise are supplied.
Simulated Author's Rebuttal
We thank the referee for the careful reading and constructive comments. We address each major point below and will incorporate clarifications and verifications in a revised manuscript.
read point-by-point responses
-
Referee: Matching to exterior (§ on junction conditions): The interior solution is matched to the Schwarzschild metric without an explicit demonstration that the Schwarzschild line element satisfies the vacuum f(Q) field equations for arbitrary α and β. Because the junction conditions fix the integration constants that enter the compactness bound (obtained from the finite-central-pressure requirement), this consistency check is load-bearing for the central claim.
Authors: We agree that an explicit check was omitted. In linear f(Q) gravity the vacuum equations outside the star reduce to the Einstein equations with an effective cosmological term set by β; the Schwarzschild metric satisfies these equations when the non-metricity scalar vanishes and β is absorbed into the integration constants fixed by junction conditions. We will add a short appendix deriving the vacuum field equations for f(Q)=αQ+β and confirming that the Schwarzschild exterior is an exact solution, thereby validating the matching used to obtain the compactness bound. revision: yes
-
Referee: Compactness bound derivation (section deriving the bound from central pressure): The bound is expressed solely in terms of the free parameter K inserted by the Vaidya-Tikekar ansatz. While the K=0 case recovers Buchdahl, the subsequent M-R curves are generated by varying α and then using observed pulsar masses to tune radii; this fitting step reduces the predictive content of the model relative to the claimed bound.
Authors: The compactness bound is obtained solely from the finiteness of central pressure in the closed-form interior solution and depends only on K, recovering the Buchdahl limit at K=0. This is a theoretical upper limit within the chosen ansatz and is independent of α and β. The M-R curves are generated by integrating the modified TOV equation with the α-dependent density and pressure profiles; the subsequent comparison with observed pulsar masses is presented only to illustrate that the model can accommodate known objects by radius tuning via α. We do not claim parameter-free predictions. We will revise the text to emphasize the distinction between the K-dependent bound and the illustrative role of the M-R analysis. revision: partial
Circularity Check
Compactness bound depends on Vaidya-Tikekar parameter K by construction from the adopted ansatz; M-R relations incorporate observational tuning
specific steps
-
self definitional
[Abstract]
"By enforcing the condition that the central pressure remains finite, we obtain the maximum compactness bound which is shown to depend solely on the Vaidya-Tikekar curvature parameter K. We recover the Buchdahl bound for the curvature parameter K=0, which corresponds to the solution for an isotropic and homogeneous fluid sphere."
The interior geometry is constructed from the Vaidya-Tikekar metric ansatz (introduced as an input to obtain a closed-form solution), which defines K as a free curvature parameter. The bound depending solely on K is therefore a direct algebraic consequence of that ansatz choice rather than an independent result derived from the f(Q) field equations alone.
-
fitted input called prediction
[Abstract]
"Utilizing the observed mass of some known pulsars, we demonstrate how our model can be used to fine-tune the radius of the star."
After obtaining M-R relations by numerical integration of the modified TOV equations for varying α, the paper uses observed pulsar masses to adjust/tune the radii. This makes the reported stellar configurations a result of fitting to external data rather than a pure prediction from the theory.
full rationale
The paper adopts the Vaidya-Tikekar ansatz plus Karmarkar condition as the starting point for a closed-form interior solution in linear f(Q) gravity, then derives a compactness bound that depends only on the ansatz parameter K. This reduces the reported bound to a property of the chosen metric family. The M-R curves are generated by varying α and integrating the modified TOV equations, followed by using observed pulsar masses to tune radii, introducing a fitting element that limits independent predictive content. No self-citation chains or uniqueness theorems from the same authors are invoked as load-bearing. The exterior matching and field-equation consistency issues raised by the skeptic are correctness concerns rather than circularity. Overall moderate circularity because the central bound result is tied directly to the input ansatz.
Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger
free parameters (2)
- α
- K
axioms (2)
- domain assumption Karmarkar's condition is imposed to obtain a closed-form interior solution
- ad hoc to paper The linear form f(Q) = αQ + β is an adequate modification for stellar interiors
Forward citations
Cited by 1 Pith paper
-
Two Parameter Deformation of Embedding Class-I Compact Stars in Linear $f(Q)$ Gravity
A controlled two-parameter deformation in linear f(Q) gravity with gravitational decoupling enlarges the stellar mass window for compact objects while satisfying causality and regularity.
Reference graph
Works this paper leans on
-
[1]
Note that for K = 0 and α = −1, the associated geometry is spherical and the model corresponds to an interior fluid sphere solution obtained by Schwarzschild. For K ̸= 0 with α = −1, we regain the maximum compactness bound M R ≤ 2(K + 2) (5K + 9), (45) obtained earlier by Sharma et al [62]. The parameter K in this model was identified as the measure of an...
-
[2]
R. Ferraro and F. Fiorini, Born-Infeld gravity in Weitzenb¨ ock spacetime, Phys. Rev. D . 78 (2008) 124019
work page 2008
-
[3]
C.-Q. Geng et al, “Teleparallel” Dark Energy, Physics Letters B . 704 (2011) 384
work page 2011
-
[4]
Cai et al,f(T ) teleparallel gravity and cosmology, Rep
Y.-F. Cai et al,f(T ) teleparallel gravity and cosmology, Rep. Prog. Phys. 79 (2016) 106901
work page 2016
-
[5]
L. J¨ arv and A. Toporensky, General relativity as an attractor for scalar-torsion cosmology , Phys. Rev. D . 93 (2016) 024051
work page 2016
-
[6]
S. Nojiri and S.D. Odintsov, Introduction to Modified Gravity and Gravitational Alternative for Dark Energy , Int. J. Geom. Meth. Mod. Phys. 4 (2007) 115
work page 2007
- [7]
-
[8]
J. B. Jim´ enez, L. Heisenberg and T. Koivisto, Coincident general relativity. Phys. Rev. D 98 (2018) 044048
work page 2018
-
[9]
Kirsch, Higgs mechanism for gravity , Phys
I. Kirsch, Higgs mechanism for gravity , Phys. Rev. D 72 (2005) 024001
work page 2005
-
[10]
M. Hohmann, C. Pfeifer, U. Ualikhanova, and J. L. Said, Propagation of gravitational waves in symmetric teleparallel gravity theories , Phys. Rev. D . 99 (2019) 024009
work page 2019
- [11]
- [12]
- [13]
- [14]
- [15]
- [16]
-
[17]
F. Bajardi, D. Vernieri and S. Capozziello, Bouncing cosmology in f(Q) symmetric teleparallel gravity, Eur. Phys. J. Plus . 135 (2020) 912
work page 2020
-
[18]
F D’Ambrosio, S. D. B. Fell, L. Heisenberg, and S. Kuhn, Black holes in f(Q) gravity, Phys. Rev. D. 105 (2022) 024042
work page 2022
-
[19]
D. V. Nguyen, D. Sarnaaik, K. K. Boddy, E. O. Nadler and V. Gluscevic, Observational constraints on dark matter scattering with electrons , Phys. Rev. D . 104 (2021) 103521
work page 2021
-
[20]
F. Esposito, S. Carloni, R. Cianci and S. Vignolo, Reconstructing isotropic and anisotropic f(Q) cosmologies, Phys. Rev. D . 105 (2022) 084061
work page 2022
-
[21]
Zhao, Covariant formulation of f(Q) theory, Eur
D. Zhao, Covariant formulation of f(Q) theory, Eur. Phys. J. C . 82 (2022) 303
work page 2022
-
[22]
G. Mustafa, Z. Hassan, P.K. Sahoo, Traversable wormhole inspired by non-commutative ge- ometries in f(Q) gravity with conformal symmetry , Annals of Physics . 437 (2021) 168751
work page 2021
- [23]
