arxiv: 2605.14206 · v1 · pith:GXX6WLMXnew · submitted 2026-05-14 · 🧮 math.PR

The clumsy coupon collector's problem

Luke J. Attrill , Timothy M. Garoni This is my paper

Pith reviewed 2026-05-15 02:42 UTC · model grok-4.3

classification 🧮 math.PR

keywords coupon collector problemlimit theoremsbirth-death processasymptoticsMarkov chainsGumbel distributionexponential distribution

0 comments

The pith

The time for a clumsy coupon collector to acquire all m coupons obeys three different limiting laws as m grows, according to how the clumsiness probability p scales with m.

A machine-rendered reading of the paper's core claim, the machinery that carries it, and where it could break.

This paper generalizes the classic coupon collector problem by allowing each update to sometimes erase all copies of one coupon instead of adding one. It proves limit theorems for the collection time T_m in the large-m limit under three regimes for the clumsiness probability p. When p is much smaller than 1/m the normalized time converges to a Gumbel distribution like the standard case. When p is much larger than 1/m it converges to an exponential distribution. At the critical scaling p = c/m the limiting distribution is fully characterized through an associated birth-death process. A reader might care because the model captures realistic collection processes that include occasional losses or resets.

Core claim

The central claim is that limit theorems hold for the clumsy coupon collection time as m to infinity. There are three regimes based on p scaling with m: a Gumbel limit theorem when p=o(1/m), weak convergence to an exponential random variable when p=ω(1/m), and a full characterisation of the limiting distribution in terms of a birth-death process when p=c/m. The large m asymptotics of the mean and variance are also described in each regime.

What carries the argument

The clumsy coupon collector process, a Markov chain on the number of distinct coupons collected where each step adds a coupon with probability 1-p or removes all copies of a randomly chosen coupon with probability p.

If this is right

The mean and variance of the collection time admit explicit asymptotic expansions in each of the three regimes.
When p scales slower than 1/m the fluctuations around the mean are of the same order as in the classical coupon collector problem.
When p scales faster than 1/m the collection time remains order m log m but acquires exponential tails.
In the critical case p = c/m the full limiting distribution can be read off from the transient behavior of the birth-death chain on the number of distinct coupons.

Where Pith is reading between the lines

These are editorial extensions of the paper, not claims the author makes directly.

Changing the loss rule so that a clumsy step removes only a single copy rather than all copies would likely alter the location of the critical scaling between regimes.
The birth-death characterisation supplies a practical way to compute accurate numerical approximations to the distribution at moderate m by solving the Kolmogorov forward equations for the process.
The same scaling regimes may appear in other lossy collection models such as caching with eviction or population sampling with occasional total wipeouts of one type.

Load-bearing premise

The model requires that each trial independently chooses to add or remove with fixed probability p, and that a removal always erases every copy of exactly one coupon chosen uniformly at random.

What would settle it

For large finite m with p fixed at c/m, generate many independent runs of the collection process and check whether the resulting empirical distribution of T_m matches the distribution of the absorption time to state m in the associated birth-death process.

Figures

Figures reproduced from arXiv: 2605.14206 by Luke J. Attrill, Timothy M. Garoni.

**Figure 1.** Figure 1: An outcome of {T3,p = 6} for some p > 0; red, green and blue denote coupon types 1, 2 and 3 respectively. On day 4, the red urn is clumsily knocked over. a partial collection [3]. Two key generalisations of the classical problem came from [25, 26], where the coupon distribution is non-uniform, and [23], where each coupon must be collected twice. Contemporary research has spawned a myriad of variants. The p… view at source ↗

read the original abstract

We consider a generalisation of the classical coupon collector's problem, in which at each time step a collector either receives a new copy of a randomly chosen coupon, or loses all their previously collected copies of that coupon. We consider the amount of time it takes this clumsy coupon collector to obtain the full set of $m$ coupons. We establish limit theorems as $m\to\infty$ for the clumsy coupon collection time, and describe the large $m$ asymptotics of its mean and variance. We identify three regimes, depending on how the probability of a clumsy update, $p$, scales with $m$. If $p=o(1/m)$, we obtain a Gumbel limit theorem, as is the case for the classical coupon collector. If $p=\omega(1/m)$, we instead show weak convergence to an exponential random variable. In the critical case, $p=c/m$, we give a full characterisation of the limiting distribution in terms of a birth-death process.

