REVIEW 26 cited by
A comparison of Noether charge and Euclidean methods for Computing the Entropy of Stationary Black Holes
Not yet reviewed by Pith; the record is open.
This paper has not been read by Pith yet. Machine review is queued; the pith claim, tier, and objections will appear here once it completes.
SPECIMEN: schema-true, not a live event
T0 review · schema-true
One-sentence machine reading of the paper's core claim.
pith:XXXXXXXX · record.json · timestamp
Signed reviews
abstract
The entropy of stationary black holes has recently been calculated by a number of different approaches. Here we compare the Noether charge approach (defined for any diffeomorphism invariant Lagrangian theory) with various Euclidean methods, specifically, (i) the microcanonical ensemble approach of Brown and York, (ii) the closely related approach of Ba\~nados, Teitelboim, and Zanelli which ultimately expresses black hole entropy in terms of the Hilbert action surface term, (iii) another formula of Ba\~nados, Teitelboim and Zanelli (also used by Susskind and Uglum) which views black hole entropy as conjugate to a conical deficit angle, and (iv) the pair creation approach of Garfinkle, Giddings, and Strominger. All of these approaches have a more restrictive domain of applicability than the Noether charge approach. Specifically, approaches (i) and (ii) appear to be restricted to a class of theories satisfying certain properties listed in section 2; approach (iii) appears to require the Lagrangian density to be linear in the curvature; and approach (iv) requires the existence of suitable instanton solutions. However, we show that within their domains of applicability, all of these approaches yield results in agreement with the Noether charge approach. In the course of our analysis, we generalize the definition of Brown and York's quasilocal energy to a much more general class of diffeomorphism invariant, Lagrangian theories of gravity. In an appendix, we show that in an arbitrary diffeomorphism invariant theory of gravity, the ``volume term" in the ``off-shell" Hamiltonian associated with a time evolution vector field $t^a$ always can be expressed as the spatial integral of $t^a {\cal C}_a$, where ${\cal C}_a = 0$ are the constraints associated with the diffeomorphism invariance.
Forward citations
Cited by 26 Pith papers
-
Explicit and covariant formula for thermodynamic volume in extended black hole thermodynamics
An explicit covariant formula for thermodynamic volume is derived that universally decomposes into explicit Lagrangian coupling dependence plus dynamical field response contributions.
-
The entropy of bulk quantum fields and the entanglement wedge of an evaporating black hole
In a 2d evaporating black hole model, large boosts create O(1/G_N) gradients in bulk entropy that move the quantum extremal surface, causing the generalized entropy to follow unitary expectations with information disa...
-
Static Black Holes and Iyer-Wald Entropy in $f(\mathcal{R},\mathcal{K})$ Gravity
In f(R,K) gravity with f=-X^{1-n}, first-order Schwarzschild corrections yield Iyer–Wald entropy S = S_BH + λ Υ_n S_BH^{n+1}.
-
Large-$N$ Carrollian Thermodynamics from AdS Black-Hole Phase-Space Contractions
Finite Carrollian limit of extended AdS first law is reinterpreted as double-scaled large-N low-temperature holographic ensemble with finite products, new boundary stress tensor, and celestial correlator representations.
-
Black Hole Entropy Beyond the Wald Term in Nonminimally Coupled Gravity: A Covariant Phase Space Decomposition
Black hole entropy in diffeomorphism-invariant nonminimal gravity decomposes as S_H = S_W + S_1 + ΔS, with the extra terms required for bumblebee and Weyl-vector Gauss-Bonnet solutions but not for regular Kalb-Ramond ...
-
Sound as a gauge theory and its infrared triangle
Linear acoustic perturbations admit a memory effect that, in a dual Kalb-Ramond formulation, is encoded by large gauge transformations plus a monopole piece.
-
Modular Witten Diagrams and Quantum Extremality
Modular Witten diagrams reproduce the O(λ² G_N) correction to holographic entanglement entropy, matching the canonical energy term in the quantum Ryu-Takayanagi formula with wedge shape deformation.
-
Covariant phase space and the semi-classical Einstein equation
A semi-classical symplectic two-form is defined as the sum of the gravitational symplectic form and the Berry curvature of the quantum matter state; it is shown to be independent of the Cauchy slice and to satisfy a q...