-
[24]
Dimakis et al , Quantum cosmology in f(Q) theory, Class
N. Dimakis et al , Quantum cosmology in f(Q) theory, Class. Quantum Grav. . 38 (2021) 225003
work page 2021
-
[25]
H. A. Buchdahl, General Relativistic Fluid Spheres , Phys. Rev. 116 (1959) 1027
work page 1959
-
[26]
O. Sokoliuk, S. Pradhan, P. K. Sahoo, A. Baransky, Buchdahl quark stars within f(Q) theory , Eur. Phys. J. Plus . 137 (2022) 1077
work page 2022
-
[27]
S. K. Maurya, G. Mustafa, M. Govender and K. N. Singh, , JCAP. 10 (2022) 003
work page 2022
-
[28]
R-H Lin and X-H Zhai, Spherically symmetric configuration in f(Q) gravity , Phys. Rev. D . 103 (2022) 124001
work page 2022
-
[29]
R. C. Tolman, Phys. Rev, 55 (1939) 364; B. Kuchowicz, Acta. Phys. Pol. 33 (1968) 541
work page 1939
-
[30]
P. Bhar, S. Pradhan, A. Malik, P. K. Sahoo, Physical characteristics and maximum allowable mass of hybrid star in the context of f(Q) gravity , Eur. Phys. J. C . 83 (2023) 646
work page 2023
- [31]
- [32]
-
[33]
Errehymy et al, Anisotropic electrically charged stars in f(Q) symmetric teleparallel grav- ity, Eur
A. Errehymy et al, Anisotropic electrically charged stars in f(Q) symmetric teleparallel grav- ity, Eur. Phys. J. Plus . 137 (2022) 1311
work page 2022
-
[34]
M. Z. Gul et al, Viable and stable compact stars in f(Q) theory, Eur. Phys. J. C . 84 (2024) 8
work page 2024
-
[35]
T. Kobayashi and K.-I. Maeda, Relativistic stars in f(R) gravity, and absence thereof , Phys. Rev. D. 78 (2008) 064019
work page 2008
-
[36]
Upadhye, W.e Hu, The existence of relativistic stars in f(R) gravity, Phys.Rev.D
A. Upadhye, W.e Hu, The existence of relativistic stars in f(R) gravity, Phys.Rev.D. 80 (2009) 064002
work page 2009
-
[37]
J. Aftergood and A. DeBenedictis, Matter conditions for regular black holes in f(T ) gravity, Phys. Rev. D . 90 (2014) 124006
work page 2014
-
[38]
A. DeBenedictis and S. Iliji´ c,Spherically symmetric vacuum in covariant f(T ) = T + α 2 T 2 + OT γ gravity theory, Phys. Rev. D . 94 (2016) 124025
work page 2016
-
[39]
Abbas et al, Anisotropic compact stars in f(G) gravity, Astrophys Space Sci
G. Abbas et al, Anisotropic compact stars in f(G) gravity, Astrophys Space Sci. 357 (2015) 158
work page 2015
- [40]
-
[41]
M. F. Shamir and M. Ahmad, Emerging anisotropic compact stars in f(G, T) gravity, Eur. Phys. J. C . 77 (2017) 674
work page 2017
-
[42]
M. A. Sadiq, R. Manzoor, and S. Mumtaz , Collapsing axial system and f(G, T) gravity, Int. J. Mod. Phys. D . 31 06 (2022) 2250044
work page 2022
-
[43]
Bhar et al, Study on anisotropic stars in the framework of Rastall gravity , Astrophys
P. Bhar et al, Study on anisotropic stars in the framework of Rastall gravity , Astrophys. Space Sci. 365(2020) 145
work page 2020
-
[44]
K. P. Das and U. Debnath, Spherically symmetric anisotropic charged neutron stars in f(Q, T) gravity, Eur. Phys. J. C . 84 (2024) 513
work page 2024
-
[45]
J. B. Jim´ enezet al, Teleparallel Palatini theories, JCAP 08 (2018) 039
work page 2018
-
[46]
S. Pradhan et al , Geometrically deformed charged anisotropic models in f(Q, T) gravity, arXiv:2408.02051 [gr-qc]
-
[47]
M. Z. Gul et al , Physical Analysis of Spherically Stellar Structure in f(Q, T) Theory, Gen. Relativ. Gravit., 56 (2024) 45. 19
work page 2024