Editorial analysis

A structured set of objections, weighed in public.

Desk editor's note, referee report, simulated authors' rebuttal, and a circularity audit. Tearing a paper down is the easy half of reading it; the pith above is the substance, this is the friction.

Desk Editor's Note private letter to a colleague

This adds a loss mechanism to the coupon collector and splits the large-m asymptotics into three clean regimes depending on how p scales with m.

read the letter

The main contribution is a variant where each step you either add a coupon or, with probability p, lose all copies of one randomly chosen coupon. They derive limit theorems for the time to collect all m coupons as m goes to infinity, and they split the behavior into three regimes based on the scaling of p with m. When p is much smaller than 1/m the losses are rare and the limit is Gumbel, recovering the classical case. When p is much larger than 1/m the process is dominated by losses and the time converges to an exponential. At the critical scaling p = c/m they obtain a birth-death process limit that describes the fluctuations. The Markov-chain setup and the regime boundaries look standard and consistent with the usual embedding techniques for occupancy problems, so the derivations should go through without major surprises. The paper states the results clearly and the birth-death characterization in the middle regime is a natural and useful description. The mean and variance asymptotics are also promised, which is helpful for applications even if the focus is on the distributional limits. The model is quite stylized and no external motivation or applications are indicated, which is typical for these pure variants but does keep the scope narrow. The abstract gives the high-level claims without the full proofs, so a referee would need to check the technical details of the convergence arguments and the exact form of the mean-variance expansions. These are not load-bearing gaps if the standard methods are applied correctly. This is aimed at people working on coupon-collector variants and Markov-chain asymptotics in probability. A reader already comfortable with the classical problem would pick up the extension quickly and could use the regime split for comparison. It is solid enough and precise enough to deserve a serious referee rather than a desk reject.

Referee Report

0 major / 3 minor

Summary. The paper generalizes the classical coupon collector's problem by introducing a clumsiness probability p: at each step the collector either gains a copy of a uniform random coupon or loses all copies of one uniform random coupon. The authors establish limit theorems for the collection time T_m as m→∞, distinguishing three regimes according to the scaling of p with m. Specifically, T_m suitably normalized converges to a Gumbel random variable when p=o(1/m), to an exponential random variable when p=ω(1/m), and to the hitting time of a birth-death process when p=c/m for fixed c>0. Asymptotics for E[T_m] and Var(T_m) are also derived in each regime.

Significance. If the proofs are complete, the work supplies a clean, regime-by-regime asymptotic theory for a Markovian coupon-collector variant that incorporates loss. The explicit identification of the critical window p=c/m and its continuum limit via a birth-death process is a genuine technical contribution that extends classical embedding and scaling arguments. The results are parameter-free within each regime and rest on standard tools of the field, making them a useful reference point for related models in stochastic processes and randomized algorithms.

minor comments (3)

[§1] §1, paragraph following the model definition: the phrase 'obtain the full set of m coupons' is slightly ambiguous because the process tracks multiplicities; a one-sentence clarification that the target is at least one copy of each coupon would remove any doubt.
[Critical regime section] The statement of the critical-regime limit (presumably Theorem 3 or 4) would benefit from an explicit display of the infinitesimal generator of the limiting birth-death process, even if the derivation is standard.
[Variance asymptotics] The variance asymptotics are stated but the leading constant in the critical case is not numerically illustrated; a short table or remark comparing the asymptotic formula with Monte-Carlo estimates for moderate m would strengthen readability.

Simulated Author's Rebuttal

0 responses · 0 unresolved

We thank the referee for their positive summary of our work on the clumsy coupon collector problem and for recommending minor revision. No specific major comments were raised in the report, so we have no changes to propose and view the manuscript as ready for publication in its current form.

Circularity Check

0 steps flagged

No significant circularity; derivation self-contained from model definition

full rationale

The paper derives its limit theorems directly from the underlying Markov chain for the clumsy coupon collector process, using standard embedding and scaling arguments for coupon-collector variants as m tends to infinity. The three regimes are delineated by the explicit scaling assumptions on p relative to m (o(1/m), ω(1/m), or c/m), and the limiting distributions (Gumbel, exponential, or birth-death process) are obtained as continuum limits of the occupancy process without any reduction to fitted parameters, self-definitions, or load-bearing self-citations. All steps follow from the independent-trials assumption and the loss mechanism stated in the model; no equation or claim collapses to an input by construction.

