Error estimation in astronomy: A guide
read the original abstract
Estimating errors is a crucial part of any scientific analysis. Whenever a parameter is estimated (model-based or not), an error estimate is necessary. Any parameter estimate that is given without an error estimate is meaningless. Nevertheless, many (undergraduate or graduate) students have to teach such methods for error estimation to themselves when working scientifically for the first time. This manuscript presents an easy-to-understand overview of different methods for error estimation that are applicable to both model-based and model-independent parameter estimates. These methods are not discussed in detail, but their basics are briefly outlined and their assumptions carefully noted. In particular, the methods for error estimation discussed are grid search, varying $\chi^2$, the Fisher matrix, Monte-Carlo methods, error propagation, data resampling, and bootstrapping. Finally, a method is outlined how to propagate measurement errors through complex data-reduction pipelines.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet.
Forward citations
Cited by 3 Pith papers
-
Spectral Handling and Estimation of AGN Parameters (SHEAP), The first AGN fitting GPU-based code
SHEAP introduces a GPU-accelerated JAX framework for AGN spectral decomposition that achieves ~100x speedup over pPXF with 85-100% parameter agreement within 0.3 dex on four test samples.
-
A comparison of methods for Poisson regression in the presence of background
Joint parametric fitting of source plus background yields unbiased parameters and valid Cash statistics, while wstat and fixed-background methods introduce significant bias in low-count regimes.
-
The Atacama Cosmology Telescope: stellar mass growth in massive galaxy clusters from DR5 over the past 7 billion years
Composite cluster stellar mass functions show marginal M* evolution at high z and a factor of 2.5 growth in stellar mass fraction from z=0.8 to 0.2 after accounting for halo mass growth.
discussion (0)
Sign in with ORCID, Apple, or X to comment. Anyone can read and Pith papers without signing in.