-
[48]
E. D. Barr et al, A pulsar in a binary with a compact object in the mass gap between neutron stars and black holes , Science. 383 (2024) 275
work page 2024
-
[49]
Herrera, Stability of the isotropic pressure condition , Phys
L. Herrera, Stability of the isotropic pressure condition , Phys. Rev. D 101 (2020) 104024
work page 2020
-
[50]
Ruderman, Pulsars: Structure and Dynamics , ANNUAL REVIEW OF ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS
M. Ruderman, Pulsars: Structure and Dynamics , ANNUAL REVIEW OF ASTRONOMY AND ASTROPHYSICS. 10 (1972) 427
work page 1972
-
[51]
R. L. Bower et al, Anisotropic Spheres in General Relativity,Astrophysical Journal 188 (1974) 657
work page 1974
-
[52]
Bondi, Anisotropic spheres in general relativity , Royal Astronomical Society
H. Bondi, Anisotropic spheres in general relativity , Royal Astronomical Society . 259 (1992) 365-368
work page 1992
-
[53]
L. Herrera, N.O. Santos, Local anisotropy in self-gravitating systems , Physics Reports. 286 (1997) 53
work page 1997
- [54]
-
[55]
S. K. Maurya, Y. K. Gupta, S. Ray and B. Dayanandan, Anisotropic models for compact stars. Eur. Phys. J. C 75 (2015) 225
work page 2015
-
[56]
S. K. Maurya, A. Banerjee, and S. Hansraj, Role of pressure anisotropy on relativistic compact stars, Phys. Rev. D . 97 (2018) 044022
work page 2018
-
[57]
K. R. Karmarkar, Gravitational metrics of spherically symmetry and class one Proc. Ind. Acad. Sci. A 27 (1948) 56
work page 1948
-
[58]
G. Abbas and H. Nazar, Stellar shear-free gravitational collapse with Karmarkar condition in f(R) gravity, International Journal of Modern Physics A . 34 33 (2019) 950220
work page 2019
-
[59]
M. Sharif and S. Naz, Gravastars with Karmarkar condition in f(R, T 2) gravity, International Journal of Modern Physics D . 31 11 (2022) 2240008
work page 2022
- [60]
-
[61]
P. C. Vaidya and R. Tikekar, Exact Relativistic Model for a Superdense Star , J. Astrophys. Astr., 3 (1982) 325
work page 1982
-
[62]
T. Gangopadhyay et al, Strange star equation of state fits the refined mass measurement of 12 pulsars and predicts their radii , Mon. Not. R. Astron. , 431 (2013) 3216. 20
work page 2013
- [63]
-
[64]
Ridolfi et al, Eight new millisecond pulsars from the first MeerKAT globular cluster census , Mon
A. Ridolfi et al, Eight new millisecond pulsars from the first MeerKAT globular cluster census , Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 504 (2021) 1407
work page 2021
-
[65]
J. L. Jonas et al, The MeerKAT Radio Telescope, MeerKAT Science: On the Pathway to the SKA. 001 (PoS 2016)
work page 2016
-
[66]
Fernando Camilo, African star joins the radio astronomy firmament , Nat. Astron. 2 (2018) 594
work page 2018
-
[67]
A. Ridolfi, P. C. C. Freire, Y. Gupta and S. M. Ransom, Upgraded Giant Metrewave Radio Telescope timing of NGC 1851A: a possible millisecond pulsar - neutron star system , Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. . 490(3) (2019) 3860
work page 2019
-
[68]
Ridolfi et al,TRAPUM discovery of 13 new pulsars in NGC 1851 using MeerKAT , Astron
A. Ridolfi et al,TRAPUM discovery of 13 new pulsars in NGC 1851 using MeerKAT , Astron. Astrophys. A27 (2022) 664. 21
work page 2022
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.