-
The On-shell Gravity Action and Linear Dilaton Holography
The Euclidean on-shell action for linear-dilaton three-dimensional string backgrounds yields a spacetime mass whose square-root form matches the TT-deformed CFT energy formula.
-
Higher-curvature corrections and near horizon symmetries
Near-horizon supertranslation charges in Lovelock gravity are nested curvature invariants weighted by a supertranslation function, and in four dimensions they reduce to the Jackiw-Teitelboim action.
-
Localized Black Holes in AdS$_3$: What Happens Below c/12 Stays Below c/12
Localized black holes in AdS3 x S3 x T4 fill the low-energy spectrum, dominate the microcanonical ensemble below a small positive energy, and appear to have the same entanglement entropy as BTZ black holes.
-
Linearization (in)stabilities and crossed products
Second-order Taub charge constraints are justified as linearization stability conditions in spatially closed spacetimes, while in boundary or no-isometry cases the justification is weaker and depends on interest in se...
-
The First Law and Weak Cosmic Censorship for de Sitter Black Holes
An Iyer-Wald first law is established for general perturbations of Reissner-Nordstrom-de Sitter black holes, and a second-order Sorce-Wald argument shows that near-extremal such black holes cannot be overcharged under...
-
Quasi-local conserved charges in General Relativity
The paper constructs a general prescription for quasi-local conserved charges in GR and proposes the zero-mode BMS charge in Newman-Unti gauge as a quasi-local energy candidate.
-
Quasi-local energy and ADM mass in pure Lovelock gravity
In pure Lovelock gravity, the large-surface limit of the variation of Brown-York quasi-local energy equals the variation of the ADM mass, giving an explicit new mass formula.
-
Canonical quantization for effective theories with perturbations altering degrees of freedom: a covariant phase space approach
Covariant phase space formalism enables perturbative canonical quantization of higher-derivative perturbed theories, verified on a solvable 2D charged particle model where perturbative results match exact expansion.
-
Canonical quantization of the Pais-Uhlenbeck oscillator with a higher-derivative perturbation: a covariant phase space approach
A covariant phase-space perturbation scheme for the Pais-Uhlenbeck oscillator reproduces the exact low-energy spectrum and commutator while decoupling the Ostrogradsky ghost.
-
The Role of the Volume in Black Hole Thermodynamics
Conserved charges built from a Kerr-Schild background show the first law requires the Killing vector and AdS background to be held fixed, explaining why the rotating-frame energy F fails while E works, and why the geo...
-
The entropy of black hole under second-order deviation from equilibrium
The entropy of a dynamical black hole equals the area of its apparent horizon at second order in perturbations when the null energy condition holds.
-
Asymptotic Algebras and Holography of Information in CGHS Model
Establishes holography of information in the CGHS model via asymptotic algebras and argues that islands violate commutativity of left- and right-boundary algebras.
-
Validity of the Background Subtraction Method for Black Hole Thermodynamics in Matter-Coupled Gravity Theories
Background subtraction for black hole thermodynamics is valid and equivalent to Iyer-Wald in matter-coupled gravity theories, with smooth performance in examples but subtleties for certain matter fields.
-
Exact Black Hole Solutions in Bumblebee Gravity with Lightlike or Spacelike VEVS
New exact Schwarzschild-like, (A)dS-like, and charged black holes in bumblebee gravity with a two-component vector VEV keep Lorentz-violating corrections even when the VEV is lightlike, with Wald and first-law entropi...
-
Violating Weak Cosmic Censorship in AdS$_3$ via Gedanken Experiment
Under the test-particle approximation, an extremal quantum-corrected BTZ black hole can have its horizon destroyed by a particle with large angular momentum, giving a potential counterexample to weak cosmic censorship.
-
Dynamical black hole entropy beyond general relativity from the Einstein frame
For f(R) and scalar-tensor gravity, the dynamical black hole entropy formula is rederived via conformal frames and shown to equal the Wald entropy of a generalized apparent horizon.
-
Lectures on the Bondi--Metzner--Sachs group and related topics in infrared physics
Lecture notes that build the BMS group from prerequisites to applications in soft theorems, memory effects, and new material on asymptotic conformal Killing horizons.
-
Emergent Gravity in a Holographic Universe
Causal diamonds in symmetric spacetimes obey a thermodynamic first law with negative temperature, and the Einstein equations can be recast as an entropy equilibrium condition, with a long-string CFT picture for non-Ad...
Discussion (0). Continue with ORCID to comment.