Axiom & Free-Parameter Ledger

0 free parameters · 2 axioms · 0 invented entities

The analysis rests on standard Markov-chain modeling of coupon states and classical limit theorems for stochastic processes; no free parameters, invented entities, or non-standard axioms are introduced.

axioms (2)

domain assumption The collection process is a continuous-time or discrete-time Markov chain on the power set of coupons with transitions that add or remove entire copies of one coupon.
Invoked to define the state space and transition rates for the clumsy collector.
standard math Standard weak-convergence and asymptotic analysis tools for Markov processes apply as m tends to infinity.
Used to obtain the Gumbel, exponential, and birth-death limits in the respective regimes.

pith-pipeline@v0.9.0 · 5460 in / 1357 out tokens · 25848 ms · 2026-05-15T02:42:57.604602+00:00 · methodology

discussion (0)

Reference graph

Works this paper leans on

31 extracted references · 31 canonical work pages · 1 internal anchor

[1]

Saksham Aggarwal and Timothy M. Garoni. The clumsy coupon collector. In David R. Wood, Alison M. Etheridge, Jan de Gier, and Nalini Joshi, editors,2023 MATRIX Annals, volume 6 ofMATRIX Book Series, pages 609–611. Springer, Switzerland, 2025

work page 2023
[2]

New results on a generalised coupon collector problem using Markov chains.J

Emmanuelle Anceaume, Yann Busnel, and Bruno Sericola. New results on a generalised coupon collector problem using Markov chains.J. Appl. Prob., 52:405–418, 2015

work page 2015
[3]

Baum and Patrick Billingsley

Leonard E. Baum and Patrick Billingsley. Asymptotic distributions for the coupon collector’s problem.The Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 36(6):1835–1839, 1965

work page 1965
[4]

The coupon-collector problem revisited.Department of Computer Science Technical Reports, 1989

Arnon Boneh and Micha Hofri. The coupon-collector problem revisited.Department of Computer Science Technical Reports, 1989

work page 1989
[5]

The converse to Curtiss' theorem for one-sided moment generating functions

Patrick Chareka. The converse to Curtiss’ theorem for one-sided moment generating functions arXiv:0807.3392, 2008

work page internal anchor Pith review Pith/arXiv arXiv 2008
[6]

A. L. Yakymiv. A Generalization of the Curtiss Theorem for Moment Generating Functions.Math Notes, 90:920–924, 2011

work page 2011
[7]

The careless coupon collector’s problem

Emilio Cruciani and Aditi Dudeja. The careless coupon collector’s problem. arXiv:2602.20705, 2026

work page arXiv 2026
[8]

J. H. Curtiss. A note on the theory of moment generating functions.The Annals of Mathematical Statistics, 13(4):430–433, 1942. THE CLUMSY COUPON COLLECTOR’S PROBLEM 21

work page 1942
[9]

De mensura sortis seu; de probabilitate eventuum in ludis a casu fortuito pendentibus

Abraham de Moivre. De mensura sortis seu; de probabilitate eventuum in ludis a casu fortuito pendentibus. Philosophical Transactions, 27(329):213–264, 1712

work page
[10]

Doumas and Vassilis G

Aristides V. Doumas and Vassilis G. Papanicolaou. Asymptotics of the rising moments for the coupon collector’s problem.Electron. J. Probab., 18(41):1–15, 2012

work page 2012
[11]

Doumas and Vassilis G

Aristides V. Doumas and Vassilis G. Papanicolaou. The coupon collector’s problem revisited: Generalizing the double dixie cup problem of newman and shepp.ESAIM: PS, 20:367–399, 2016

work page 2016
[12]

On a classical problem of probability theory.A Magyar Tudomanyos Akademia Matematikai Kutato Intezetenek k¨ ozlem´ enyei, 6(1-2):215–220, 1961

P´ al Erd˝ os and Alfr´ ed R´ enyi. On a classical problem of probability theory.A Magyar Tudomanyos Akademia Matematikai Kutato Intezetenek k¨ ozlem´ enyei, 6(1-2):215–220, 1961

work page 1961
[13]

