Good Enough? An Investigation on the Impact of Label Quality in Large-Scale Medical Datasets

Manually refining radiological segmentation masks is highly resource-intensive. To determine when this expert commitment is truly justified for the training of segmentation models, we investigate the relationship between label quality and model performance. Expanding beyond models trained directly for inference, we conduct the first study isolating the impact of label quality in pre-training datasets. While high-quality labels remain essential for models proceeding directly to deployment, we find no evidence that strict label quality is crucial for pre-training efficacy. These results question the necessity of exhaustive human-in-the-loop refinement for massive corpora intended for pretraining and suggest that expert effort is more effectively invested in well-curated downstream target datasets.