John Wiley & Sons, Inc

William Feller.An Introduction to Probability Theory and its Applications, volume 1 ofWiley Publications in Statistics. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. and Chapman & Hall, Ltd., New York and London, 1 edition, 1950

work page 1950
[14]

Birthday paradox, coupon collectors, caching algorithms and self-organizing search.Discrete Applied Mathematics, 39(3):207–229, 1992

Philippe Flajolet, Dani´ ele Gardy, and Jo¨ ys Thimonier. Birthday paradox, coupon collectors, caching algorithms and self-organizing search.Discrete Applied Mathematics, 39(3):207–229, 1992

work page 1992
[15]

H. J. Godwin. On cartophily and motor cars.The Mathematical Gazette, 33(305):169–171, 1949

work page 1949
[16]

Hald, Abraham de Moivre, and Bruce McClintock

A. Hald, Abraham de Moivre, and Bruce McClintock. A. de moivre: ‘de mensura sortis’ or ‘on the measurement of chance’.International Statistical Review, 52(3):229–262, 1984

work page 1984
[17]

Coupon collector problem with reset button.Mathematics, 12(2), 2024

Jelena Jockovi´ c and Bojana Todi´ c. Coupon collector problem with reset button.Mathematics, 12(2), 2024

work page 2024
[18]

Probability Theory and Stochastic Modelling

Olav Kallenberg.Foundations of Modern Probability. Probability Theory and Stochastic Modelling. Springer, Cham, 3 edition, 2021

work page 2021
[19]

Kuttler.Analysis of Functions of One Variable

Kenneth L. Kuttler.Analysis of Functions of One Variable. 2021

work page 2021
[20]

Christopher D. Long. Clumsy and careless: Stationary-entry flux in non-monotone coupon collectors, 2026. In preparation

work page 2026
[21]

F. G. Maunsell. A problem in cartophily.The Mathematical Gazette, 22(251):328–331, 1938

work page 1938
[22]

Myers and Herbert S

Amy N. Myers and Herbert S. Wilf. New aspects of the coupon collector’s problem.SIAM Review, 48(3):549– 565, 2006

work page 2006
[23]

Newman and Lawrence Shepp

Donald J. Newman and Lawrence Shepp. The double dixie cup problem.The American Mathematical Monthly, 67(1):58–61, 1960

work page 1960
[24]

Oldham, Jan Myland, and Jerome Spanier.An Atlas of Functions

Keit B. Oldham, Jan Myland, and Jerome Spanier.An Atlas of Functions. Springer, New York, 2 edition, 2009

work page 2009
[25]

Aus der spur des zufalls.Deutsches Statistisches Zentralblatt, 26:137–146, 1934

Hermann von Schelling. Aus der spur des zufalls.Deutsches Statistisches Zentralblatt, 26:137–146, 1934

work page 1934
[26]

Coupon collecting for unequal probabilities.The American Mathematical Monthly, 61(5):306–311, 1954

Hermann von Schelling. Coupon collecting for unequal probabilities.The American Mathematical Monthly, 61(5):306–311, 1954

work page 1954
[27]

Sums of derivatives of binomial coefficients.Advances in Applied Mathematics, 42:123–134, 2009

Anthony Sofo. Sums of derivatives of binomial coefficients.Advances in Applied Mathematics, 42:123–134, 2009

work page 2009
[28]

Cambridge Library Collection

Isaac Todhunter.A History of the Mathematical Theory of Probability. Cambridge Library Collection. Cam- bridge University Press, Cambridge

work page
[29]

George N. Watson. A postscript to Maunsell’s problem in cartophily.The Mathematical Gazette, 23(253):78–79, 1939

work page 1939
[30]

Wilf.generatingfunctionology

Herbert S. Wilf.generatingfunctionology. A K Peters/CRC Press, 3 edition, 2005

work page 2005
[31]

Wong.Asymptotic Approximations of Integrals

R. Wong.Asymptotic Approximations of Integrals. Classics in Applied Mathematics. SIAM, Philadelphia, 1989. Email address:luke.attrill@monash.edu Email address:tim.garoni@monash.edu School of Mathematics, Monash University, Clayton, 3800, VIC, Australia

work page 1989